
Curie prep starts pretty early in elementary school. Is that all just TJ prep? Why don't they do SHSAT like they used to. You could get prep books on Amazon and khan academy had YouTube courses. Why did they move to a secret test? |
That might fix some of the income gap but it wasn't going to affect the race gap. You would just be replacing wealthy white and Asians with poor Asians. You would likely end up with even more Asians. This is not goal. |
It's certainly better than trying to bind minors to keeping a secret. The secret to expensive prep is transparency. Reduce the barriers to prep, don't erect new more expensive barriers. And like a PP started, it took less than a year for quant q test prep study aid to pop up on Amazon. Only a moron thinks secret testing would work. And what was the economically disadvantaged population in the incoming class that first year of quant Q? 1.5%, virtually indistinguishable from what we got with the SHSAT. |
I don't think that would have changed much. The problem was people engineering their kid's childhood and preparing extensively (for years, months) for the test specifically to get their kids into TJ. It was creating a dynamic where if you DIDN'T do that and just had a normal very smart and hard working (at school) kid, they didn't have much of a shot at making it in. That's what drove the reform. |
That's some bull. Normal, very smart kids earn high standardized test scores without any prep. They also typically had very high grades, good achievements, and excellent teacher recommendations. Prep centers didn't change things for kids at the top of the heap. Mostly, they changed who was being admitted into the bottom half of TJ by letting less talented but highly prepped kids edge out the more talented but unprepped ones. |
But the more talented unprepped kids weren’t who got in with the recent change. The more talented unprepped kids aren’t URMs. |
I guess if they were to use a standardized test that might make sense, but you can also argue that grades are the product of many many tests so to say they aren't using tests is misleading. |
Yes, and those smart kids with access to test prep did even better. It had become an arms race of who could afford the best prep. It was out of control and the kids are the main beneficiaries of the county ending this nonsense. |
I'm always amused by the people who keep trying to cover up that the cheating was rampant. Everyone knew this was going on. It wasn't a secret. It's been discussed to death here. |
I’m sure some parents start that early. They also rent homes in feeder school districts and hire consultants to determine the best activities for a strong application. Wealthy, motivated parents do all kinds of things to get a leg up for their kid in competitive admissions. |
+1 They have been trying for years to level the playing field. |
Yup. Only wealthy kids had a shot. |
HHI is a big factor for DEI. |
Yep. Now only wealthy kids and poor kids get in. Hard working middle class kids who don’t spend tons of money on prep but absolutely outscore their URM counterparts have been skipped because FARMs students get application welfare points for a variety of experience “factors.” The middle always gets squeezed in these pseudo class struggles. The reality is that URMs have never been able to close the gap between their peers, rich or otherwise. Even controlling for income, standardized tests reveal a painful truth for these DEI-advocates. So instead, they focus on welfare and tearing down the reputations of the top performers as cheaters and “wealthy.” Why cant they bring these scores up? ever? |
Nope. The top merit half of TJ is the same now as before change. Lot of changes in bottom half though. |