Trump govt is deporting Green Card holder student exercising free speech

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Green card holders don't have the same rights as citizens. Sorry the left has perpetuated this lie but you are a guest and must act accordingly.

This guys was not a peaceful protester. He was in charge of breaking and occupying campus building. Disrupting classes, bringing in agitators.

Also distributing Pro Hamas ( not pro Gaza) flyers.


No need for that. That’s not protected speech to support a terrorist group!

Bye bye buddy.

Follow the effing law.

If he committed a crime, say so. Charge him with it publicly. He is a green card holder (and married to a US Citizen.). He has followed the law and is here in the US legally. As a green card holder he is entitled to most of the protections of the Constitution (I'm not sure exactly which ones he isn't entitled to, I'm sure that the courts have had something to say about it.)

If he's been charged with a crime, then say so and say what the crime is.

Follow the law. Respect our Constitution. Respect our First Amendment rights.

We do not charge people with crimes merely for disagreeing with Donald Trump. Merely for disagreeing with MAGA republicans.

We do not charge people with a crime for protesting peacefully, no matter what opinions they are shouting.

We do not charge people for distributing the opinions on leaflets. Even if we don't like what the leaflets are saying. Even if we don't like who they are supporting. The bar is HIGH for proving someone is supporting a terror organization BTW.

If he committed a crime while protesting? Say what the crime was. Charge him with the crime. If it was a crime in NYC it should be charged and prosecuted in NYC where the crime was committed.

Do not pick him up and move him out of state. This is someone who has a Green Card. (Not that this is acceptable treatment for any immigrant. But especially because he is a Green Card holder.)

Don't say "Well, IF he committed a crime while protesting, you know, he MIGHT have... and IF he did he will lose his Green Card status." No. That's not how protection of your civil liberties works.

Follow the law. IF he committed a crime, there's a process to follow. Follow it.

Trump's method of operation is to commit egregious violations of the law, and only care if enough people protest it.

Protest this.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Judge has blocked his deportation

https://news.yahoo.com/federal-judge-blocks-trump-administration-from-deporting-pro-palestinian-activist-mahmoud-khalil-203724926.html

No he hasn't. This judge has no jurisdiction over Khalil.

LOL, did you go to the Trump University Law School?

Jesse Furman from the Southern District of New York doesn't have jurisdiction to hear a habeas petition of someone being held in Louisiana.

The filing was made when he was still in the NJ area. He was kidnapped by the government and shipped off to a GOP friendly circuit court jurisdiction.

Well, he is actively campaigning for and supporting people who engage in kidnapping (as well as torture and murder) so he probably understands the logistics of kidnapping better than most might. At least he’s got that going for him.

I actually don’t support this to be clear but I think the hysterics about “kidnapping” here are ridiculous. Khalil knows what actual kidnapping is — he has openly supported it. This is not kidnapping and the misuse of the phrase is appalling.

Your logic is appalling

This is kidnapping and your side is trying to brush it under the carpet so anyone else who might do something Trump won't like doesn't get their wind up and decide to band together.

Coz that is a lot of people he has targeted.

I literally wrote “I actually don’t support this to be clear” in my post. Also, I voted for Harris.

But facts and grounding in reality have never been the provenance of the pro-Palestine movement. So your inability to read doesn’t surprise me.

I know what you wrote.

It's not legal
And it's a dictator move

You can't just take people like this in country. Full stop

[Anonymous]

If you want full rights get citizenship if not be subject to deportation if you act up

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:If you want full rights get citizenship if not be subject to deportation if you act up

In your dreams maybe

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Judge has blocked his deportation

https://news.yahoo.com/federal-judge-blocks-trump-administration-from-deporting-pro-palestinian-activist-mahmoud-khalil-203724926.html

No he hasn't. This judge has no jurisdiction over Khalil.

LOL, did you go to the Trump University Law School?

Jesse Furman from the Southern District of New York doesn't have jurisdiction to hear a habeas petition of someone being held in Louisiana.

