Trump govt is deporting Green Card holder student exercising free speech

[Anonymous]

Of course the Trump admins first attempt at dehumanizing and disappearing someone was a Muslim non citizen. You are fools if you think you won't be a target at some point. Even if you buy the poorly supported terrorism argument, the tactics preview the endgame for thousands. These aren't secret playbooks, but many of your minds are incredibly limited.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Who paid for his education at Columbia?

Likely his middle eastern family that owns oil, who else would sponsor him?!

Oh yeah, Palestinians are swimming in oil, there’s just so much of it

Do you not realize that most Palestinians are poor because they live under a brutal military occupation?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

No matter how much cnn plays this story no one cares. I am sure msnbc plays but who watches that?

He was on a temporary green card supporting terrorists. Game over.

He can help clean up rubble on Gaza Strip if he is so passionate about Palestinians.

What about his American wife who is 8 months pregnant? Will we now be supporting her and the child? I imagine she will get the full support of the US embassy when she travels abroad? Will the child know his father?

Dunno. She is a US citizen- I assume she has family here to help her out.
If she moves to Gaza maybe US puts in a good word for her with IDF?
They are adults - well educated - they’ll figure it out.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

No matter how much cnn plays this story no one cares. I am sure msnbc plays but who watches that?

He was on a temporary green card supporting terrorists. Game over.

He can help clean up rubble on Gaza Strip if he is so passionate about Palestinians.

What about his American wife who is 8 months pregnant? Will we now be supporting her and the child? I imagine she will get the full support of the US embassy when she travels abroad? Will the child know his father?

Dunno. She is a US citizen- I assume she has family here to help her out.
If she moves to Gaza maybe US puts in a good word for her with IDF?
They are adults - well educated - they’ll figure it out.

Maybe AIPAC should move to Gaza and fight the war of survival and redemption for Israel? Everyone pack a bag and head to Trump hotel Gaza-the apparent tourist paradise for 2025 and beyond.

[Anonymous]

This guy should have focused on his studies instead of agitating, until he became a US citizen.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Who paid for his education at Columbia?

This is actually quite a good question. Arabs , just like Jews, also are white on the census so they don’t qualify as affirmative action/DEI.

I am going to guess he received a scholarship wowing the admissions committee with the story of how he was A second generation Palestinian born in a. Refugee camp in Syria after Zionists burned half his village down in 1948 or 1967 or 1982?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Who paid for his education at Columbia?

Likely his middle eastern family that owns oil, who else would sponsor him?!

Owns oil but lived in a refugee camp?

[Anonymous]

If he gets deported to Gaza, he can join the real Hamas and get a generous monthly Qatari stipend/direct deposit from Bibi Netanyahu and a nice tunnel apartment. Probably better than a Manhattan apartment. More spacious and less people these days

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is clear why he is being deported. Hamas is a terrorist organization.

It's common sense this guy and those like him are people who shouldn't be here.

Looking at this, it appears the federal government can legally deport greed card holders based on their advocating or expressing support for terrorist acts.

That said, the terrorist label has become a red herring. Clearly Palestinians and Israelis disagree on who gets to live where on the land. A world where wars are fought as humanely as possible is also clearly a good thing.

But the Palestinians don't have an army, air force or navy. I'm pretty sure Israel would never allow that. So is it surprising the Palestinians resort to terror and other asymmetrical tactics? Should Palestinian jihadists declare war on Israel and attempt to march on Israeli military bases? If the Palestinians are denied access to a regular conventional army it seems a terror response is to be expected.


If a Palestinian militant goes home to an apartment building and the IDF blows the building up killing dozens of people, is the claim that Hamas hides among civilians absolve the IDF from any culpability?

Plenty of oppressed people in the world. A few great leaders found non violent ways to protest and free them: MLK, Gandhi to name a couple. Their causes were no less just. This guy is not one of those great leaders. He has called for and celebrated violence against civilians. He has therefore violated the terms of his probationary acceptance into the US and needs to be deported. Why would we accept any person advocating for violence? It puts our own country and citizens at risk. The ends do not justify the means.

He didn't commit any violence, nor did he advocate for violence in the US.

I think there are many Jewish American Zionists who also put this country at risk, and put Israel's interests above the US'.

Nelson Mandela also used violence. I guess he was a terrorist in your eyes.

DP. You are showing your ignorance with your statement about Mandela. His own party admitted to atrocities, eventually. And it is flat-out delusional to compare Khalil to Mandela.

https://www.nytimes.com/1997/05/13/world/party-led-by-mandela-now-owns-up-to-atrocities.html

Indeed, so you would consider Mandela a terrorist, even though he fought for equal rights for native South Africans?

And you're right, not a fair comparison.. Mandela actually committed violence, where has Khalil did not.

I wouldn’t consider Mandela a terrorist in his own country. Now, if Mandela had been a green card holder in the US advocating relentlessly for necklacing his political opponents (including Americans and babies) from his comfy and safe position in the US, that would be a different matter. And that’s what the Khalil situation is analogous to.

So, if Nelson Mandela was living in the US fighting apartheid, you would want him to be deported. Got it.

You think people who are fighting for freedom should be limited to only being nice if they live in the US, but fine for them to use violence if they live in another country.

Did Khalil actually say babies should have their heads cut off? I didn't read that part.

I do not think the US has any obligation to house foreign nationals who support and advocate for terrorism against Americans and others. Call me crazy if you’d like, but I suspect you are in .05% of the US population in taking that position.

If Mandela had been supporting the execution of babies from the US, I would have said the same thing about him.

Again ,did he say he supported killing babies?

Anyone who comes out in favor of Hamas and 10/7 explicitly supports killing babies.

Considering that Israel has killed many more babies, and is currently starving thousands more, I think it’s safe to say that support for Israel is support for killing babies

Just in case you need a reminder, Palestinians are PEOPLE. Not roaches, or animals, or whatever it is the JEWS of all people are calling them.

Remember - Hitler so easily exterminated your ancestors because he was able to convince regular Germans you were a threat to their existence. Why do you want to do that to another people?

[Anonymous]

Only 1 baby died on 10/7.

We were told 40 were beheaded. Netanyahu told our president that then denied it to his own people the next day saying he was just putting on to Americans

Israel is tricky but they aren’t smart

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This guy should have focused on his studies instead of agitating, until he became a US citizen.

No

Naturalized citizen are next on Trump's hit list. You know, not "real" citizens

And finally, American citizens by birthright.

Watch and see

[Anonymous]

Trump just pulled a fast one on Israel by talking to Hamas without their knowledge the first time the US has spoken to Hamas directly ever.

This war couldn’t be a worse tactical disaster for Israel so they have to take wins in small things like deporting some nobody loudmouth college kids. They would’ve never have stooped so low a decade ago. The antidote to destroying Hamas are not bombs or deportations but getting rid of their president/PM who nurtured Hamas’ rise

[Anonymous]

But this is the psychological dilemma Israel has. Rabin was a traitor for signing the Oslo Accords but Bibi is not a traitor for giving billions to Hamas.

Right wing Israeli and Palestinian movements like Likud and Hamas rose up together in the mid 90s with the singular goal of destroying Oslo and golly what destruction did they cause to both peoples in the profess

[Anonymous]

Another rapid-fire solo from our resident HamA$$ troll!
Your WPM is truly impressive.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:What I want to know who is paying for the very expensive lawyers representing him.

Didn’t ask the same question when payments were made by AIPAC …