|
OP here, I originally posted this thread on the Off topic board and was baffled when I saw that it had disappeared-- only to find it here. IMO this topic has zero to do with religion, so I am not sure why it was moved here.
This, I believe, is part of why I find the subject to be so intriguing...no one knows what to do with it or how to treat it. It's taboo. |
I can’t say I truly believe you, but I definitely want to. |
But isn’t it your question the fundamental question of all religions? Where did we come from? Where do we go? |
Religion at its base involves the worship or belief of a god. My question has nothing to do with god, heaven or hell. It's much bigger than that, which is likely the reason I am having difficulty articulating it. I respect differing religious beliefs and I have my own, but this not a religious question. My question really has more to do with why people don't question it when we question everything else. Loved ones essentially disappear/vanish from your life and you grieve the loss, but never really delve into where they are. I guess I am just amazed at that part. Everyone so easily accepts the disappearance without questionning how. Maybe this is grief talking, but I have always had a curious mind so it does not surprise me that this is the way I express my grief via curiosity. |
I think the practice of religion involves worship of a god or entity, but the many sacred texts weigh in on the fundamental question which leads me to believe that these are the fundamental questions. And people DO question it all the time, and there are examples of movies and literature that delve into the "where"...but ultimately it can lead someone to madness because there will never be an answer that will provide us with 100% certainty. Individually, though, the questions will lead some to reaffirm their existing faith, maybe to to find a new faith, or to lost their faith all together. Personally, I feel I am more of a hopeful nihilist/stoic. I don't truly "believe" in anything but the scientific explanation...that our bodies break down and the atoms are reabsorbed into the universe. However, I do "feel" that we are more than atoms and are part of a greater consciousness and maybe we re-join that once our time in the bodies is passed. I am sorry for you loss, OP. |
I think you are totally correct about the potential madness exploring the subject could cause. It's just so very fascinating because there is no answer. I also fear that you are correct about the scientific explanation...that is actually my biggest fear and the ending I would like the least. I would never commit suicide, but I often wonder if some who did were simply curious about what was behind the curtain. |
|
My mother often wondered about NDE's and life after death. She had many interesting experiences in her life that led her to thinking about them. She did not share her thoughts with many people, but she did with my sister and I when we became adults. I have often thought about them as well, as I too had many unique experiences in my life that are unexplainable with our limited senses.
My mother passed away 9 years ago from cancer at the age of 57. My step father called me and I went to the hospital. I got there about 2 hours after she passed. My grandfather, aunt and uncle, step father and godparents were all in the room. My mothers clothes were neatly folded on a table against the wall and her glasses were sitting on top of them. Everyone in the room was very still and quiet. All of the sudden we hear something fall. I looked on the floor and it was her glasses that fell down. Nobody was near the table and the glasses were firmly planted on the clothes. When this happened, I had a tingling sensation in my stomach and I started crying. I had the idea pop into my head that my mother was communicating that she could see us. It truly could have been coincidence, but it was pretty wild and felt more than coincidence. |
You think people who didn't believe in the afterlife are now sending messages from the afterlife? If so, what are they saying? |
To me, it sounds like a very nice dream, that would have ended if your died and instead ended when you woke up. I'm glad it's enhanced your life. I think no one can say that this is what will happen to everyone when they die. It's one dream among many. I think the greatest likelihood is what we see with other living things. They are born, they live, they die and decay into the earth. I try not to worry about dying and instead focus on being grateful for being alive -- which was not a given at all -- it's a tremendous accident that any of us ever made it into life. |
It comforted you at the time, which was a very good thing, whether or not it was really your mother trying to communicate. |
The part about the music reminds me of my father's experience. He died during surgery and was resuscitated. Ten years later, I asked him about the time he was dead. He told me he heard the "music of the spheres". He wouldn't/couldn't elaborate because it is indescribable. |
Very true. |
Not necessarily, it is also scientific question and a lot of scientists attempted to answer this question. |
You are wrong, there is an answer. You have to sick it and you will find it. |
Well, religion predates science. And the earliest scientists were often religious...at least until they were labeled heretics and condemned to death. It’s definitly, though, falls under “philosophy” which also overlaps science and religion. |