Eyeliner great stays put

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Another +1 for the Laura Mercier cake eyeliner that you have to use a brush with, but it's not very dark/dramatic as previous posters have noted. But it doesn't budge, and I've tried it through everything - yoga, out in the rain, crying, etc.

Under eye as well? Nice!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote: Urban Decay Primer + Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

+1.... still looks perfect after a full day!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My problem is the liner smudges on my lower lash line. I have hooded lids and dark circles, where I use concealer under my eyes, if that makes a difference. What's a girl to do?

Hello face twin. Are you also very pale? I have used and enjoyed many an eyeliner that stays well enough on my top lid, but nothing on the bottom till Charlotte Tilbury's Rock and Khol in Veruschka Mink. I think it is the name? She has two eyeliners, but the color is right. Applied very sparingly it smudges like I like, then sets for the day. It wears away just a smidge, but that may have as much to do with the fact that I wear so little.

I could try to remember drugstore options that work better, but in most cases, i save more if I just buy the one thing I can actually swatch in store, you know?

Just wanted to follow up and say I got the brown Charlotte Tilbury eye liner and love it! It hardly smudges on my lower line and stays put. When I try to take it off, it's really hard to do. Thanks for the rec!