You don’t have statistics and if you’ve seen 4 SROs disarm students you are delusion and need therapy. Being ignorant is not an insult it’s a call to educate yourself. If a farmer told me I was ignorant about farming it would be a correct statement not an insult and I’d listen Instead of talk. SRO reinstatement is a.waste of money and a call to a psycho they need more fire power. Enjoy your future AR15 day. |
This is an example of a shooting that was not stopped. The student shot his target. The SRO missed his target. The student shot him self as planned. The SRO was ineffective. |
So, what is your "better" solution? |
Once again, you bring nothing but insults to the table. Your absurd comments regarding ignorance are highly ironic; you refuse to listen to somebody who has presented statistics (see link above) and true anecdotal evidence. 18 years in a high school? I’ve seen A LOT. I have yet to see you present anything but denial. At this point, I recognize I’m arguing with someone incapable of having a logical discussion about school safety. (Actually, I figured that out already…) |
It's not enough, unfortunately. They need to be back in the schools to the extent they can form decent relationships with kids. |
Here is a bigger study that found the exact opposite. Of the 652 cases they studied (after starting with a 1,400 case sample frame), presence of a police officer (a more precise category than "armed guard") is associated with a shooting being non-fatal rather than fatal. It also showed only about 26% of shooters had mental health problems. https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/creation-school-shooting-open-source-database-fuels-understanding?fbclid=IwAR0r8LS5KGW90ESB05ub2Hs2zgkyxrGAxAkYIDomsLWKdZBk0jEYt3OSR9Y#noteReferrer1 https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/301665.pdf |
What does that really mean? There is no way these shooters DON'T have mental health issues. They may not be diagnosed but no one in their right mind does this. |
What it means is most school shootings are like what happened at Magruder. And those are interpersonal conflicts. Not mental health issues. Do you plan for the majority of school shootings? Or the mass shootings that occur less than 1% of the time? Of course you plan for both -- but the foundation of that planning has to be for the everyday violence that we see in our schools. |
DP here. You're right. We need Gun control but you're wrong that SROs make schools less safe and wrong when you said that they don't disarm students. At Clarksburg High, an SRO disarmed a student with a gun a few years ago. All 25 HS principals disagree with you. And students disagree with your position that SROs are harmful. This is from the Blair HS newspaper written by a student recently: Before MCPS decided to remove SROs, Blair benefited from a mentoring program run by its security team and then-SRO. As Blair's Security Team Leader, Darryl Cooper, describes it, "Everybody on security would take at least five kids [to] mentor throughout the year along with the SRO. So you had a police [officer] that was mentoring kids… they keep in touch with her now that she's been transferred out." By limiting the presence of these officers on high school campuses, MCPS prevents them from continuing their tradition of mentoring at-risk students. According to the Department of Homeland Security, social isolation is a major risk factor for students who commit violence in schools. A core part of violence prevention is ensuring that at-risk students build positive relationships with mentors–teachers, counselors, coaches, and officers–who can guide them in the right direction. |
| Maryland's gun control measures are better than most states. Not that this going to help. This is a national problem. |
Follow gabby Gifford, or Mom’s demand action. Gun control, waiting periods, age to buy raised to 21, no assault weapons, red flag laws, …. Do you really need to be told this? Mental illness is often identified from 16-25, we need intervention and ways for family to deal with mentally ill adult children that is not “call the police”, see Denver police mental health intervention program. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2021/02/06/denver-sent-mental-health-help-not-police-hundreds-calls/4421364001/ People know the The solution but congress is bought and sold by special interest groups … they even fooled you with their SRO propaganda. |
No an SRO did NOT disarm a student at Clarksburg. A student told a teacher, who told an SRO, who told a principal (because the SRO didn’t even know where the student was/which class). They called the real police and the real police made a plan and called the kid out of class. Nobody was disarmed because he was not holding the gun. What that kid needed was a mental health intervention before he brought a gun to school. Everybody knew he was unstable. The SRO didn’t stop him from bringing a gun”because he was so in tune with students”. I agree principals need to identify dangerous kids and remove them but they can’t. They get moved around like the Damascus rapist and Sheinbein. Mentoring at risk kids FFS. No just no. They need therapists/ psychiatrists and real parents/families. A cop is not a psychologist, most don’t even have a 4 year degree. Hey maybe the school plumber can mentor them too, they have more of an education. |
You know there have been more than one gun confiscated at Clarksburg, right? I don't know why you hate police so much but don't make everyone else suffer because of your bias. |
I suspect you are the same anti-SRO poster from above since the parroted “SROs do not disarm” argument is being used in spite of being proven untrue. SROs don’t operate in a vacuum. They work WITH the school psychologists, administrators, and teachers. I am a teacher who regularly used to work with one. SROs get to know students and can help identify troubling patterns early. SROs go through additional training in order to fulfill this role, which has been highlighted over and over on DCUM. At the end of the day, if you want to hate SROs, you’re going to hate them. No amount of evidence will change your mind, even if evidence of need and support of the program is currently growing. |
|
Here in Montgomery County, police in schools are real police.
They are really good police -- both highly trained to deal with youth and naturally just good at it. If you had gone to the forum last week, you would have heard SROs recount stories of just how they were able to avert violence, get others help, and discover why those kids who were causing pain were actually in pain themselves. And the SROs helped them move on to be successful. https://www.mymcmedia.org/school-officers-principals-discuss-relationship-building-at-forum/ Spanish https://www.mymcmedia.org/funcionarios-escolares-y-policias-discuten-el-rol-de-los-oficiales-en-las-escuelas-publicas/ |