The filing was made when he was still in the NJ area. He was kidnapped by the government and shipped off to a GOP friendly circuit court jurisdiction.

Well, he is actively campaigning for and supporting people who engage in kidnapping (as well as torture and murder) so he probably understands the logistics of kidnapping better than most might. At least he’s got that going for him.

I actually don’t support this to be clear but I think the hysterics about “kidnapping” here are ridiculous. Khalil knows what actual kidnapping is — he has openly supported it. This is not kidnapping and the misuse of the phrase is appalling.

Your logic is appalling

This is kidnapping and your side is trying to brush it under the carpet so anyone else who might do something Trump won't like doesn't get their wind up and decide to band together.

Coz that is a lot of people he has targeted.

I literally wrote “I actually don’t support this to be clear” in my post. Also, I voted for Harris.

But facts and grounding in reality have never been the provenance of the pro-Palestine movement. So your inability to read doesn’t surprise me.

I know what you wrote.

It's not legal
And it's a dictator move

You can't just take people like this in country. Full stop

Well, it does seem to be something Khalil is quite in support of himself. But I agree that the US should have higher standards than Hamas, even if Khalil himself is a strong supporter of kidnapping innocents, including babies.

That having been said, this isn’t kidnapping and it’s offensive to describe it as such.

[Anonymous]

Ah yes the part where they throw people in jail for saying things they don’t like.

These are the same guys talking about free speech and no censorship.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:See Section 237(a)(4)(C)(i) of the INA

"An alien whose presence or activities in the United States the Secretary of State has reasonable ground to believe would have potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States is deportable."

LOL Please describe how this applies to Mahmoud Khalil.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Judge has blocked his deportation

https://news.yahoo.com/federal-judge-blocks-trump-administration-from-deporting-pro-palestinian-activist-mahmoud-khalil-203724926.html

No he hasn't. This judge has no jurisdiction over Khalil.

LOL, did you go to the Trump University Law School?

Jesse Furman from the Southern District of New York doesn't have jurisdiction to hear a habeas petition of someone being held in Louisiana.

The filing was made when he was still in the NJ area. He was kidnapped by the government and shipped off to a GOP friendly circuit court jurisdiction.

Well, he is actively campaigning for and supporting people who engage in kidnapping (as well as torture and murder) so he probably understands the logistics of kidnapping better than most might. At least he’s got that going for him.

I actually don’t support this to be clear but I think the hysterics about “kidnapping” here are ridiculous. Khalil knows what actual kidnapping is — he has openly supported it. This is not kidnapping and the misuse of the phrase is appalling.

Your logic is appalling

This is kidnapping and your side is trying to brush it under the carpet so anyone else who might do something Trump won't like doesn't get their wind up and decide to band together.

Coz that is a lot of people he has targeted.

I literally wrote “I actually don’t support this to be clear” in my post. Also, I voted for Harris.

But facts and grounding in reality have never been the provenance of the pro-Palestine movement. So your inability to read doesn’t surprise me.

I know what you wrote.

It's not legal
And it's a dictator move

You can't just take people like this in country. Full stop

Well, it does seem to be something Khalil is quite in support of himself. But I agree that the US should have higher standards than Hamas, even if Khalil himself is a strong supporter of kidnapping innocents, including babies.

That having been said, this isn’t kidnapping and it’s offensive to describe it as such.

I would like to see proof that Khalil said he is a strong supporter of kidnapping babies.

Have you’ve been to any of the student protests? They were not protesting to support 10/7 they were protesting for a ceasefire.

[Anonymous]

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Green card holders don't have the same rights as citizens. Sorry the left has perpetuated this lie but you are a guest and must act accordingly.

This guys was not a peaceful protester. He was in charge of breaking and occupying campus building. Disrupting classes, bringing in agitators.

Also distributing Pro Hamas ( not pro Gaza) flyers.


No need for that. That’s not protected speech to support a terrorist group!

Bye bye buddy.

If he illegally broke into a building, then arrest him. Follow the procedure. You will appreciate that if you read your Niemoller.

