+1 |
What you did 100% prompted her posting that she regretted the comment. The "Good" poster was faced with a situation where she didn't know what would come of the location reveal. She was scared. Maybe you are giving her credit because you played dirty pool (in some way absolving yourself) but make no mistake... fear led the "Good" poster to regret the post. You played Big Brother and scared the beejeezus out of her. Accept it. |
Who is "we" and how have you "destroyed" me? You sound like a buffoon. You are making the HUGE assumption that this family is not cooperating with the police, with ZERO evidence to back up your assertion. Doesn't matter how many other families are this way in Baltimore. You have NO PROOF that this family is hiding information from the police. And why am I injecting race? Please, don't play dumb. At least, I hope you're playing. |
+1. I agree that the remark was repugnant, but a big part of what makes DCUM what it is (the good and the bad) is that people feel free to post anonymously. Perhaps in this case, Jeff quasi-outed someone for stating something that most of us would agree is morally reprehensible. But it could still have the effect of chilling speech, because there's no saying when Jeff will choose to exercise those powers. And I think part of me is disappointed because I thought Jeff was above that sort of thing. |
Amen. If your anonymity is going to be comprised (even in a benign way) then this site should require registration with a valid email. |
i share your sensibilites on this but i don't think you're gonna be right about this one. sadly. |
How do you know the person's gender? |
It's the usual assumption. Most posters are women. Or maybe Jeff really does know all and see all, and knows the exact identity of each poster. But I figure he was assuming. Also, I agree with him. On an anonymous forum like this, if you post something you regret, you can't really go back and edit or delete it. All you can do is come back later and apologize. |
More outing. Could we change the default status to something akin to the truth, such as: "semi-anonymous" or "anonymous only when Jeff feels like it or agrees with your politics" ?? |
You have a strange definition of anonymity. Since you apparently -- thanks to me -- know this poster's identity now, why don't you schedule a lunch with her? Also, I am assuming that it is a "she" based on our user demographics which heavily favor women. |
Don't know the gender. Analogous to the doctor referring to the fetus in one gender or the other if the parents don't want to know the sex. I can change it to he if it will make you feel better. |
+ 1 I agree. I am never going to be comfortable again writing anything that will not show me in a good light. That means that I have to be PC all the time. The anonymity of this forum was the best part of this forum. Yes - there are conflicts and wars - but there are also honest give and take. And I would rather hear the real reasons why someone disagrees with me, rather than be presented with the polite mask that we are presented with everyday IRL. I also thought that Jeff was above something like that. However, DCUM has brought out the best and the worst in all of us - one time or another - and so I think we can let it go this once. I appreciate when Jeff cleans up after us (deleting threads and locking threads) - I think as a moderator that is a great work. However, let the anonymity be maintained. Don't call out posters in this way. |
Exactly. As a product of an inner-city environment, I saw far too many suburb people (read: VA whites) come to DC with money from wealthy families, bartering guns and other goods in exchange for drugs, other to cross the Potomac and turn their noses up at the ghetto. |
Please calm the eff down. Your identity (nor that of the shameful commenter) has been compromised. You're being silly. |
I would love to walk down the street and engage that poster in a friendly conversation on my lunchbreak. I have lost over sixty neighbors, associates, friends, etc. to gun violence right here in this city. Good, is the last thing that it is. It's a fourteen year old for pete's sake. |