This is the most histrionic, over the top language and sounds like it belongs in a romance or YA novel. Take it down a notch and someone might see your point of view. |
Jill dumped Bethenny. Bethenny begged Jill to stay in her life. It wasn’t until Bethenny became settled in her relationship and Jill realized that she was going to be fired, that she wanted to be friends again. At that point Bethenny was done. |
Disagree. The PP is spot on with Bethenny. Watch her in any discussion - she’s like a machine gun just firing words so that no one can get a word in. And she’s downright viscious to people. |
Jill dumped Bethenny because she thought it was good TV and she planned to get back together and be friends with her at the end. This has all been stated publicly by her. Once Bethenny figured all that out and once Jill played her hand too hard, Bethenny ended the friendship. Jill had zero intention of not being friends with her long-term. |
What I don't understand from the Carole defenders is the things that Carole has said about Bethenny this season are a lot worse than anything Bethenny said about Carole. That's just fact. The stuff in Carole's blogs was next level terrible. My opinion is Bethenny typically calls it like it is and is spot on, however her delivery is sometimes over the top. And sometimes telling someone the truth to their face just isn't a good look. The truth can be mean and she comes off looking unkind and unhinged. But honestly, nothing she has ever said has rung untrue to me about any of these women. And that's why she is ratings gold. Because she says the shit we are all thinking. |
I’m the PP above you and I’m not a Carole defender. I’m glad she’s leaving. She did say some terrible things about Bethenny in her blogs. But Carole’s 5 blogs don’t make up for the years of Bethenny on tv. Bethenny is a brutal no holds barred person. I think hiding behind - I call it like I see if attitudes - is also pathetic. There’s no two ways around it, Bethenny is a viscious person. She just don’t need to be that mean to other people. And look where it’s gotten her? Now all we are hearing is her crying about being alone. She just has to look in the mirror to see why. |
Maybe I'm being to meta, but that's the whole point of these shows. We watch her say the shit we are thinking, which she does better than almost anyone on these shows. We watch her suffer the consequences. We watch her be really compassionate and vulnerable in one moment and then unhinged in the next moment. It's a human train wreck. Most of these Housewives are broken humans on some level. This is also why NY is the best city, in my opinion. You have to have women who are willing to sling the truth telling and risk being very unpopular. That's why Beverly Hills has gotten so damn boring. So I just can't fault her too much. Hate the game, not the player and all. |
I'm over whatever girl-breakup went down between Carole/Bethenny. That horse is dead- no need to do a postmortem on it.
The thing that sticks with me is how painful it is to watch everyone not acknowledge Dorinda's alcoholism. During the dinner, Luann quietly said 'you're turning', to Dorinda, like in the way a friend would tell a friend she had lipstick on her teeth. Dorinda's inability to hear that and rein in her own behavior and to be so sensitive/feel judged by that simple comment just smacks of what a mean delusional drunk she is. And then she turned. You can be mad someone said something 'mean/judgemental' about you, but when you can't course-correct and you do exactly what they are warning you about, the proof is in the pudding. Dorinda is not ready to acknowledge a problem. I think Bethenny is right that Dorinda never remembers what she did wrong, but the next day she probably wakes up like "I think I should feel guilty about something... I remember doing something... oh well..." She is good at apologizing because that is what you always need to do when you act like that. I found it interesting, that comment about "let's do 21 days together" that she muttered when hugging Luann. I wish Luann could have jumped on that and said "Pick a date. Let's do it. When?" I have this gut feeling that Dorinda was a drunk when Richard was alive and she's still a drunk- I don't have sympathy that she is doing this to cope with that loss. |
Dorinda's drunk behavior has not surprised me. What has surprised me is her doubling down on it after watching the shows back. That is some deep, deep delusion. |
I agree with this. I love Sober Dorinda - she's smart and funny and nice. I hate Drunk Dorinda. I am surprised LuAnn forgave her for calling her a convict. "That was way harsh..." |
Agreed. She was on WWHL and still thought she was the victim. She even called out Lou going back to rehab by making a comment about “well we all know how this played out...” She’s a mean drunk and really needs to stop drinking. And I don’t want to hear her blubbering about Richard anymore. They weren’t together very long and he’s been dead longer than they were married. |
I'd bet any amount of money, she was drinking when she did WWHL. She needs help. Lu should have very gently followed up on the offer to go away together (maybe she did, who knows?) but i agree that the documentation of this behavior is NOT new and should be enough to curb it in anyone who had control. She clearly does not. |
Can we please spell “vicious” correctly amidst all this talk of Bethenny?? |
I think at some point Dorinda needs to be stopped by bravo. You can't pay someone in order to broadcast their addiction to the world year after year and not at some point be acountble. Just like E eventually had to let Guiliana Rancic go, bravo needs go stop taping Dorinda. |
+1! It’s so distracting. My brain keeps reading that person’s post as a misspelled viscous. |