Trump govt is deporting Green Card holder student exercising free speech

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

DP

Israel as a nation state was forged and continues to subsist on an endless diet of welfare and conflict.

The fact that you suggest otherwise would be laughable if it wasn’t so jarring in its detachment from reality.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

"And it's so nice that someone like Riley Gaines, who seems to have no marketable skills can find work talking it up on the American conservative media circuit. That's America for you."

Funny you mention Riley Gaines in a thread about immigration. She claims her Irish husband can't get a green card because he refuses to get a Covid shot. I hope he gets deported and takes her with him. He probably won't since she's on Trump's good side. Different rules for MAGA.

https://www.newsweek.com/riley-gaines-husband-covid-vaccine-green-card-1987894" target="_new" rel="nofollow"> https://www.newsweek.com/riley-gaines-husband-covid-vaccine-green-card-1987894

Did her Irish boyfriend incite violent student protests supporting a terrorist organization after a history of working for them?

Khalil served as a political affairs officer with UNRWA — a UN agency that supports Palestinian refugees — which was stripped of tens of millions in federal funding after an explosive report that some of its members took part in the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack against Israel in which 1,200 people were killed.

For those who would like a different take in the NYpost article quoted by PP, this link offers one as well as some of the legal issues
https://cis.org/Arthur/ICE-Arrests-Palestinian-Activist

But PP left off the paragraph previous to what they quoted, for obvious reasons

"Khalil — who did his undergraduate degree in Beirut — told the Columbia Daily Spectator that he has not participated in any of the protests over the past week and a half because he is worried about losing his student visa that allows him to remain in the US.

Khalil was a political affairs officer with UNRWA — the United Nations’ agency that supports Palestinian refugees — from June through November 2023, according to LinkedIn.

UNRWA lost hundreds of millions of dollars in funding earlier this year when an Israeli dossier suggested that agency workers were linked to the Oct. 7 terror attack.

Earlier this week, an Independent Review Group announced that a nine-week probe found a lack of serious evidence that the group had legitimate connections with Hamas."

Just because he claimed he had not participated in the protest does not mean it is true. And an organizer can stay in the wings while the mayhem unfolds.
And look at the timing.
Per the linked article, he was "worrying" about the student visa in April 2024. In February 2025 he has a Green card by marriage and a heavily pregnant wife. This means that he was already married or about to get married (shotgun? LOL), so would not be needing a student vise for much longer.
So I would allow that Khalil is not being entirely truthful, in the article and elsewhere.

And yet the organization he was involved with was investigated and cleared of wrongdoing.

If he participated in the protests, that is nkt illegal. Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean he can't protest. Not everyone who protested was involved in anything that was illegal.

The burden is to prove that he did something illegal, not just that he was involved in protests. And no, I don't count camping out in the middle of campus as illegal. Has that been declared yet?

He violated the terms of his green card. Support for terrorist organizations is a deal breaker for those who seek the *privilege* of US citizenship.

Democrats loved to say free speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequences.

FAFO.

Once again, I’d like to explain that the whole point of 1A is those consequences can’t come from the government.

The law on first amendment issues is not nearly this clear when it comes to alleged terroristic threats made by non-citizens.

Alleged is the word

Also, though non citizen, he has rights on the level of a citizen

What were these threats? They would have to actually come from his mouth. And random threats aren't enough. Otherwise Steve bannin would be in jail

He was serving as a mediator for the group that had taken over a building on campus. Extortion, do what we say or things get worse.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

Where are the nuclear vassals?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

DP

Israel as a nation state was forged and continues to subsist on an endless diet of welfare and conflict.

The fact that you suggest otherwise would be laughable if it wasn’t so jarring in its detachment from reality.

And literally any other country in the world is different how?

I suppose you are going to tell me how awesome Saudi Arabia is now. 🙄

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

"And it's so nice that someone like Riley Gaines, who seems to have no marketable skills can find work talking it up on the American conservative media circuit. That's America for you."

Funny you mention Riley Gaines in a thread about immigration. She claims her Irish husband can't get a green card because he refuses to get a Covid shot. I hope he gets deported and takes her with him. He probably won't since she's on Trump's good side. Different rules for MAGA.

https://www.newsweek.com/riley-gaines-husband-covid-vaccine-green-card-1987894" target="_new" rel="nofollow"> https://www.newsweek.com/riley-gaines-husband-covid-vaccine-green-card-1987894

Did her Irish boyfriend incite violent student protests supporting a terrorist organization after a history of working for them?

Khalil served as a political affairs officer with UNRWA — a UN agency that supports Palestinian refugees — which was stripped of tens of millions in federal funding after an explosive report that some of its members took part in the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack against Israel in which 1,200 people were killed.

For those who would like a different take in the NYpost article quoted by PP, this link offers one as well as some of the legal issues
https://cis.org/Arthur/ICE-Arrests-Palestinian-Activist

But PP left off the paragraph previous to what they quoted, for obvious reasons

"Khalil — who did his undergraduate degree in Beirut — told the Columbia Daily Spectator that he has not participated in any of the protests over the past week and a half because he is worried about losing his student visa that allows him to remain in the US.

Khalil was a political affairs officer with UNRWA — the United Nations’ agency that supports Palestinian refugees — from June through November 2023, according to LinkedIn.

UNRWA lost hundreds of millions of dollars in funding earlier this year when an Israeli dossier suggested that agency workers were linked to the Oct. 7 terror attack.

Earlier this week, an Independent Review Group announced that a nine-week probe found a lack of serious evidence that the group had legitimate connections with Hamas."

