The PP argues that money is the reason why she’s a better parent. It’s not. Yes, affluent schools have better test scores. We know this. But there are many reasons for that, including test questions that are skewed against students in other districts (like sailing terminology in a low-income city school). Affluent parents also pay for additional tutoring, obviously. The data doesn’t show that students succeed because of better parenting. It’s simply more targeted opportunity. And why the heck did you bring affirmative action into an argument about parenting? We’re in a different lane here. |
80k twenty years ago would be almost 150k in today’s money. |
There is plenty of creditable research totally accessible that show higher income parents ARE in fact spending more time on actual parenting. It’s not all the tutors. I took my child to museums, planned interesting activities, travels, personally coached and tutored. I was afforded all this time with my child because I had money and job flexibility. |
|
Higher income parents generally spend more time on active parenting and quality time with their kids. Education and success truly begins with the family
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.22.3.23#:~:text=The%20paper%20uses%20data%20from%20the%20American,nonworking%20and%20working%20mothers%20and%20working%20fathers. |
I would love to see your research that proves wealthier parents are better parents. I’m not going to take the time to look for it because I doubt it exists. Sure, they can easily provide more opportunities or outsource parenting jobs to others. However, that is not —better parenting—. I am not wealthy, nor do I have a lot of job flexibility. That doesn’t stop me from taking my children to free museums, national parks, or a myriad of other opportunities when we are home together. That doesn’t stop me from reading with them and helping with homework. My time is extremely limited, but my children are my priority. They are far more important to me than money, actually. |
We are not telling about YOU. We talk about general trends. You were provided research already. But great for you to be an exception from a general trend that money in fact result in more quality time with kids |
DP. Wish I could see the looks on all the nannies’ faces as they read that. |
Yeah, I read your research. I stopped at page 9 when it was clear to me that the report mainly argues that the parent’s acquired education level has a bearing on time spent with children. That doesn’t prove the PP’s argument that money alone makes one a better parent. Plenty of well-educated people are in lower paying professions. I’m also not sure why PPs even need this to be true. How is it threatening that somebody without your means is also able to raise successful, well- adjusted adults? |
If you’re busy struggling to pay the rent you generally don’t have the bandwidth to read about child development, feel calm when your kid misbehaves, eat and sleep in a way that supports your and your family’s wellbeing, etc. Money gives you more choices. Everyone is dealing with myriad aspects of their current environment, environment they were brought up in, and physiological/psychological environments. Money makes everything easier. To say it doesn’t is dishonest. |
DP. Wait, are we still talking about people who make $250k? |
|
Folks, no one who makes 250k on one salary is "struggling to pay the rent." This conversation has gone off the rails.
The OP's question reminds me of a line from Fleishman is in Trouble: "Excuse me, I make almost $300,000 a year. I am a rich man in every single culture except the 40 stupid square blocks that you insist we live within." Other than a narrow swath of people who don't come from money but want the trappings of it (multiple houses in high COL areas, kids at very expensive privates, lots of expensive foreign travel, designer everything, etc.), most people would be THRILLED with a salary of 250k, or to marry someone with that salary. If most people you encounter find it disappointing, you should ask yourself why you are self-selecting into that narrow group. |
Being raised surrounded by wealth and privilege has downsides, too. To say it doesn’t is also dishonest. |
I find this hard to believe. Can someone confirm this? I thought doctors made pretty good money, even primary care, especially the ones with their own practice. |
lol. Sure, pick your poison, PP. |
I’m the PP. No, absolutely not. 250k is a good salary. People on this board are stupid and out of touch. I’m not saying it gives you a lush lifestyle in NW DC, but you’re doing great. |