Your attempt to make a (false) equivalence between corruption in covering up massive, long-histories of child rape in the Catholic church, and lazy teaching or union corruption, doesn't help the opinion of the Catholic Church as a pedophile ring - and that many Catholics (not all), still make excuses for their centuries-long (perhaps inception-long) history of raping children. PP again. So basically, there are two anti-Catholic bigots here, and both of you also happen to be anti-union freaks who hate on teachers and public schools. I'm done with this forum. For the record, I'm not Catholic and my kids have attended private and public schools. But two bigotted, union-hating public school-bashers is two too many unsavory posters for me. |
I'm not sure how on earth you're gathering any of the above from PP's post. The didn't bash unions or public schools, and pointing out facts about an institution does not make anyone bigoted. |
| I'm a former Catholic and I could be considered as "hating on the Catholics." I'd describe myself currently as agnostic. |
OP here. Why criticise them rather than church practice or doctrine? |
Dude, my point is that you're whole hatred for the Catholic religion is based on the infallible nature of man. Priests sin, bishops sin, cardinals sin, the pope sins. Man is imperfect. But the teachings of the Church, the foundations of faith and morals, the principles and teachings are greater than the sins of men within the institution. It's like you're hyper focused on one issue, while ignoring the beauty of the faith. Throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Not all priests/clergy committed these heinous crimes; in fact it's a small minority. Yet you're determined to demonize the entire institution/religion regardless of situation. If you're a hammer looking for nails, then all you're going to see are the nails. If you're so caught up on one aspect of how the Church fucked up, then you're only going to see that aspect of it. Live and let live man. |
| Jack T. Chick. |
Sure individuals in positions of authority over the laity were raping kids, then when discovered, the kids and parents were hushed up, and the priests shuttled off to new parishes where they could rape again, with no warning given to their new charges. And of course there were people in the Church hierarchy that orchestrated this scheme, and have faced no repercussions whatsoever, and to this day hold positions of prestige and power. But *that's* not the institution. Stop hyper-focusing on the century old, institutional child raping--focus on the "beauty" of the words these men are saying. No thanks. |
Sure Stalin was a monster, but we shouldn't criticize the Communists ruling the Soviet Union during the 40s because, however imperfectly they implemented the lovely ideas of Marx, it's not about the men, it's about the beauty of the ideas. Sorry, institutions are comprised of people. |
Again, if we were having the same conversation about Islam, you would be considered a bigoted, ignorant, intolerant, prick. We get it, you hate the Catholic church, duly noted. But how about showing some respect for other people's religion/religious beliefs, and keep your bigoted, ignorant, intolerant comments to yourself? |
| Everyone but the catholics themselves? |
| NP - I don't think there are catholic haters on this board. Everyone from Lon Solomon, McLean Bible Church, the Baptists, etc. to the Mormons all get beat up. I don't "Hate" the Catholic church, but based upon first-hand long-time behavior of my mother-in-law, her biddy friends, my Catholic friends, and a horrendous experience at a private parochial school, my family will never become Catholic. I don't want to become that sort of person nor do they. For some reason (guilt? "We are going to heaven and you're not? I have no idea) Catholics seem to act in the least Christian way and hurt those around them through snobbery, gossip, uncharitable acts or narcississtic acts. Just IMHO. |
This is absolute horseshit, or based on your lack of understanding about religious differences. There is no leader of Islam. There is no institution. No organization. No hierarchy. Nothing that structurally resembles Catholicism in the slightest. That may cause other problems, but it's there is no comparison to Islam because it's structurally, comparably impossible. You know what Catholics can do to improve the image about their institution? Stop doing some kind of distraction switcharoo, telling people "hey! look what's going on over there!" when there is rampant and institutional child rape going on in their organization. Stop running from it, and confront it head on. I have FAR more respect for Catholics that don't try and play distraction games about the crimes in their church. They condemn it, they openly denounce it regularly, and they don't try and point elsewhere. |
Sounds like your typical DC/MD/NOVA resident, actually. That's quite the broad brush you're casting. Just like Muslims are terrorists, Jews are rich, elitist snobs, etc. There are douchebags in all walks of life.
|
So what if there's no "leader?" The people who died on 9/11 were murdered in the name of Islam. As are all the other countless, senseless murders, beheadings, rape, etc. done in the name of Islam around the world. Should I hold the same contempt for Islam? Or should I focus instead on all the peaceful Muslims who peacefully, devoutly practice their religion, the same way Mother Theresa, countless Saints, and millions of Catholics do/have over the centuries. Who's making excuses? I'm not arguing that there wasn't a sex scandal in the church, I acknowledge it, I condemn it, I despise it, and demand that it never happens again. But I don't perseverate on it like you do. I don't expect you to understand why I believe what I believe; you're not Catholic, and don't share the same beliefs about Christ's teachings. But live and let live and move the fuck on already. Forgiveness is a virtue, I feel sorry that you carry around so much resentment toward a group of people who strive to live loving, charitable, virtuous lives. |
ex catholic here. Yes every group has its douchebags, but some groups have more than their quota |