Forum Index
»
Money and Finances
India does not provide free education except in special government schools in elementary levels. Education, housing and food costs are very high in India. In any case, it is very hard to get into college in India because there is no endless supply of colleges and community colleges like US. In fact, it is surprising to me that Americans do not utilize the free resources that is available in this country. Isn't it amazing that free education is available from K-12 to all kids in US but most of them will waste this opportunity and come to school only to be badly behaved and disruptive. This is the kind of wastage that kills me because around the world poor kids want to go to school but they do not have the opportunity. |
POC is the color of skin. Not the bank balance. |
But you don't get to claim the same degree of white atonement as African Americans, Native Americans or Brown Hispanics, which obviously bothers you.. |
And you can't claim how systemic racism stopped you from achieving financial and even political success. Indians have surpassed another "model minority" - East Asians in breaking through that "white ceiling" to the highest power positions in Fortune 500 companies, and even politics. But YOU specifically still don't feel "high caste" enough? How so? |
|
I do think that one of the things that especially immigrant pocs need to come to terms with is that along the journey for African Americans in this country there have been plenty of times where African Americans have been successful and at each turn white Americans made sure to knock them back down.
I mean you can look all the way back to the Northwest Territory which would be modern day Illinois Ohio and Michigan. Which was essentially deemed to be free of slavery and so that frontier became a huge settlement area for free African Americans including those who paid for their freedom and the freedom of their family members. There were very successful farmers some of which were able to accumulate wealth and large amounts of land. And they were decimated within 30 to 50 years. It wouldn't it was a slow claw back of items like requiring a $500 bond to be placed for each family member. Allowing for bounty hunters to enter states after the passage of the fugitive slave act and then taking children working in fields, etc. Many successful Farmers tried to move to other areas and some even moved to Canada. Fast forward to civil war reconstruction, tulsa race massacre, axle race in FL, Jim Crow laws redlining not allowing students of color to be admitted to colleges or universities. Charging higher interest rates just because of race. The war on drugs I mean if you compare the heroin crisis to cocaine opioids and weed it's a ridiculous comparison because the former was mostly centralized to inner City areas that were predominantly black and the latter three are predominantly white people's drugs of choice. Even the rhetoric around reasoning of drug use for cocaine weed MDMA and opioids is completely different than the rhetoric around heroin/crack. Your experience- and/or your families experience- coming here as a first generation with an education in the 1950s to 2000s is quite ridiculous. They aren't comparable. My DH, who is black, was traveling with coworkers- one of whom was Muslim. When they were going through security he said to him, in here I'm Public enemy number 1 but out there it's you. And they had a good laugh. That's probably one comparison that sticks. |
All the Indians I know in this country who came as adults were educated there and were at least middle class if not UMC. poorer Indians seem to have come in earlier immigration waves. Their kids are educated in the USA. What I know about those who are 1st gen immigrants of the last 25 years is that by far and large they had access to education in India and were connected enough to get to work in the USA (or to be foreign students here). They outnumber Indian kids of uneducated parents who went to school here when it comes to tech field specifically. Maybe it's different in medicine |
Thanks to NP. Immediate PP, I don’t waste time explaining shit to stupid people. If you didn’t go to IIT we are not of the same caliber and you need to shut up and learn. |
Again, you’re not of my caliber. I don’t explain to first gen who didn’t go to IIT. |
So your take is that wealthy Black people aren’t POC? Wealthy Hispanic people are not POC? You think POC = poor. |
I don't understand what the point of your post is. Did you get the answers you were looking for? Are you expecting to have the doors shut in your face because you are POC? What exactly is behind your question on overcoming racism? You aren't applying for a job 50 years ago.. |
You forget America’s racist policy towards Indians. They don’t let in the uneducated ones. Remember the Asian Exclusion Act? When we weren’t even allowed to immigrate. Then they opened up immigration but only to educated Asians in science and technology fields. When you only let in the educated from a certain group, then obviously you aren’t going to have the poor and uneducated from that region. Then obviously those that were educated enough to get the golden visa to immigrate are going to be successful. If the fail, they lose their green card. They have to be successful. And you think immigrants that had to prove themselves that much to be accepted in this country are not going to push their kids to excel too? Canada, UK, Australia- they don’t have Indian ‘model minorities’ because they allow immigration of Indians of different SES or ‘caste’ as you all like to dramatize. It’s the US that upholds this casteism is by not allowing poor, uneducated Indians immigration allowance. |
It's not an unpopular opinion that there are privileged Blacks and Indigenous people. Black kids who grew up in well-off households and with educated parents had a leg up. Some feel uncomfortable claiming their experience is related to poor kids stuck in generational poverty due to systemic racism. Why don't you think harder and tell me what "POC" means in the context that OP is describing. This is obviously not about skin color alone, but about identity, and identity that could lead to certain discrimination and denial of equal opportunity to build wealth. Had Indians been denied opportunity to build wealth in a systemic way? Recent wave of Indian immigrants were ushered into the US straight into the industry where the high paying jobs are. How are they wronged exactly? |
I know my own relatives who came here without much education in 1960s. They did low skill jobs and their kids delivered newspapers, sold concessions at movie halls, drove taxis, delivered pizza, worked in McDonalds and availed of the free education in public schools and community college to now have homes in Potomac. Educated here and belonging to parents who were not even fluent in English. One lady of that generation never learned English, never learned how to drive a car, never had a paying job and could not communicate to others outside her family. |
What group of poor uneducated people does US allow to enter with the exception of those crossing our Southern Border? And how exactly did uneducated Indians who worked low wage jobs and ran small businesses arrive decades ago? To immigrate legally from any country you have to have some family here or win Green Card lottery or be sponsored by your employer or a school. Over the last 3 decades you were given advantage over other immigrant groups because tech industry decided to choose India as its hub for outsourcing. This fueled demand on education and to start churning eligible candidates, which certainly didn't hurt India's economy not to mention didn't hurt your chances getting here and building successful lives as educated professionals. Sorry your ancestors didn't arrive in Slave ships, lived under Jim Crow, or had their land stolen, so that you can enjoy the "white guilt". You think whites wronged you and owe you? |
OK, this isn't really that different from experience of many immigrants who arrived back then, immigrants of various ethnicities and skin tones from all over the world. Those from South America and Eastern Europe and China, etc. |