Forum Index
»
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)
My kids are actually AP kids, but this feels wrong. AP kids can be "pointy" and just not take exams in subjects in which they don't excel. IB kids are forced to test in all areas, including foreign language. That feels much better-rounded. To answer OP's question, AP is probably best for kids looking at conventional paths in highly rejective US colleges. DE is better for kids who don't really care about a "traditional" HS experience, and IB is better for kids aiming for international universities or for a narrow swathe of US colleges that value kids with global perspectives. |
|
Among all three I think IB is the least appealing option.
You sign your life away for two years and take 3 high level classes spanning two years and other 3 standard level classes each year. As far as advanced coursework, standard level are not considered college level so you’re left with only the three high level ones that would be comparable with AP classes. When you draw the line, over two years you took the equivalent of three AP classes, plus the other standard classes that are somewhere around regular/honor classes. In contrast, AP and DE, you can take a path that’s as rigorous as you can handle. It’s not uncommon for AP kids to have 12 AP classes, or hard working DE kids to get an associate degree. |
Ok, so that means she started Calculus in 11 grade as she entered the early college program and she is doing all classes at college. What’s the plan after completing the two years at MC, how far is she in the program and is she applying to regular universities now? I hope I don’t sound too intrusive, thinking about this path for my kid, also strong in math, high percentiles etc. |
IB teacher here who really knows what goes into earning the IB diploma: I’m impressed by both students, with an edge to the IB one. That student took all advanced coursework AND completed a 11-14 page paper on the side AND completed an additional 75 hours of service / activities. I also know the IB rubrics are very demanding, and that IB students become amazing writers. |
AND have parents who half-brag/half-complain about how stressed the kids are, and how college was a breeze afterward. |
The bragging/complaining part comes standard with the IB diploma, it is part of the program culture. |
|
IB is “mine is better” program
IB: in recognition of how hard I worked, I get a diploma in the end DE: I get an AA diploma AP: I get national merit scholar IB: MINE IS BETTER! AP, DE: shrug IB: I do a lot of writing DE: I am taking a creative writing class AP: I write a lot in AP English and AP History IB: I WROTE MORE! AP, DE: shrug IB: I was well prepared for college! DE: I took actual college classes! AP: My classes were college equivalent IB: I WAS BETTER PREPARED FOR COLLEGE! AP, DE: shrug |
DE: I finished half of my BS degree in high school AP: I got credit for most of my general education requirements and sophomore status IB: I wrote a 10 page paper! And did Theory of Knowledge! DE, AP: shrug |
NP. I don't think the diploma matters, but I think the ability to write clearly and effectively is likely better with IB than AP. I think what's better for a kid depends on their interests. But I think anyone going for either AP or IB is going to have a career where writing is essential, and I just don't think AP is as strong on that. On the other hand, if a kid were intent on a STEM career I think AP would be the way to go. |
| I have a young elementary children in the RM cluster. Which is more impressive to t25 colleges when they get to high school, taking the AP path or the IB path? For STEM, it sounds like AP. Is that true? And if not STEM, which one? |
This seems like such a stretch. It’s not like there’s no writing in AP to begin with. At least for DE, if writing is your interest you can take writing specific classes in creative writing, technical writing etc, that are a much better preparation than the entire IB program. All students go to college where they do college papers and a thesis several hundred pages long under the supervision of a college professor to be prepared for their future career. By the time they graduate, whatever paper they wrote in 12th grade will matter very little. At best IB might be a better preparation for the first year of college, but even that is quite debatable. |
Not sure where you got the information that AP doesn’t prepare students for writing, because it couldn’t be further from the truth. My stem oriented son, took AP English, both composition and literature, and AP US History. Each class had a 2000 word paper due weekly and a longer 10-15 page paper for the year end. The writing portion of the AP exam is quite grueling, three different styles of writing under time pressure, about 2000 words total in two hours. It more than prepared him for any writing in college at a top ranked university. |
Agreed! |
No way!! 🤣 You’re delusional! |
I have never heard someone brag about the IB diploma. The IB coursework is what’s valuable and far more rigorous than AP classes. Signed, Parent of RMIB graduate at a Top 10 university (with IB HS friends currently at CalTech, MIT and Ivies) |