![]() |
My point was if tables and chairs for a new school cost a million dollars, retrofitting the building is going to cost more than $2.4M. Do you know what the final budget was to redo Dorothy Hamm? Keep in mind that H-B Woodlawn was there for 40 years, functioning as a middle and high school with a full complement of programs serving 700 students (not even counting the Shriver program). APS spent $40 million to renovate and expand the existing building so that it could be a middle school that now enrolls....800 students. |
They essentially built a NEW 1/3 of the school. So yeah retrofitting existing office space for $10M would have been easy. Why are you just counting one year of interest? We are paying that debt for 30... |
Looking at the trend, I agree, they were growing. HB enrollment then suddenly went back down and based on the lottery admissions this past month for next school year, they have no plan to go back to the numbers they were at when the building first opened. March 2016: 232 MS, 425 HS, Total: 657 February 2017: 244 MS 441 HS Total:685 February 2018: 249 MS, 454 HS Total: 703 February 2019: 247 MS, 461 HS Total: 708 Move to new building February 2020: 243 MS, 473 HS Total:716 February 2021 241 MS, 449 HS, Total: 690 February 2022: (projection based on 6th/9th grade lottery admissions and current enrollment): 234 MS, 452 HS, Total: 686 (add a few admin transfers...so let's say they are back to 690) Essentially, all of the HB enrollment growth we were seeing is now gone and we are back to 2017 pre-move HB enrollment numbers. How is this acceptable when there is a huge waiting list? It doesn't matter if this year was weird. If someone left APS because they didn't like how things were mostly DL this year, someone on the waiting list should have been offered their seat. Did this not happen? Maybe I'm missing something but the numbers just don't add up - HB families keep telling me they are doing their fair share of growing like the rest of APS schools, but I'm not seeing it. Happy for someone to correct me and point out where the additional seats are located which would bring them up to 100% capacity of 775 seats. Please don't say it's the Shriver program. They have just about 35 seats. |
It cost Fairfax $10 million to convert an office building that they owned into a school, and it didn't have a gym or outdoor space. https://www.insidenova.com/news/arlington/fairfax-may-provide-prototype-for-arlington-schools-of-the-future/article_7eb48964-328a-11e4-bdf7-0019bb2963f4.html https://nationswell.com/fairfax-county-turns-high-rise-office-building-into-a-school/ But good luck getting taxpayers to agree to pay $10M to convert a rental. |
Why do people complain about the spending at The Heights and not Dorothy Hamm? They spent $100M in Rosslyn and got a new building for 775 students. They spent $40M in Cherrydale and got 100 seats. Um.......... |
Can't we all just agree that the problem isn't any one school but John Chadwick and the crazy building and overspending on schools that do not need to look like they could be on the cover of Architectural Digest to provide decent educations for our kids? |
Well, the fact that HB is still going to be under when other schools are struggling does point to HB being the problem. They should admit at least 5-10 from each MS for incoming 9th grade and 2-3 from each ES for 6th. |
Renovating an old building is always less cost effective per unit than building new, just like with a house. |
Why did they spend a dollar? HB was there and it was fine. They could have a) left HB there and built a middle school at The Heights (oh wait, the parents rejected that), b) moved HB and let the kids move into Vacation Lane as is (why was this not acceptable???) and saved $40 million either way. And now the south Arlington middle schools are huge compared to the north Arlington ones because Hamm is so far north all the moves came from Williamsburg and Swanson. |
I don't disagree, but it doesn't really make a difference. If HB takes 25 more kids from across the county each of the next four years, that is 100 kids, sure they can probably do it. But look at it the other way--enrollment at each of the three comprehensive high schools is over 2,000, and you would be removing 20 or 30 kids across four grades. That hardly helps a school that is over capacity. |
Why? Because of a bunch of complainers in Taylor. You can thank them for this inefficient use of space. |
It was too small, what are you talking about. It going to be a 1000 person middle school once the WM/SN grandfathering is over. That was the bulk of the renovation. The original parts got new lockers and paint. But excavating and construction next to an active in-person school is complicated and adds costs. |
Yes. I still have a 7th grader in APS. So less than 2 years until I bid adieu for good! |
Nope they are projecting 1000 more students per grade by the time your kid goes to school. If they haven't gotten around to building the 4th high school, what is the plan? Night shifts? DL for half your classes? Double decker trailers and lunch at 9am? https://www.apsva.us/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Fall-2019-28-APS-Enrollment-Report_v12_.pdf |