Forum Index
»
Political Discussion
If teens are sexually active, why not let them get married? |
This false statistic that keeps getting repeated is based on an entirely false premise. The real percentages are significantly higher. Reporting on the reason why the patient is getting the abortion is not even remotely comprehensive, and where it exists, it's voluntary, so it's at a complete disjoint from the overall totals. So, for the overwhelming majority of abortions, they simply have no data at all on the reason why. Either no questionnaire on why they were getting it, or declined to answer why, which is legitimate given the trauma they are already living through. So they falsely count those non-answers as "abortion of convenience" and in so doing, significantly undercount the actual reasons, including rape and incest cases. |
If DC parents stop sending kids to Oberlin, that will be quite a bite out of the school’s money. |
It does because medicines people need to live are not being distributed to patients. Methotrexate. Some men report they can’t get their prescriptions refilled. |
DP On the one hand, you aren’t wrong. Yes, presumably anyone looking at “top schools” is well-educated. Yes, presumably well-educated people follow the news and have a “sense” (typically based on assumption and stereotypes) of what it means to go to a certain school or a certain state. (The state piece makes me chuckle because the reality is students tend to live on or extremely close to campus and they only experience campus life, not the real local culture; it’s akin to visiting DC for a week and only seeing the touristy things). But your statement is dripping with arrogance and intellectual elitism fueled by identity politics that compel you to label entire states as backwater shitholes. Congratulations. You are the stereotypical liberal elitist. You are entitled to your beliefs. FTR, I’m a lifelong liberal who lives in super blue MoCo and has a social justice advocacy job. I’m very, very pro-choice. But let’s get real: families like yours were never really considering schools in the south, right? I mean, before the Supreme Court decision came down, many states had already limited abortion by the fact they only had 1 abortion clinic in the state. Was that level of access sufficient for you and your daughter? Was the state a backwater s-hole a month ago or only post-Dobbs? Just admit that your family had already written off certain states based on whatever measure you use. You probably never set foot in most of those states. You probably don’t have close contacts there who are good people doing good things regardless of their party affiliation or personal beliefs on abortion. You adhere to stereotypes that allowed you to pass judgement on an entire state and it’s people. If you live in VA, you should know that many liberals similarly judge Virginians in similar fashion. If you are from the dc metro area, you might think that’s unreasonable and unfair. I bet good people living in AL, TN, etc. feel the same way. Regardless of what your kid does regarding college (a privilege in and of itself), I encourage you to step back and evaluate your role in perpetuating stereotypes, bias, and the identity politics that are literally destroying our democracy. Our democracy thrives on constructive debate and bipartisan consensus. We must not live in bubbles and pat ourselves on the back for being well-educated good people while throwing rocks at all citizens of certain states (and their colleges) and saying hateful, condescending things. I know you think it helps, but it really doesn’t. Advocate to change hearts and minds and ultimately laws. Do not close yourself off and hurl sweeping generalizations and antagonistic slurs. Rigid activists aren’t effective; open-minded, persistent, consensus-building advocates are. You can’t advocate by preaching to the choir in your bubble. |
With your rationale that rape and incest are "significantly undercounted," along with your omission of data, one can assume that yiu don't know if the percentages are "significantly higher." You just want people to assume you're correct? |
True, there aren't a lot of decent schools in red states. Duke, Vanderbilt, Rice, Davidson, etc. UWSTL has always been a sh1thole. |
Even before the decision, my kid said “no” to the South. Too hot, too backward. We do have 1-2 Ohio schools on the list, and I wonder if we should keep them or not. DP |
Advising your children about a major life and financial decision is not helicopter parenting, it’s good parenting. A kid who is paying for college would be a fool not to consider the fact that these school’s brands are tarnished by association, that there is a chance however slim that they will not get proper medical care, and that the political and cultural environment in those locations is increasingly regressive and authoritarian. These schools ain’t worth it! |
|
Look, pro-lifers - no matter what you want to believe, this is already in motion and it's far bigger than DCUM. You can't and won't stop this by going on a message board and calling everyone "nutjobs."
Your states *will* and already are losing revenue as will companies based in your states, and that's entirely the fault of you pro-lifers. |
+1 Thank you for this post!! |
I have been throwing out all of the Catholic school literature. One school gave our kids a big scholarship. We won’t be using it. They seem desperate for students, and I bet the scholarship is a discount designed to fill seats. No way. |
We live in VA and will move out of this sh1thole if the VA GOP attacks women. If people don't want to be associated with a sh1thole state that treats women like trash then they can also move away. Or elect new officials. |
You honestly don’t think there will be other kids from other states that can close the gap? |
Yet you wanted people to assume your completely faulty 0.5% statistic was correct and not be questioned on it, didn't you. Your 0.5% premise is no more valid. We don't know what the real statistic is. But whatever it is, it's guaranteed to be higher, as we know pregnancies resulting from rape are significantly higher than 0.5% and we know that rapes and other forms of nonconsentual sex are undercounted. |