18yo daughter obsessed with marriage—not boyfriends—what should I tell her?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Have you asked her what she's looking for in a husband?


Yes, it’s seems unrealistic.


How so?

It’s a lot..
Believes in soulmates and true love.
1. Wealthy
2. Extremely ambitious and successful
3. Charismatic and outgoing personality
4. Perfect physical appearance
5. The "ideal" personality—someone who meets all her emotional and personal needs
6. High social status
7. Perfect match in every way (financial, emotional, personality)
8. Perfect family background
9. No flaws in character
10. Prioritizes her above anyone else
11. Always on the same page


The word "perfect" appears three times in that list. No one is perfect.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Have you asked her what she's looking for in a husband?


Yes, it’s seems unrealistic.


How so?

It’s a lot..
Believes in soulmates and true love.
1. Wealthy
2. Extremely ambitious and successful
3. Charismatic and outgoing personality
4. Perfect physical appearance
5. The "ideal" personality—someone who meets all her emotional and personal needs
6. High social status
7. Perfect match in every way (financial, emotional, personality)
8. Perfect family background
9. No flaws in character
10. Prioritizes her above anyone else
11. Always on the same page



And what does she think she has to offer? Besides a tight teenager bod and vajayjay, I mean.
Anonymous
Tell her to look for someone who values family and can put her first
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:She sounds manic. Possibly bipolar?


Not even close. Sounds like a typical emotionally immature and inexperienced 18 yo girl who just so happens to speak her mind freely. She's far from the only one like this! But most don't tell their mothers.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Have you asked her what she's looking for in a husband?


Yes, it’s seems unrealistic.


How so?

It’s a lot..
Believes in soulmates and true love.
1. Wealthy
2. Extremely ambitious and successful
3. Charismatic and outgoing personality
4. Perfect physical appearance
5. The "ideal" personality—someone who meets all her emotional and personal needs
6. High social status
7. Perfect match in every way (financial, emotional, personality)
8. Perfect family background
9. No flaws in character
10. Prioritizes her above anyone else
11. Always on the same page


Well, she is 18 and those are idealistic criteria. Not a single thing on that list is an inherently BAD thing to have in a partner, just very unrealistic as you said. You can help her understand where her criteria are too rigid or help guide her away from stuff you don't think "should be" a priority in a relationship. You are her mom and get to tell her what you think is important. I personally would be encouraging my daughter to steer away from stuff like "high social status" and "wealthy" but might keep the stuff that is more "career driven and ambitious" in order to prioritize a value of hard work or being financially successful or however we defined it.

Overall, it sounds like she's a kid with a kid list. That's a good reason for her to date people and see how reality matches up to this Disney princess fantasy you've got here.


She’s had plenty of chances to date but turned them all down because she’s holding out for her idea of the ‘perfect’ husband, not just a boyfriend. And now she’s asking me where she’s supposed to find one.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Have you asked her what she's looking for in a husband?


Yes, it’s seems unrealistic.


How so?

It’s a lot..
Believes in soulmates and true love.
1. Wealthy
2. Extremely ambitious and successful
3. Charismatic and outgoing personality
4. Perfect physical appearance
5. The "ideal" personality—someone who meets all her emotional and personal needs
6. High social status
7. Perfect match in every way (financial, emotional, personality)
8. Perfect family background
9. No flaws in character
10. Prioritizes her above anyone else
11. Always on the same page


Well, she is 18 and those are idealistic criteria. Not a single thing on that list is an inherently BAD thing to have in a partner, just very unrealistic as you said. You can help her understand where her criteria are too rigid or help guide her away from stuff you don't think "should be" a priority in a relationship. You are her mom and get to tell her what you think is important. I personally would be encouraging my daughter to steer away from stuff like "high social status" and "wealthy" but might keep the stuff that is more "career driven and ambitious" in order to prioritize a value of hard work or being financially successful or however we defined it.

Overall, it sounds like she's a kid with a kid list. That's a good reason for her to date people and see how reality matches up to this Disney princess fantasy you've got here.


She’s had plenty of chances to date but turned them all down because she’s holding out for her idea of the ‘perfect’ husband, not just a boyfriend. And now she’s asking me where she’s supposed to find one.


I think you need to ask her how she's going to find out the characteristics of a potential husband if she is unwilling to date anyone. After all, it's boyfriends that turn into husbands. If her perfect future husband had asked her out and she turned him down, she wouldn't even know about the missed opportunity.
Anonymous
I give my daughter the feedback which I learned from observing my parents’s terrible relationship. My mom never provided guidance.

Find a good man who will be a good provider. Women who have to work while having kids have it very, very hard. You are pretty, smart, and kind, and therefore, you can afford to be picky.
Anonymous
I wish I had tried harder for marriage when I was younger. I instead was looking for fun and a soulmate and now I'm old and divorced because I ended up settling when I realized my biological clock was ticking.

Though honestly, I am so different now than when I was 20 that maybe it wouldn't have worked out either. But I think it's not backward or terrible to be thinking about marriage at 18.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Uhh...tell her how to find a good husband and what to look for. Many of us met our husbands in college. Many of the most balanced people I know did. One quality can be "find someone who supports your education and success and wants you to reach your full potential"


What exactly should I tell her? I married the first man that I dated so I don’t have a lot of experience.


Tell her that. Tell her it worked out well for you but you think dating other men first might have been good, too.
Anonymous
What is your dh like? That’s likely the kind of man she’s going to marry.
Anonymous
Introduce her to DCUM and ask her if this is what she wants. DCUM is full of failed marriages
Anonymous
Tell her that being overfixated on marriage as a goal can make it more likely that she will sacrifice on serious issues just to acheive the goal of marriage.

That marriage isn't a be all end all, and that there are plenty people who might want to get married but not near as many who are able and interested in building a healthy relationship and a successful family life.

That being married might seem fun and magical, but that it is a choice that will have a large effect on the entire trajectory of her future and that of any children she may have.

That, of course.You hope that she finds someone she would like to build a future with, but you trust this will happen all in good time, and that if it was up to you, you would like to see her having fun building her own life and figuring out her own adult self, while enjoying getting to know the various men that will cross her path.
Anonymous
Get curious about why she is so interested in it
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Uhh...tell her how to find a good husband and what to look for. Many of us met our husbands in college. Many of the most balanced people I know did. One quality can be "find someone who supports your education and success and wants you to reach your full potential"


What exactly should I tell her? I married the first man that I dated so I don’t have a lot of experience.


Well if you are happy with your choice then you did something right. Tell her about it.
Tell her not to wait too long to have kids. Out of college, 5 years of work, time to have a kid.
Anonymous
I wish I was as smart as your daughter. I wasn’t thinking about marriage or family at 18 or 28. After 30, the options get bleak. Unless you’re Meghan Markel.
post reply Forum Index » Tweens and Teens
Message Quick Reply
Go to: