Did he figure out a way to work around the sperm's life expectancy in the uterine environment? Or did he figure out a way to say sperm doesn't really mean sperm, and womb doesn't really mean womb, and it was not really forty days. Maybe you should ask him. But wait. He doesn't actually want to talk about it any more. Hmmm. |
But there is such a thing as a devout Muslim who has only the most passing knowledge of the Koran. This pretty much suffices--one doesn't have to have recourse to Arabic or learned scholars or have a really deep understanding of what is in the Koran; I maintain that to say so borders on heresy. Further, you don't have to have any knowledge of the Koran to convert. All that conversion to Islam requires is a recitation of "there is no god but God...." in front of witnesses. It does not require that you demonstrate knowledge of the Koran. |
I agree that many devout Muslims have only the most passing knowledge of the Quran. The question, however, is: is it possible to be a devoted Muslim and disagree or reject parts of the Quran? By the way, I know you mean well, but your statement about "all that conversion requires is a recitation..." is taken, chapter and verse, from the salafi dawwah playbook in the U.S. - convert now and learn later. |
With all due respect I understand the expression "those whom their right hands possess" (i.e., "those whom they rightfully possess") relates either to slaves taken captive in a war and/or, to all who are dependent on another for their livelihood and thus become the latters' responsibility. The placing of one's dependants on an equal footing with oneself with regard to the basic necessities of life. How did you arrive at it as just being slaves? While it is fac that the pre-Islamic society had slavery, I question the use of it solely in the phrase since the word Abd (slave,who is totally subordinated) would have then been used to relate that fact. ...And [also prohibited (for marriage) to you are all] married women except those your right hands possess. [This is] the decree of Allah upon you. And lawful to you are [all others] beyond these, [provided] that you seek them [in marriage] with [gifts from] your property, desiring chastity, not unlawful sexual intercourse. So for whatever you enjoy [of marriage] from them, give them their due compensation as an obligation. And there is no blame upon you for what you mutually agree to beyond the obligation. Indeed, Allah is ever Knowing and Wise. I see that as you could marry slave or dependent and also saying it is unlawful to have sex unless married and they must be virgins to wed. Not an argument. Just a conundrum. |
You cannot marry a slave. Marriage is a contract between equals, concubinage is relationship between owner and property. Marrying a slave requires manumission first. This is what this verse means: marry chaste single women (which requires a dowry), if you can't afford a dowry, manumit your slave and marry her. |
| Chaste does not meant virgin. It just means someone who has sex only with people they're supposed to. A divorced woman with no boyfriends is chaste, even though she's clearly not a virgin any more. |
As are those who rape women, wife or concubine. The permission to have sex is not the same as condoning rape. The captives spouses were dead. Many of their relatives might be dead. What would you have done with them? |
If you do not trust others to translate the Quran, then you must learn Quranic Arabic yourself. |
Since you're all about Dr. Moore, let's shed a bit more light on his involvement in the business of Islamic embryology. A long time ago, in the 1980s, Dr. Moore was invited by the Embryology Committee of King Abdulaziz University to produce a special 3rd edition of his most successful book "The Developing Human" specifically for use by Muslim students in Islamic Universities. He was paid by the Saudi royal family for the use of his name, and for no real additional work. The textbook he delivered to the Saudi Universities that commissioned the work is titled, "The Developing Human: Clinically Oriented Embryology with Islamic Additions." http://www.islamicbookstore.com/b6147.html The base textbook was work that Moore had completed years before. He did nothing new for this new edition. The “Islamic additions” are actually the work of an Abdul Majeed al-Zindani, so it alternates chapters of standard science with Zindani's "Islamic additions". (here's the review of the book, if anyone is interested) Reviewer: Stop Spamming While based on an original embryology textbook, this edition is a disgrace to any medically educated student. All pages describing reality have been removed and in its place Koranic texts have been inserted by a Muslim. The resulting book does not describe embryology as experienced all over the world, but the wishful thinking of a religious group. This book does not appear on Dr. Moore's CV and is not available outside the Islamic region, such as a Western public library or Amazon. Now, what is so special about the book? Here is what the publisher, Abu Qasim Publishing House, Saudi Arabia, has to say: Now available! Numerous Muslims have constantly referred to the work of acclaimed embryologist Keith L. Moore. Here is his complete original textbook (third edition), superbly updated with the "Islamic Additions" (commentary, relevance, Qur'an and Hadith references, and more) of Shaykh Abdul-Majeed A. Azzindani of Saudi Arabia. Moore's popular textbook is written primarily for students of medicine, specializing in clinically oriented embryology. Shaykh Azzindani, a reputed scholar of Islam, has been interested in the same phenomenon on but from the perspective of the teachings of the Qur'an and Hadith. The two collaborated, with other scientists, in the relation of the two foci of thought. The volume herein conclusively shows that the information contained in the Qur'an and Sunnah is not only consistent with modern scientific discoveries in the field of embryology but also it is a fore-runner by some fourteen hundred years. Now, who is Mr. Azzindani, this reputed scholar of Islam, the beacon of knowledge, who interspersed Dr. Moore's writing with Islamic bits? He is the founder and head of the Iman University in Yemen, head of the Yemeni Muslim Brotherhood political movement and founder of the Commission on Scientific Signs in the Quran and Sunnah, based in Saudi Arabia. (Yes, they really do call it that.) This is the outfit dedicated to underwriting the work of scientists who need a Ferrari or a second home badly enough to write what Al-Saud wants to see written, and in the process, convincing gullible westerners that Quran is a scientific miracle. Interestingly, the acknowledgments for the book recognize a number of “distinguished scholars” who supported the book with time or money. And number 6 on the list is Saifullah (Sword of God) Shaykh Osama bin Laden. What else is Mr. Azzindani famous for? I tell ya, finding the cure for AIDS. No kidding. Yes, it's another case of "I have a cure but I'm not gonna tell you what it is." You can read for yourself: http://www.yemenpost.net/27/InvestigationAndInterview/20081.htm He also discovered a scientific proof of why women can't talk and think at the same time. I don't time to post a link but it's all over the web. So, you still think Dr. Moore omitted all traces of this work from his CV because he is...hounded by Islamophobes? Nah. The man is embarrassed. I bet he thinks "damn be the day I accepted this commission. What do I need that money for, anyway? Damn, damn, damn." |
Me? I'd have sex with them. Wild, unbridled, no-holds-barred sex. I'd ride them up and down till the crack of dawn. That's just me, though. |
It's not me who doesn't trust others. It's an article of faith for the Muslim discourse that the Quran is untranslatable and all translations are too feeble to convey the glory of the holy book. That's why, when reasonable people express doubts about something in the Quran, they are told to sit down and shut up because "you don't understand Arabic, and you have to." |
Not rape -- excuse me, force sex, on them. Jesus, literally. |
Who was it who was wondering whether PP is a troll trying to get us to hate Muslims? Or, maybe there's a new shift at the madrassa, and a real idiot is on duty now. |
|
+1, thanks! |