OP, I'm so sorry. I'm the poster who suggested these allegations of phone theft might be a pretext to harass and threaten your son. Unfortunately it sounds like this is the case. You're doing the right thing by advocating for your son. Being in physical danger isn't the same thing as telling the waiter you ordered the pasta when he brought you the chicken. |
There is a big difference between elementary or middle school kids and a high school senior. These are basically adults. |
While they are 17/18 years old, they are still youths and still in school. And even if this were college or a first job, it is outrageous that this kind of conduct is acceptable or event expected. Kids are required by law to be in school, it needs to be a safe place. The fact that this is school limits the option of a student to protect him or herself. |
Really? You think Black kids are more at risk? You don't think white kids in a prediminately black school, likely located in a rough neighborhood, have it rough? Are you in fantasy land? This is the reason why many families either avoid DC school like the plague, or they do everything in their power to avoid particular schools. I don't blame them at all. |
Mediation is not a good idea, given the threats, intimidation and attempts at violence. I would go directly to the protective order stage and hope things will cool off after graduation. GL |
Of course they do. Any kid , black or white, who do not resort to violence and threats to solve their problems have it rough in an environment where this is a common tool. The threat of "being jumped" would significantly raise these childrens stress levels, and we know there is a lot of fallout from that. Or they might decide if they cant bday em join em. Where is DCPS with its SEL initiative? Sadly they cant start IN the home, but a healthy enough school culture is something at least. |
This does seem like a big fear of white families regarding predominantly black schools. I can tell you that I attended them myself, and white kids were NOT targeted. They seem to stay out of a lot of stuff. Also, our IB school is predominately AA and my kid’s white classmates seem to love it just as much as anyone else. |
|
Most of the comments seem to come from suburbanites that thought living in the city would be cool. This type of situation happens a lot in middle and high school. You can't protect your son forever so seek a solution versus avoidance. Say you keep him home the rest of the year. What happens if he's out somewhere and encounters the kid again? It will be very ugly. So it's now or later!
If the school says there hands are tied, reaching out to the parents is your best option right now. It is already at a boiling point so either he fights the kid(s) or mediation. Going thru all the DCPS red tape is an option but won't help right now. You want an immediate solution. A friend went thru the exact same thing and she reached out the parents. They had no idea what was going on and immediately diffused the situation. Still pursue the DCPS options in tandem so the parents know the seriousness of the situation. |
You're making assumptions about the parents. Sometimes, the parents are unaware and would intervene if notified. It's entirely possible that one of these kids is simply trying to fit in with a new crowd. I'm also speaking from experience. My kid was targeted by a classmate and the parents intervened once notified. I've also been on the other side of the coin. In this case, the other parents knew but did not bring it to my attention. I would have corrected the behavior sooner if I'd been notified. |
That's great that you're so optimistic, but the positive outcomes in your situation may not happen in all. Speaking from experience, many kids who fight a lot come from ROUGH backgrounds themselves. The parents may react negatively and may see it as an attack on their kid. Tread carefully if you try this approach. |
| Why do the kids think he took the phone? Maybe he did. |
I don't think you have any experience of this topic. Black kids are much more at risk. If you look at crime statistics, this is also true of adults -- being white makes you less likely to be a victim of crime. I went to rough a rough, poor all white middle school. I fought almost daily and often carried a knife outside of school. Two guys who used to jump me for fun went to jail for manslaughter soon after high school graduation. My parents moved, and I went to a rough majority black high school. I was never once in a fight or bullied or threatened. It was like I was assumed to be an un-involved bystander in the fighting that went on, which I was happy to be. My impression talking to parents at my kid's majority non-white high school is that parents of color have much more to be concerned about in terms of peer pressure and fighting than my white kid. He's assumed to be a bystander and, as he says, if he doesn't look for trouble he has none. |
How old are your kids? I'm guessing elementary school. This is questionable advice for elementary kids. For 17/18 year olds it's loony. |
My point was that 17/18 year olds are much more able to hurt each other than elementary school kids, so I don't think OP overreacted. |
So, why did you even mention an Uber? |