Tell Me The Truth…..Was I Out Of Line Here??

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I think in general it's rude to criticism cuz someone in that situation BUT OP did it for the girl and OP is right. Maybe the experience will give that woman pause the next time. I think it was worth it to speak up in this situation.

My parents both really openly resented having kids and being parents and it had a very bad impact on their relationship with us. Hearing stuff like that as a kid can follow you your whole life. Children need to feel wanted. It's essential.

I bet later on in life this child will remember the ONE grownup out of many who actually spoke up about how inappropriate this Mother’s comment was and be grateful that someone had the balls to advocate for her.
Groupthink can be a very negative thing.
Sometimes it just takes one person to stand up for another person - just one.

And that one person has the ability to make a world of difference.

[Anonymous]

MYOB

[Anonymous]

Mom was being judged bcs her child was misbehaving. Then she was judged bcs she said something. And OP, presumably another mom, decided to pile it on.
Not cool.

[Anonymous]

OP, YTA.

[Anonymous]

Normally, I respond to these posts as out of line.

I don’t think you were in this case. I understand why she said it in the moment, and you offered her a perspective the moment didn’t provide her otherwise. She might reflect on this moment and bite her tongue next time.

[Anonymous]

Omg, the poor woman probably felt embarrassed and awkward and was trying to make a comment to diffuse the situation. You made it worse.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Omg, the poor woman probably felt embarrassed and awkward and was trying to make a comment to diffuse the situation. You made it worse.

Yes, this has been covered. OP expressed her regret. It's ok to stop piling on, now.

[Anonymous]

Inappropriate/WAAAAAY out of line. What was your goal?

Someone was having a rotten day. Instead of being kind and telling her 'don't worry, we have all been there' or 'hard to believe it, but you do miss even the bad days with kids' you chose to make her day worse.

At a port of call on a Mexican cruise a couple months ago, a frustrated mother was trying to get her two overtired cranky toddlers back through the open market shopping area to the cruise security line before the sailing. Every human in the vicinity, all our teen/tween kids overhead the mother yell "you are the biggest dick in all of Mexico!!!!" to one toddler.

I know she really was just feeling embarrassed and feeling a need to tell the adults around 'hey, I know this kid is being a brat- sorry'. It was 5% funny (like if it was a movie, not real life) But it was just SO MEAN. My kids have been quoting her for weeks w sad faces... they felt so badly for the kids. I wanted them to know it's normal and ok to feel overwhelmed w kids but to choose a better option.

Anyway I asked if she was on xxxx cruise line and she was on the same one as us. I told her we were going in the same direction. Could my kids take some of her bags and I'd carry the toddler. She was like 'YUP'.

The toddler was so so shocked but entertained by my kids that he shut up and off we went. If she'd told me to go F myself I'd have kept walking but sometimes people just need to not feel judged and to get a little help.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I don't know why people stand around and watch a toddler having a temper tantrum. Why were you just standing there watching? That's so weird.

I don't know why people go shopping with children. I only took my children shopping when I was clothes shopping for them. If necessary, I hired a babysitter or shopped when they were in school. When I went back to work, I went out early on Saturday Morning and grocery shopped.

Only a fool thinks taking a child to a store that has toys on display isn't an invitation for a tantrum.

This is so very true. Of course any child that goes into a store that sells toys is going to cry when they see toys displayed. Of course the child will want the toys they see. It is human nature. I would never shop at Walmart or Target with a child just for this reason. I would only take my child shopping with me in a clothes only store or even appliance.

I think this store mama was the one out of line. A child at four years old is going to be traumatized for hearing her mama say in a nutshell that she wishes she never had her. That she regrets that she was even born.

I cannot even imagine what the mother says to her behind closed doors.
CPS should be involved.

Good heavens.
I remember when my kid was a kid in the 1990s parents would quote the Bill Cosby line (from his standup comedy quoting his mom) "I brought you into this world, I can take you out of it." I thought it was a horrifying thing to say, and these were trashy people in general (it was a working class neighborhood, I was floored when I moved into this cheap duplex and a neighbor's kids came to introduce themselves and immediately opened my freezer to see what was in there--I was poor and had grown up working class but never would have dreamed that to be ok) but wouldn't have called CPS.

I did call CPS about the kid who would show up at midnight asking if my kid could come out and play and once told us about a fire he'd built in his basement and turned out to wear a knife strapped to his leg. Kid was 10. His mom also stole my rose bush while I was moving to the house we bought.

As for shopping with kids, plenty of people have no choice so shut up about that.

I would have just apologized to the woman for staring if I said anything at all.