Except that’s not what you said. It’s ridiculous for them to have two different lessons. This was overly complicated. Glad they are simplifying. |
OK, but it seems logical that while female students should learn a bit about male student anatomy and male students should learn a bit about female anatomy, especially at these early ages, they should spend most of their time learning some practical things about themselves. Combining the two groups means that either you shortchange or you increase the time allotted, leaving less room in the schedule for everything else. |
Wrong. They shouldn’t just learn “a bit”.
WTf is wrong with you? |
The problem with me is that I live in a world where time and attention are limited resources. Boys really don't need to learn all the details of the female reproductive system the same way that girls don't need to learn all about the male reproductive system. A girl, unless she's one with a penis, does not need a full forty-five minutes learning how to check her balls for testicular cancer. A boy, unless she has a uterus, does not need to spend an entire class period on the pros and cons of tampons vs menstrual cups. |
Lol. The fainting incidences occurred a few years apart! BUT, they both happened during the menstruation talk. |
And let's be honest. Those girls weren't wrong. |
Exactly, and like another PP said, this time is taken from other instructional time. So at MINIMUM 5 hours taken from science and social studies - 2 subjects that are already short changed. |
Yes, it’s exactly what PP had said. Still stupid. |
No, it’s not. We can see what she wrote. Just scroll up. |
PP said they learn about both genders in 5th and up. |
| FLE used to start in 5th grade. Now it starts in 4th. The 4th grade lessons are strictly related to one sex though. But in 5th they do learn about both genders. That’s exactly what PP said. It’s not they they never learn about both genders, it just starts in 5th. She was saying stop yelling about learning about how genders bc they actually do. |
You forgot to read the next part which says….because they do. There is no need to yell that they aren’t doing that because they do. How is that not clear? |
Nope that’s not what she said at all. She explained what FCPS currently does. She didn’t say what they should do. Currently in FCPS, they do learn about both genders beginning in 5th grade. That has never changed over the years. What has changed is they added two new lessons in 4th about puberty for one sex. So girls leaver about girls in 4th. Boys learn about boys in 4th. |
Since puberty is starting earlier for all kids except those taking puberty blockers, this makes sense. |
|
What's really horrifying is that some kids don't learn about this at home, from a parent/caretaker. I get that we need it taught in schools because it's basic info everyone truly needs to know, but when we talk about more or less instructional time being lost to teach about it it just hits home how much basic info some families punt to schools to teach their kids.
My kids have known about male/female anatomical differences and details of human reproduction since at least age 8. Why is this info so rarefied and secret?? |