Forum Index
»
Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS)
|
" And the candlelight vigil is underway "
I saw some beautiful photos of that on facebook. |
Not all depression is "irrational". Can we face some reality? |
|
I don't suppose anyone will ever breathe a peep about what issues either student was depressed about. If, however, as someone here has speculated, no one really knows, right there is your answer. No one took the time and made the effort to really know these young people.
So hey, let's just keep up the guessing game. Maybe start getting to know your own kids and their classmates? But when, you ask? Hard to say, since you can't much pull off "speed" anything with your kid. It's all about "slow" parenting, giving our kids whatever time they need. What's the rush, anyways? The kids who get the most firm foundations, are the ones most likely to make it through the tough times. |
| I think the things that the kids were depressed about are known I just don't think anyone thought it would rise to the level of taking their own lives. That's the thing about depression it is irrational-- it's a disease that unless you have it or have had it you have trouble understanding. |
That is not true. Depression can have some really specific causes. Remove those causes and depression lifts. |
| That's not depression that's sadness. While related they are not the same thing. |
Sad people, especially teenagers who are prone to impulsivity, can still act on it. So if the end result can be the same, there is no difference. |
A don't think even a Dr Phil would say something like this. |
No, it is situational depression. |
If you're getting a divorce after 25 years of marriage, and are experiencing depression, please explain how you perceive that as irrational. |
|
Anonymous wrote: I think the things that the kids were depressed about are known I just don't think anyone thought it would rise to the level of taking their own lives. That's the thing about depression it is irrational-- it's a disease that unless you have it or have had it you have trouble understanding. If you're getting a divorce after 25 years of marriage, and are experiencing depression, please explain how you perceive that as irrational. Because you should have known going in that it was 50/50 at best that you wouldn't get divorced... |
Your answer speaks of a person who isn't especially knowledgable about depression. |
| Exactly. Read this http://www.healthline.com/health-blogs/bipolar-bites/whats-difference-between-sadness-depression. You should be sad if you are going through a divorce. It's rational to feel "depressed". But that is not clinical depression. |
Who cares about splitting hairs over semantics, when all you're really doing is guessing anyways. |
When we turn everything into a 'I can't help it' or 'it's not my fault' situation, we are much less likely try to pull ourselves out of a hole. Every case of depression is not clinical. |