Columbia U chose not to arrest him in the moment. Maybe out of disgust, maybe out of fear. If you see a rabid animal, you don't get close.
But he should have been arrested then.

Please share the specific action he took at that was illegal? Ie violated an actual law.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Green card holders don't have the same rights as citizens. Sorry the left has perpetuated this lie but you are a guest and must act accordingly.

This guys was not a peaceful protester. He was in charge of breaking and occupying campus building. Disrupting classes, bringing in agitators.

Also distributing Pro Hamas ( not pro Gaza) flyers.


No need for that. That’s not protected speech to support a terrorist group!

Bye bye buddy.

If he illegally broke into a building, then arrest him. Follow the procedure. You will appreciate that if you read your Niemoller.

Columbia U chose not to arrest him in the moment. Maybe out of disgust, maybe out of fear. If you see a rabid animal, you don't get close.
But he should have been arrested then.

And I’m sure Trump is preparing the investigation into the antisemites who refused to arrest him, and deport those individuals as well if they support Hamas (like it looks like they do).

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Green card holders don't have the same rights as citizens. Sorry the left has perpetuated this lie but you are a guest and must act accordingly.

This guys was not a peaceful protester. He was in charge of breaking and occupying campus building. Disrupting classes, bringing in agitators.

Also distributing Pro Hamas ( not pro Gaza) flyers.


No need for that. That’s not protected speech to support a terrorist group!

Bye bye buddy.

If he illegally broke into a building, then arrest him. Follow the procedure. You will appreciate that if you read your Niemoller.

Columbia U chose not to arrest him in the moment. Maybe out of disgust, maybe out of fear. If you see a rabid animal, you don't get close.
But he should have been arrested then.

Please share the specific action he took at that was illegal? Ie violated an actual law.

His actions at Columbia University during a protest.

18 U.S. Code § 1203 - Hostage taking

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1203

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:If you want full rights get citizenship if not be subject to deportation if you act up

And in acting up, there is still due process. No one has the legal power to just kidnap someone without a warrant and abscond with them elsewhere.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Judge has blocked his deportation

https://news.yahoo.com/federal-judge-blocks-trump-administration-from-deporting-pro-palestinian-activist-mahmoud-khalil-203724926.html

No he hasn't. This judge has no jurisdiction over Khalil.

LOL, did you go to the Trump University Law School?

Jesse Furman from the Southern District of New York doesn't have jurisdiction to hear a habeas petition of someone being held in Louisiana.

The filing was made when he was still in the NJ area. He was kidnapped by the government and shipped off to a GOP friendly circuit court jurisdiction.

Well, he is actively campaigning for and supporting people who engage in kidnapping (as well as torture and murder) so he probably understands the logistics of kidnapping better than most might. At least he’s got that going for him.

I actually don’t support this to be clear but I think the hysterics about “kidnapping” here are ridiculous. Khalil knows what actual kidnapping is — he has openly supported it. This is not kidnapping and the misuse of the phrase is appalling.

Your logic is appalling

This is kidnapping and your side is trying to brush it under the carpet so anyone else who might do something Trump won't like doesn't get their wind up and decide to band together.

Coz that is a lot of people he has targeted.

I literally wrote “I actually don’t support this to be clear” in my post. Also, I voted for Harris.

But facts and grounding in reality have never been the provenance of the pro-Palestine movement. So your inability to read doesn’t surprise me.

I know what you wrote.

It's not legal
And it's a dictator move

You can't just take people like this in country. Full stop

Well, it does seem to be something Khalil is quite in support of himself. But I agree that the US should have higher standards than Hamas, even if Khalil himself is a strong supporter of kidnapping innocents, including babies.

That having been said, this isn’t kidnapping and it’s offensive to describe it as such.

Armed officers physically removed him from his residence without legal cause to do so. How do you define it otherwise?

[Anonymous]

He’s not a citizen. He’s not protected by the US Constitution. He doesn’t even like it here, so not sure the big deal. Time to go!