Fairfax County Double Murder

[Anonymous]

Are we allowed to being in laptops outside the courtroom? (not media.)

[Anonymous]

Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

[Anonymous]

Can someone post a link? Are there any graphic photos to avoid?

Thats interesting, maybe BB wanted to walk into a rape scene and, I don't know, accidentally shoot her while saving her?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Can someone post a link? Are there any graphic photos to avoid?

Thats interesting, maybe BB wanted to walk into a rape scene and, I don't know, accidentally shoot her while saving her?

https://webcache.fairfaxcounty.gov/circuitcourt/Evidence%20Admitted%20January%2013%2C%202026/CW%2067%20UNSEALED%20%20ANASTASIA%20AND%20TACOSUPREME%20FETLIFE%20MESSAGES%20FORMATTED%20FOR%20PRINT.xlsx

No photos

[Anonymous]

I’ve said before and got a lot of hate but I’ll say it again: this case is full of reasonable doubts, we just don’t wanna see it bc BB is a huge POS regardless if he’s a murderer or not. So we tend to find excuses to all of those gaps in the case.
Either way, he was convicted so I’m aware that my opinion doesn’t matter.

[Anonymous]

How is it full of reasonable doubt?? Do you really think CB wrote those messages on FetLife?? And she conveniently didn't use FetLife the weekend that BB and JPM were away together. BB just happened to bring JPM to the gun range in the months before the murders? You are right about one thing, BB is a huge POS.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

Carrol didn't bring it up because it's not based in reality. The Annastasia profile brought up cutting her clothes off to nine different users besides JR on fetlife. BB's guilty verdict beyond a reasonable doubt is righteous. 9 other dudes dodged a bullet. Literally.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

Carrol didn't bring it up because it's not based in reality. The Annastasia profile brought up cutting her clothes off to nine different users besides JR on fetlife. BB's guilty verdict beyond a reasonable doubt is righteous. 9 other dudes dodged a bullet. Literally.

Cutting her clothes is one thing. But did you see how she said she didn’t want blood play in the beggining?
Maybe his plan was to shoot her and say it was a mistake ?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:How is it full of reasonable doubt?? Do you really think CB wrote those messages on FetLife?? And she conveniently didn't use FetLife the weekend that BB and JPM were away together. BB just happened to bring JPM to the gun range in the months before the murders? You are right about one thing, BB is a huge POS.

I think he didn’t like CB and he prob did want her killed. Maybe even planned it, but I think the story is not exactly how it was presented by the CW. Only CB, BB and JM know the whole truth. We’ll never get the whole picture. Ever. We can get to what most likely happened, but the details will never be revealed.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

Carrol didn't bring it up because it's not based in reality. The Annastasia profile brought up cutting her clothes off to nine different users besides JR on fetlife. BB's guilty verdict beyond a reasonable doubt is righteous. 9 other dudes dodged a bullet. Literally.

Cutting her clothes is one thing. But did you see how she said she didn’t want blood play in the beggining?
Maybe his plan was to shoot her and say it was a mistake ?

I'm aware that the statement about blood was made.. I don't see the significance. The key was that a the person who entered the home was toting a knife. Bringing the knife is key. A fair jury came to a unanimous verdict beyond a reasonable doubt after weighing the evidence.

I'm convinced they came to the correct verdict. I believe Julianna's story is substantially accurate.

I'm curious.. do you think BB did is guilty and the commonwealth didn't make its case?

Alternatively, do you believe that BB is innocent?

[Anonymous]

There is reasonable doubt...? Huh?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:There is reasonable doubt...? Huh?

DP here but CB saying she doesn’t want blood play doesn’t raise questions to you?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

Carrol didn't bring it up because it's not based in reality. The Annastasia profile brought up cutting her clothes off to nine different users besides JR on fetlife. BB's guilty verdict beyond a reasonable doubt is righteous. 9 other dudes dodged a bullet. Literally.

Cutting her clothes is one thing. But did you see how she said she didn’t want blood play in the beggining?
Maybe his plan was to shoot her and say it was a mistake ?

I'm aware that the statement about blood was made.. I don't see the significance. The key was that a the person who entered the home was toting a knife. Bringing the knife is key. A fair jury came to a unanimous verdict beyond a reasonable doubt after weighing the evidence.

I'm convinced they came to the correct verdict. I believe Julianna's story is substantially accurate.

I'm curious.. do you think BB did is guilty and the commonwealth didn't make its case?

Alternatively, do you believe that BB is innocent?

I’m the one that posted originally about the case having reasonable doubts. I’m also the one that posted originally that Juliana didn’t make sense and there were key differences from her interview w prosecutors to the trial testimony.

I don’t think BB is innocent. Despite what happened that day, the things he was doing to CB before her murder were already disgusting.

I do think the story we know is not the full story or exactly what happened.
I do not think his first intention was to stab CB. JR clearly is the one offering blood play and talking about cutting Anastasia while she denies it and says she doesn’t want it and it’s scared to do it.

Wouldn’t that be an ideal scenario for BB anyways? Why declining the offer? Why saying you don’t want pee and poop as part of the fantasy? Why caring about that if you hate your wife to the point of murdering her? These are questions that will never be answered.

Did he want to shoot her instead of stabbing her ? I don’t know. You don’t know. Only BB knows…

The logistics inside the house also doesn’t make sense to me. The timing and the way it was plotted, the 911 calls, the dates between the Discord conversations and fetlife ones, moving the conversation to telegram, telegram code still in CB’s phone … everything is full of gaps that will never be filled, imo.

I’m also the one that said that my opinion doesn’t matter, since he was convicted the way the case was presented. I’m just sharing my thoughts on it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There is reasonable doubt...? Huh?

DP here but CB saying she doesn’t want blood play doesn’t raise questions to you?

That's not reasonable doubt in the full context of everything that happened and all the evidence presented. Bringing a knife to a scene doesn't imply the person has to be cut as part of the roleplay - the point was just to get the person to bring the knife so it would be there.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Ok
On fetlife messages between JR and CB… He’s the one that suggested blood play, and she did say she didn’t want them, she was afraid of them bc it could leave marks for longer than she wanted.

What do we make of that?
Because this wasn’t brought up in any other conversation with other users either.

If not stabbing, what would BB’s plan be ? Since the blood play/knife was never a thing until JR suggested?

Curious how John Carrol didn’t bring that up.

Because later in the messaging the Anastasia user says she DOES want it and she clarifies she wants him to bring a knife. Why would he draw attention to that again.