Great advice. TJ isn't a school for everyone. Not all kids will like the "fit". OP seems to think her kid is strongly interested in it though so it's worth a shot. Worst case is kids give it a try and then transfer back home if they hate it. My DC loves it FWIW. Yes it's harder and yes she'd be successful academically at her home school too but the "fit" for her at TJ is wonderful which is why she's thriving there. Like you said, you need to weigh what's best for your own kid. |
| I am a bit surprised that the kids who are strongly interested in TJ don’t choose to stay at a school like Franklin where there are strong academics and fewer kids applying for TJ. It strikes me like a better move then moving to Carson where the odds of being accepted are probably worse. |
OP here, yes I wonder this too. My DD does not have many peers that want to go for TJ which this may be a win for her. But, at the same time, the kids that each school sends can exceed the 1.5% rule. |
Was your daughter in AAP and chose to go to Franklin? She will have a peer group at her base HS if she doesn’t get into TJ. TJ takes 500 kids, and not only from FCPS. A good number of the kids at Carson will end up at Chantilly and she will be in AP classes with them. |
My DD was in half time AAP- Level 3. There were peers in her grade last year who wanted to try out for full time, but our DD did not want to. There are rigorous courses at Franklin and most of her friends are at Franklin with her. But, her friends at Carson seem to be ahead in the curriculum, and more TJ “addicted.” We are trying to get our daughter in the top 1.5%, otherwise the open pool would be really hard for her. Please let me know if this is wrong. |
Is she currently taking all honors classes or a mixture? |
All honors, with algebra 1 hn. She is in the 7th grade. |
What competition did you just find out about this year? It’s not clear from your post. |
My apologies; what I mean by competition is we just found out how strong the competition for TJ was, and we are wondering if our DD will be too late to the game. |
|
Honestly, at this point you just need to chill and help her chill out. Go over the requirements for applying to TJ and make sure she understands what she needs to aim for. After that, it is pretty much done. Carson is our base school but DSs ES does not have a huge push for TJ. We still end up with 1 or 2 kids from his ES that goes to TJ but it is not something that most of the kids are focused on.
I would talk to your daughter about what has sparked her interest all of the sudden because this sounds new. Talk to her about what she is asking to do requires and what it means to go there. Let her do the work and apply next year. She seems to check the box for activities to write about in her essay next year. |
Then why do some schools see almost half their kids return to their base school? |
Really? What is the objective measure? because it sounds like they are admitting kids based on essays that are inherently ysubjective. |
I didn't realize the competition was that strong until DD wanted to apply. Honestly, I don't get why everyone is climbing all over each other to get in. As PP mentioned private schools are much better with more rounded kids. |
Citation? |
Because unlike private schools it is free and for the right kind of kids it is a fantastic environment |