Forgive me if this should be a new thread, but I have a question about Carson. He clearly has no knowledge about the federal government and how it works (e.g. the disastrous Marketplace interview about the debt ceiling) and he doesn't seem to have any knowledge about international affairs, foreign leaders, etc. If he wants to be president, what on earth has he done to prepare himself for the job? |
and some people think that you can commit suicide by flying a plane into heavily occupied office buildings, killing thousands of innocent people and 7 virgins will be waiting to fuck you in heaven. But we won't go there as it would be politically incorrect-just keep hurling rocks at Carson-I would love to see any of you accomplish what he has to date. He has more integrity in his pinky finger than most. |
Are you suggesting that you would support a suicidal hijacker for President? I guess you would have to because it is so important to you that religious beliefs be respected. Call me intolerant, but I think if you believe flying a plane into a building will send you to heaven, you have disqualified yourself for an elected position. |
OK... I'm going to speak S L O W L Y so you understand. Freeman revived the procedure from a theoretical sense. He did not perform the procedure. He could not hand it off because he never performed it in the first place. Freeman thought it was worth a shot, he studied what others had done and had some thoughts on how to refine the procedure from what was done in the past. Carson was the one willing to take the risk and perform the surgery. They worked closely together to plan the case, Carson executed it - flawlessly. Carson never indicated Freeman was on the periphery, you chose to read that into it because its what you believe. |
If you take these extreme nonsense positions to argue your point in real life, I truly feel sorry for your wife. |
I agree, he needs to go out and be a community organizer for a while. He was on faculty at Hopkins so he's got that piece covered. |
Yeah but he started getting hemispherectomies for his patients in the late 60s when he returned to Hopkins. Hopkins was doing them on an ongoing basis. Carson only got there in 1984. So the neurosurgeons there has been doing the procedure for 15 years before he set foot there. So yes, he was building on a long body of prior work. |
Well it would go against the constitution wouldn't it? It is a dilemma-though there are certain religions which wholeheartedly support such things. Carson agrees yhey should be disqualified to run as POTUS. |
I'm mocking the poster, not arguing. How would you respond to someone who believes we are too PC to criticize suicidal hijackers? |
Uhuh. Einstein also came up with relativity in a theoretical sense. I suppose that's why it's called "Einstein's theory of relativity", not "whatshisname who found experimental evidence for it's theory." We know Carson has deft fingers--good at videogames and all. No one denies that. |
Which religion wholeheartedly supports such things? Where does the Constitution say that specific individuals can't be disqualified? You seem to be unable to distinguish between individuals and entire religions. |
Well some people believe an angel got a woman pregnant without touching her.
So believing weird or even impossible things is not a disqualification from the Presidency. But yes Jeff, it's nuts and disturbing. And conservatives won't care. |
By your logic neither should receive credit. The first hemispherectomy was performed by a German doctor on a dog in the late 1800's. Prior to Carson, the procedure was plagued with poor surgical outcomes, primarily mortality and complications caused by hydrocephalus. You do realize this is not a common surgery right? Over a twenty year period of time I think it was just under 50 or 60 patients that qualified. |
Well, you occasionally come across that PC. Just sayin... But you probably think I'm a banana shy of a bunch. ![]() |
Is anyone bothered that Carson thinks Joseph built the pyramids, when he came around 1000 years after the pharaohs and 300 years after Egypt had been conquered by the Greeks? |