You know that both can be true, right? Do you think the Chinese government was lying when they admitted they had a problem with so many bridges falling down and killing people, out of, what? A desire to make poor America feel better? |
Chinese bridges fall down while bridges in Minnesota fall, railway disasters in Ohio spill tons of toxic chemicals, lead leeches into waterways feeding Flint Michigan, levees fail and ruin the entire city of New Orleans, the DC metro is constantly on fire, large portions of the big dig in Boston had to be redone due to shoddy work, Texas and California powergrids routinely fail, US airports suck and America's own engineers give the US a near bottom rating for our own infrastructure: https://www.npr.org/2021/03/03/973054080/potholes-grid-failures-aging-tunnels-and-bridges-nations-infrastructure-gets-a-c Americans love to dish it out but can't take it. They have a million excuses for why the US infrastructure is decades behind the modern first world. Americans simply can't wrap their brains around the fact that we are no longer exceptional, we aren't #1, our systems are stupid, our engineering stinks, and that we need to shutup and learn from other people in the world who are doing it better, which *gasp* can include the Chinese. It is entirely a bunch of American hubris thinking we do everything the best and they our ways are the right way. Go take a tour in Tokyo to see their drainage system yourself in person: https://www.tokyoweekender.com/japan-life/take-tour-tokyos-underground-temple-concrete/ It will blow your mind. Somehow the wealthiest country in the world can't do similar things to save our cities like New Orleans, but we have trillions of dollars for bombs. The US is decades behind now. |
| China owns the land, property rights are minimal. Lack of unions, minimal regulations |
This is the other trendy thing that YIMBYs are advocating for now, eliminate environmental reviews and let companies do whatever they want without accountability ugh. Yes, there are some reforms that can be made, but eliminating environmental review is a mistake. I am very concerned that any reform proposed by the YIMBYs will be a complete handout to wealthy special interest groups that want to avoid accountability. Also, $94 Million per mile is not remotely cheap and that is still very expensive to build a metro line. |
Saving New Orleans is very stupid and it does not make any logical sense financially. The entire city is already below sea level minus a very small portion adjacent to the Mississippi. Also, the sea level is rising by around half an inch per year and the city is sinking by up to 2 inches per year. It is a complete waste of resource to try to protect a city that is so vulnerable to hurricanes and already below sea level. |
China is a totalitarian state that can leverage its power to achieve whatever it likes. They want your land for new apartments or to build a train - done. They want your company's technology for the military - done. They will probably pay you, but they don't have to. Don't have COVID but the state has declared it a pandemic and mandated you stay in your home no matter what? - done. The police or worse will be dispatched to deal with you if you don't like it. Practice a religion that the state doesn't like? Oh well, not anymore. So that's how. |
Tokyo is below sea level, doofus. Yet the Japanese can do some of the most impressive feats of engineering in human history to keep Tokyo viable while Americans can't even supply people in Flint with potable water. Keep making excuses. When will you finally admit the US isn't exceptional anymore because we have all of our priorities backwards, have subpar engineering, and simply the way we do things is absolutely illogical? But go ahead, keep crapping on the Chinese when they've lifted almost 500M people out of poverty in the span of only 30 years. Once again, Americans love to hurl it and can't take it. Then they have every excuse in the book for why they're so wealthy yet have infrastructure they really hasn't improved since the 1950s. |
"We."
You ought to look in the mirror, son. Nobody is sitting around chumping on China, but you're here with a chip on your shoulder saying it's only the US that has a problem with criticism. Nobody is denying that the US has problems, but you seem to be on a real tear about denying problems in China specifically. If you want to bring up Flint, MI (agreed that this is a tragedy and national embarrassment) and the other non-bridge issues, you should be able to field these: ----- Why did you all contaminate infant formula deliberately with melamine, causing kidney stones and kidney failure, just to make a buck? "Investigations showed that melamine had been deliberately added to diluted raw milk to boost its apparent protein content." That's BABIES. Incredible. Never would have passed US regulation. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2799451/ Speaking of food safety, as you have brought up toxic chemicals, China is using fuel tankers that carried toxic chemicals to transport cooking oil. Good lord, that is absolutely avoidable, isn't it? https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cml2kr9wkdzo You mentioned a US railway disaster. China is far from free of those: List of rail accidents in China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rail_accidents_in_China The US also isn't committing frank genocide within its own borders, either. The Uyghur genocide is more than a tragedy and embarrassment -- it's absolutely evil. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-22278037 ----- None of this mitigates anything that happens in the US, of course. It is all a part and parcel of a country that -- like the US -- has its failures and successes. You really should come to terms with the reality of China's own problems. They won't get fixed otherwise. |
Yeah, no, that would be you. You came in swinging. |
I agree with some of this. I'm 53 and the more I reflect I think our issues really started in the late 70's/80's when conservatives adopted government is the enemy as a mantra. Reagan really fu*ked us. |
Apparently CHina can't help itself from poisoning literal infants just to make a few extra bucks, so -- glass houses. |
As opposed to the USA where drugs are contaminated with meningitis due to shoddy oversight, resulting in 100 deaths and sickened almost 80/: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_England_Compounding_Center_meningitis_outbreak Keep on trying to dish it. I bet you can't take it. |
|
OP, how could you forget the Tiananmen Square massacre? The Chinese government sent tanks and military out against its own people, with thousands of deaths all across China. Not just in Beijing. That doesn't make Flint or anything else in the US okay. It does mean that pointing fingers at the US looks pretty hypocritical. Nobody in this thread -- no one -- has been a nationalist champion intolerant of criticism, other than you. The US responders agree with the very real problems you raise. You, however, are the one who can dish it but won't seem to take it. |
Oh, that's an error. But in China, the contaminant was added deliberately. You still haven't even acknowledged that, have you? |
China is Authoritarian not totalitarian like North Korea but you have good points. |