+1. I don't think Tufts is a good school. Maybe it has improved but it's always been a Vanderbilt-eque school in my mind. A private, expensive, mid-range school for kids that want to stay private. Think SMU. So I'd prefer any of the public schools in the area - UMD, UVA, VaTech, W&M, etc. over Tufts any day. I don't see the draw. Maybe Ivies are worth the sticker shock but even then I think they're overpriced. You're paying for the name brand, OP. You can get better deals and state schools. But most people want prestige so they buy the Audi even though the Toyota lasts much longer for 1/2 the price. |
đź’Ż |
We can only pray… |
So you haven’t reported me? Whatcha waiting for? I mean someone who disagrees with you should be immediately banned. For life. |
Vanderbilt vs. UMD/VaTech/W&M vs Tufts? Major dependent i think? For a humanities/Econ type major… For my kids, I’d pick: Vanderbilt Tufts UMD/VT/W&M |
I would disagree. Most Vandy / Tufts grads that I know have been middle of the road type students. Nothing stellar but still go on to have good careers. I have not seen anything impressive from either school - which leads me to believe that they're not worth the money. Admittedly, I am biased. I graduated from a big state school and paid significantly less to now out earn many of my private school friends. Subjective? Yes, but I've not seen these private unis earn their tuition rates. |
I’m thinking about cohort. People admitted in the last 2 to 3 years. That is your cohort. |
If the outcome for a middle of the road student is a good career, how does that compare to the average Florida State or Michigan State grad (to use to previous schools posited as comparable) |
It was never elite. More like semi-elite |
That was my point. The results from Vanderbilt or Tufts are no different than a solid state school like Fl St, M St, or similar. So why pay more? Not worth it. |
Tufts is not semi-elite either. NYU would be semi-elite. Tufts is a target school for most kids. |
| This is a silly discussion: it you think it's worth it and have the funds to pay for it, by all means have your child apply. If not, don't let them |
^^this is NOT OP btw. |
But those results are the same as Ivy's. I mean, people go to college and then they have careers. A handful go on to be a supreme court justice or something, but that is very rare, even for elite schools. |
Not meaning to be mean - you want a leg up on admissions AND money because your kid is good at their sport? It's not new information that college is expensive and that sports recruiting to small privates often comes with no money - but an admissions bump. I know this and my kid isn't in sports. |