New Additions to Leagues Check Up (ECNL & GA)

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It’s been long rumored that STA is going ECNL.
The other is the real question.

Indy Prem

Yeah I mean if rumors true, those are decent choices. It has to be someone that either has a positive or net neutral change for the Boys. Have to keep in mind that ultimately this is about the boys. STA already has Boys in ECNL so no change, Indy Prem Boys play like USYS so positive change. If either was getting MLSN, then neither would be moving. Just like all the other teams that have been mentioned in other posts that already have MLSN are not giving that up to move to ECNL.

I know everyone hears ECNL and thinks Girls, and only the Girls are really discussed on this board, but at the end of the day the Boys is really what steers the ship.

[Anonymous]

Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

Indy Premier's boys play in MLS Next via a partnership with Hoosier called Hoosier Premier Academy so they do have access to a higher level boys program.

[Anonymous]

Updates?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

Agreed.

Indy premier leaving would hurt, but I don’t think they are as big as nationals and SSS leaving.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

Arlington is trying but MLS has no interest in boys program

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

The IHS guy does not have the background to to be viewed as a "respected source of information". Traditional journalists are typically trained to verify information through multiple independent sources. In contrast, coaches-turned-content-creators like Collinsworth often rely on personal experiences or singular "messages" to drive engagement relying on a single tip or message to create a "story. For a creator not trained in the trade, the pressure to produce frequent content can sometimes come at the expense of fact-checking.

[Anonymous]

The only clubs leaving that would really “hurt” the GA in my opinion would be:
1. Tophat (biggest by far)
2. City SC
3. NEFC
4. Florida United (not for their collective, but they produce a ton of the leagues best individual players)

Other clubs have some asterisks next to them whether it’s strength in some ages but not others, use of a lot of other clubs players to attain success, etc

Clubs who would be solid adds but not dynamic to either league would be ones such as Indy Premier, Michigan Jaguars, Lamorinda, Beadling, Lou Fusz (rumor is they have lost a lot to SLSG @ tryouts). I’d have had CUP in there but they have dropped so far the last two years it’s crazy.

[Anonymous]

The important part to remember is the boys ecnl side. Which of the “very dominant” clubs is on the verge of going MLS Next?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The important part to remember is the boys ecnl side. Which of the “very dominant” clubs is on the verge of going MLS Next?

Great point, we need to remember the boys side here is the one to watch. I imagine there will be movement both ways here once a few teams make their decision.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

The IHS guy does not have the background to to be viewed as a "respected source of information". Traditional journalists are typically trained to verify information through multiple independent sources. In contrast, coaches-turned-content-creators like Collinsworth often rely on personal experiences or singular "messages" to drive engagement relying on a single tip or message to create a "story. For a creator not trained in the trade, the pressure to produce frequent content can sometimes come at the expense of fact-checking.

"Traditional journalists are typically trained to verify information through multiple independent sources". this is the most laughable statement I have heard in a long time. traditional journalist are the most intellectually bankrupt people who drive anagenda and make up facts to fit the narrative they want to present.

[Anonymous]

Is there a "dominant" ECNL boys team that would want MLS Next? Who can we predict gets moved to GA with that decision?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Makes sense.

If IP is getting the opportunity to elevate the boys via ECNL, then I see them and STA as the two

If the rumor turns out to be true.. (BTW I've heard from 2 executive directors at different organizations that Arlington was making the switch to GA and it has not happened)

STA and Indy Premier would not move the meter. Especially with STA being replaced by Football Academy.

The IHS guy does not have the background to to be viewed as a "respected source of information". Traditional journalists are typically trained to verify information through multiple independent sources. In contrast, coaches-turned-content-creators like Collinsworth often rely on personal experiences or singular "messages" to drive engagement relying on a single tip or message to create a "story. For a creator not trained in the trade, the pressure to produce frequent content can sometimes come at the expense of fact-checking.

"Traditional journalists are typically trained to verify information through multiple independent sources". this is the most laughable statement I have heard in a long time. traditional journalist are the most intellectually bankrupt people who drive anagenda and make up facts to fit the narrative they want to present.

I think you are not understanding the difference between journalist and content creator. Do some research and get back to me with what you learn.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Is there a "dominant" ECNL boys team that would want MLS Next? Who can we predict gets moved to GA with that decision?

I can give you one example.

SC Surf. They are strong on the boys side and meh on the girls side.

The girls were GA, boys ECNL.
The girls now have ECNL…makes you wonder what discussions were had.