Does anyone have any experience with Burke AC, Team America, or SCAA? Looking at smaller clubs in the area. |
its because there are so many teams at ccl clubs. take the same boy or girl, same skills, and if they is on A team, they are magically happy, but a lower C team??, they get pissed!!, and rhen start watching other teams practice, comparing their kid to higher players, and all the crap. never mind that their kid has same ability in the end, and neither team is going to make them exponentially better ... or worse. that was what made us sick; crazy grown-ups comparing little boys and girls. look at all the pps talking about a stupid U9 tryout at one of the biggest CCL clubs and comparing who should be where and who is on what end of the field. run, don't walk. |
this was us too. the minute I heard the player bashing anytime a kid was asked to guest play up. I was done. I didn't want my kids in that environment. I didn't want myself in that environment. |
SCAA/South County is our local club and they rebranded from FCV to South County last year and it is a relatively young club. We went to the tryouts for U9 last year and I would say roughly 8 kids showed up. One of the players is our neighbor and they left mid year. He told me the training was subpar and that to complete the team they played up U8 rec players. Because of that in every game they were getting blown out by double digits and his kid didnt want to play anymore. Yes I know its not about winning but you hope it is atleast slightly competitive. He ate the remaining costs to make the switch. I looked at the coaching lineup and they changed coaches again for the 3rd yr straight. I know its not my direct experience but thought I would share. Not trying to sway anyone so perhaps still request to attend or seeing a practice and attend the tryouts. Perhaps it has or will get better. |
What the parents on the team they are guest playing on say is even worse a lot of the time. They see the kid as a threat to their own child's placement. The kids won't pass to the guest player either. |
So it depends on how much training you want. DCYFC is travel lite- 2x week training and one day a week winter in NW. Achilles is 3x a week(location? Lower or upper Montgomery Co. can be a pain if you are coming from DC). Stoddert travel I'd also an option for DC. I think is x3 a week in NW also. So the difference between travel and rec soccer is night and day. You have paid coaches and the players on average are the better players from rec. So think back on your son's games. Over the course of all his games, you may remember one or two kids who you thought were really good. Those are the player who will make up a top travel team or club soccer. These kids will get professional coaching 3x a week and will develop fairly quickly. They also develop faster because they play against better kids at practice. The speed of play is very noticeable(i.e. You do not get much time or space to screw around with the ball). Travel lite is in between a top travel team(big commitment, lots of training)and rec(no commitment, training questionable). At u9 you can play travel lite and develop. You do the same skill work just in a less demanding environment. You can always tell which players have technical skills at tryouts. If your son wants to tryout for a full travel team later(u10 or u11) he can. What you do is hire really good coach for private training the winter and spring before your travel tryout. |
Everyone else's kid is 'average at best'...until their own player starts moving down the chain. Then, it's complete outrage. How our these average kids getting promoted? See it time and time again as their kids age upwards. It's harder for the parents to take, then the kids most of the time. |
ADP is a good program, and all my kids have done it - but it is a slower pace of play than travel - but all games are in Arlington - which is a plus. You get one professional coached session and a parent coached session. Travel does require more of a time and parent involvement requirement - all parents must sign up for certain duties. It is challenging when kids have to play above their grade since they don't really get to play with their classmates - but you'll face that with ADP as well. |
Posters here bashin' youngers at tryouts now too. They think their 7 yr old is better then some other 7 yr old. Really? Already? Having seen this in action with olders, it is mostly middle tier players and their families. The very top and very bottom tiers seem less affected, at least initially. |
Something must have changed, because I saw their U9s play a couple of weeks ago and thought they were OK. They weren't playing a particularly good team, but they were certainly outplaying the opposition and playing the "right" way (passing, dribbling, not kickball). |
To some extent, I've seen parents on the A team viciously bad-mouth kids below for the threat of their kid's spot. They are by far the most type-A of the bunch. |
Thanks this is helpful. The costs/commitment seem on par with other teams and the location is good. I am familiar with the new coaches. I guess my son could go to tryouts and see what it is like. I'm not super interested in 3 days/week for a second grader. Is that the norm around here?? |
Yes, but not until last year. The change to birth year from school calendar year majorly sucks and is the reason you have kids in lower grades starting too soon. |
Crap my kid guest plays up every so often. Does that mean he is getting bad mouthed?? I have never seen that type of behavior on our sidelines one way or another. The only way you could know about it is if you engage in that sort of discussion. I would say its ok to observe and comment on strong and weak players...I would not consider that bad mouthing by any means. |
There you have it. Parents saying the kid is weak and shouldn't be there. The coach pulled him up or down. Shut your mouth. It's assholish to be talking about kids. |