Forum Index
»
Advanced Academic Programs (AAP)
They don’t need to. Plenty of jealous people out here will tell. |
Maybe they could set up bounties like in Texas to rat out your neigbhors. |
Shhhh, there are parents who hate it when you point this truth out. |
Stop. Just stop. You are calling a bunch of canards "the truth." What exactly is an "overprepped kid" versus a gifted kid that preps? What exactly is a "wealthy school" and what if you are not wealthy and attend that school? What do you mean by "mediocre" and how is that measured and compared to who and what? What makes you "less affluent" and does it matter where you go to school? And what exactly do you mean by "far greater promise" - some aspirational and subjective wish versus actual results? |
Tryly gifted children don't require prep. It's strictly for the strivers. |
| You could say that about TJ as a whole, yet the TJ AAG types clearly were heavily invested in "diversifying" TJ when the real equity move would have been to disband it entirely. |
Just so you know, wishful thinking almost never comes true.
Didn't happen under a dem guv. Ain't happening under a Republican. |
And.. what's wrong with striving? Are you raising your kids to be slackers? Training them to live off the strivers maybe? What's your game plan? It's the strivers that build the world and society you mooch off of... Not some random geniuses or slackers (like your kids will be, based on your disdain for strivers). |
|
Striver could be used to describe kids look look after younger siblings until their parent(s) get home from work. It could describe those who work minimum wage jobs after school to pay the household bills. Those are activities that hinder being able to do extra prep for a school that none of your community go to and you can’t afford the bus or extra commuting time required to attend anyway.
Prep is fine but for a public education access should be equally accessible to all. |
Fine. Then for kids that just aren't that bright - what do we do for them? Since it should be equally accessible to all, it sounds like you are advocating for a lottery with no minimum requirements. A lottery will also help provide equal access for the lazy kids too. Great plan. |
Not sure what a "striver" is, but I assume you mean hard working children that work to close the ability gap. We certainly reward strivers in sports, music, etc. - basically anywhere merit is a measure. Not sure a "striver" needs prep, but maybe that want to bust ass and leave no doubt that they belong by doing the best they can do and "striving" to crush the admissions test. |
I agree with that. Problem is how to provide an "elite" education for free for everyone that qualifies. We will need many more TJs for this to happen. More tax if need be (I'm willing to pay). However, that's unlikely to happen. So the fight for limited resources will continue. As you point out, some of the strivers (as you define it) unfortunately cannot attend TJ given the extra time commitment. So why the hatred from folks against parents/kids that can make it happen for their kids? |
It would appear that current school system logic is that families of poor students do not have the same time or focus to devote to studies as average students. Therefore, a metric (GPA) which is based primarily on devoting time and focus to studies will put poor students at a relative advantage. It wouldn't be controversial to say that the new system successfully does one thing: it uses criteria that's sufficiently non-discerning, that the the candidate pool is broad and thus selection by population distribution is possible. I do not believe that the new system can successfully distinguish which students have inflated their GPA through blow-off classes. I do not believe that the new system is better at distinguishing students who have above-and-beyond intellectual intuition. I do not believe that the new system emphasizes things in the right way to allow students to succeed if they are poor but measurably smarter than everyone else (I say this as someone with parents who were in this category). I do not believe that the new system sufficiently precludes selecting people based on preferential personal politics and ability to tell a good sob story. |
The hatred is because they are Asian or White. |
Tell that to all the national math and science contest winners, or even to the average USAMO qualifier. They must have done it all without trying because they are so gifted! The quicker you discard "gifted children" from your vocabulary, the farther you will go in life. |