Just because he claimed he had not participated in the protest does not mean it is true. And an organizer can stay in the wings while the mayhem unfolds.
And look at the timing.
Per the linked article, he was "worrying" about the student visa in April 2024. In February 2025 he has a Green card by marriage and a heavily pregnant wife. This means that he was already married or about to get married (shotgun? LOL), so would not be needing a student vise for much longer.
So I would allow that Khalil is not being entirely truthful, in the article and elsewhere.

And yet the organization he was involved with was investigated and cleared of wrongdoing.

If he participated in the protests, that is nkt illegal. Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean he can't protest. Not everyone who protested was involved in anything that was illegal.

The burden is to prove that he did something illegal, not just that he was involved in protests. And no, I don't count camping out in the middle of campus as illegal. Has that been declared yet?

He violated the terms of his green card. Support for terrorist organizations is a deal breaker for those who seek the *privilege* of US citizenship.

Democrats loved to say free speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequences.

FAFO.

Once again, I’d like to explain that the whole point of 1A is those consequences can’t come from the government.

The law on first amendment issues is not nearly this clear when it comes to alleged terroristic threats made by non-citizens.

Alleged is the word

Also, though non citizen, he has rights on the level of a citizen

What were these threats? They would have to actually come from his mouth. And random threats aren't enough. Otherwise Steve bannin would be in jail

He was serving as a mediator for the group that had taken over a building on campus. Extortion, do what we say or things get worse.

Why was a creepy 30-year-old representing teenagers anyhow? Weird.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

DP

Israel as a nation state was forged and continues to subsist on an endless diet of welfare and conflict.

The fact that you suggest otherwise would be laughable if it wasn’t so jarring in its detachment from reality.

And literally any other country in the world is different how?

I suppose you are going to tell me how awesome Saudi Arabia is now. 🙄

No a lot of other countries are made with alliances but not the hand outs and special treatment Israel got

- don't have a dog in this fight but facts

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

DP

Israel as a nation state was forged and continues to subsist on an endless diet of welfare and conflict.

The fact that you suggest otherwise would be laughable if it wasn’t so jarring in its detachment from reality.

And literally any other country in the world is different how?

I suppose you are going to tell me how awesome Saudi Arabia is now. 🙄

No a lot of other countries are made with alliances but not the hand outs and special treatment Israel got

- don't have a dog in this fight but facts

Oh come on. Pretty much all of Europe exists on welfare now.

Look, I want to wash my hands of this whole region but I am so sick of the ridiculous drama.

[Anonymous]

https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2025/3/14/us-arrests-second-student-imposes-receivership-on-columbia-university


Second student taken into custody.

Palestinian protester at Columbia.

Student canceled in 2022. It was canceled due to lack of attendance.

This one I am good with.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

are you kidding? Do you think a British emigre doesn't complain about the US or an ally of the US, ie support of Sinn Fein and a united Ireland?

False equivalence.

He wasn't just "complaining." He was publicly demonstrating and signing his name to statements supporting a designated terrorist organization.

That is not illegal

What some of you don’t seem to understand is that even if he is released and allowed to remain for now, the Department of State can simply not remove the provisional component of his green card and allow it expire. They don’t need a reason that you agree with. So whether he’s deported now or a year from now, he’s done.

And a good thing, too.

Yes it is just the start. The pro Israeli crowd has a long list of people they want arrested and replaced with loyal pro Israeli. America, what’s it like to become a vessel state to Israel?

Keep taking those ESL classes. The word is "vassal", not "vessel".

That aside, it's just fine. Both countries abhor people who subsist exclusively on handouts, who support and engage in terror, and who are incapable of peaceful coexistence.

DP

Israel as a nation state was forged and continues to subsist on an endless diet of welfare and conflict.

The fact that you suggest otherwise would be laughable if it wasn’t so jarring in its detachment from reality.

And literally any other country in the world is different how?

I suppose you are going to tell me how awesome Saudi Arabia is now. 🙄

GTFOH … nobody reprises the role of welfare queen like Israel.

[Anonymous]

The man was never arrested by NYPD was he? I only see a picture of him standing by a tree . I don’t see any evidence that he was anything worse than the other rabble rousers and protestors

[Anonymous]

However, by pinpointing the Palestinian protestors rather than anyone else, Israel is kinda proving their point about apartheid

[Anonymous]

I am sure Khalil is not the first random detainment in his family

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

He is a political operative meant to sow division and chaos. And it worked until January 20th.

Exactly. Probably got a full free ride based on the kindness of alumni donations, many of whom are Jewish. His actions demonstrate that he is clearly an agent of some sort and he must have lied on his visa application, checked “no” on the support of terrorism question.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:56 pages and yet it should be evident that if the U.S. doesn't want this guy here, he's not going to stay here and will be deported.

What's puzzling, and still unaddressed, is why he came here to complain about Israel. You'd think he'd be happier in Syria, or Gaza, or the West Bank, or as part of the Israeli political opposition. To come to the U.S. to complain about a U.S. ally, on behalf of people who don't live in the U.S., is inexplicable. No sane person would think that leading protests in the way he did, for the cause he represents, would actually result in a change in U.S. foreign policy.

Oh, well, I'm sure he'll be happier in a more receptive environment like Gaza.

He is a political operative meant to sow division and chaos. And it worked until January 20th.

Exactly. Probably got a full free ride based on the kindness of alumni donations, many of whom are Jewish. His actions demonstrate that he is clearly an agent of some sort and he must have lied on his visa application, checked “no” on the support of terrorism question.

Speaking of agent, which GOPerative are you, playing the tired game of making accusations with nothing backing them up?