Yes, it is absurd to believe that any sort of club rec curriculum at 5-7 years old is anything more than playing sharks and minnows mixed with some cone dribbling drills followed by a scrimmage and a hearty juice box. You will find no program at this age that offers more than introductory fun. You also fail to take into account the tremendous player turnover that occurs over the years. Half the kids playing at that age will not even bother to pursue travel soccer not to mention stick with the club through the entirety of their “curriculum” through U19. The ECNL team at U13 will likely be turned over by 50% before U15. But by all means worry about college commitments at a club, one of which is younger than your own DD, before you even know if she is even good at soccer. Yeah, you’re a clown. Neither club is even 19 years old themselves and you want to know how they follow through on their curriculum. Lol. |
+1 |
While maybe a little harsh to hear for some, that last post was 100% true. |
VDA has one top 3 team in ECNL Midatlatic division. Unless your DD is in the same age group as that team, I would steer clear from VDA. |
You are right, nothing looks the same from U13 to U19, next year a new big merger with great propaganda will be drawing all your top players. It is what it is. Good Luck. |
NC courage u19 are 9th, committed players… UNC Florida State Wake Forest Louisville NC State Davidson South Florida Fordham Charlotte Mason Minnesota Georgia UNC Wilmington Duke VT |
You’re a clown. At least don’t make it obvious. You have no clue the level of competition faced day in and day out. Back to back double header weekends. Ask Arlington 04. They were third last year in GA Mid-Atlantic. They’re 14 this year in ECNL Mid-Atlantic. Winless. And it doesn’t get easier the older you get. It’s much harder because of the built in filter to push kids out. It’s are hard pill to swallow but it’s a fact. Lace up your boots and zip up your mouth. For you 06-09 parents. Take a look around. Most of your teammates will be replaced. |
I’m not denigrating anybody. Those aren’t easy programs to make - and stay in. I don’t claim to have it all figured out, but some of this is easy to figure out. If you think your kid is going to get what they need in terms of soccer training/education/curriculum from either A) a club led by a guy who spent his college years playing soccer, but not for his college team, for the club team or B) a club led by a guy who spent his college years playing, not soccer, but records for the college radio station, you’re way, way off target. They are just clubs with teams and platforms. Learning the game happens elsewhere. |
|
From what I’ve seen across several age groups and over a period of time here’s my advice at a club level At the ECNL OR GA level (since we don’t know the exact age of your daughter).
1) Union (overall best coaching NM and CW and solid college connections) 2) VDA or Arlington (pick the one that you live closest to) 3) BRYC (coaching actually seems decent but players tend to be weaker) or FCV (used to be good and still are at older ages but that ship is sinking now. Coaching has some pockets of goodness, but league is not great) 5) Loudoun (and my kid plays there. Poor coaching and not a lot of good college connections. Well run administratively.) |
There is little doubt that if parents were smart enough to recognize a good curriculum that the clubs providing it would thrive. And for the most part, this happens. The clubs reviewed above are among the best. The trouble with all of them, is that they struggle to remain consistent with it. There are lots of reasons. There is a significant shortage of quality coaching. Good U8 coaches are not necessarily good U15 coaches. There is often a lack of integrity in club management. Pay to play youth soccer has a built in conflict of interest between generating income and providing great coaching. That generally means alot of turnover. The reality is you have to re-evaluate your club every year as a result. |
Finally, something helpful and not condescending. Thank you |
+10,000 Most people assume the club that has put themselves on top of the chain will have the best coaches. Don't agree with this as I have seen many teams well trained outside of the big clubs. |
It sounds like VDA. They replaced their 07 and older team players with several players from surrounding small clubs, yet this club makes a lot of noise bragging that they have strong feeder pools. |
This is FCVs business model! Note, business not soccer |