Fairfax County Double Murder

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I understand the majority of people here are probably moms and wives who relate themselves with Christine. The average American mom, who gets cheated on by her husband with the “hot” Brazilian AP.
Every woman’s nightmare.

But we need to take a step out of the emotional involvement and understand that Christine could and most likely was involved (or starting an involvement) with JR. There are a lot of things that goes on in people’s minds that we don’t know about. Just look at yourselves for a second. Everyone has things that nobody has no idea about.

Actually if BB really did catch CB cheating, wouldn’t that give him even more motive to murder?

He looks guilty any way it went down

Pretty much. Which is why his mouth is shut.

I wonder if he may just stop paying for AP's lawyer at some point depending on how things play out. She's in a much more vulnerable position than she may understand.

I think of nurses as typically nurturing types. Not stone cold killers. She's a piece of work.

lol real nurses are normally the wildest. Have you never heard of the stripper to nurse pipeline? It takes a different breed to be dealing with blood and trauma all day and maintain high energy.

[Anonymous]

I doubt there is a "stripper-to-nurse" pipeline.

There may be a nurse-to-stripper trail...but I don't think a lot of strippers are becoming nurses. That sounds like a Halloween cliche.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just a reminder that BB never even bothered to write an obituary for his wife. The mother of his child.

https://moloneyfh.com/obituary/christine-ann-banfield/

Would you, if you would catch her cheating on you and then this whole chaos played out ?

She cheats on me, I get another girl as a replacement. If my wife cheats on me in those conditions, leading everyone to believe I’ve committed homicide, I can understand the rage and logic of getting the AP as a “new lover”.



Yes I would write an obit for my spouse! I would think most people would? Even if my spouse cheated, that’s still the parent of my child who was unjustly murdered. I would think most people would want to remember the good qualities of their spouse and celebrate their memory.

Eh, if i found them fatally stabbed by their knife-wielding fetish partner who I had to shoot leading people to believe I was somehow responsible for a double homicide all of which I would get to explain to my daughter, I might have trouble finding the words.

But no trouble moving your mistress into the same bed you stabbed your wife in?

I mean, if she created all of this for an andventure? And led everyone to see me as a murderer? Heck yea, I’m gonna bring another girl to the bedroom. Specially someone that would prob piss her off.

Even after a child psychologist has told you to keep things as simple and similar as possible, not introducing too much change? BB's friends say they told him to move to NY to be closer to friends and family. He said no as child psych told him not to introduce too much more change. So he moves AP into the child's mommy's room and puts of pictures of them around the room, goes away with her on trips, etc?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just a reminder that BB never even bothered to write an obituary for his wife. The mother of his child.

https://moloneyfh.com/obituary/christine-ann-banfield/

Would you, if you would catch her cheating on you and then this whole chaos played out ?

So you would kill a man who was stabbing your wife (after she was killed of course!) but wouldn’t write an obit for her? Something her daughter could read one day?

And I thought Bb caught JR killing his wife, not his wife cheating? Which story is it?

Isn’t it obvious that after everything calmed down, couple days later he found out she was talking to JR?
She died on the 24th, service wasn’t until March 3rd. A lot was discovered in the mean time.

Per a friend of JR, he had met the couple, including BB.

Even if the friend was correct, what’s to say that the guy JR met was BB?

Or that the wife wasn't AP.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I understand the majority of people here are probably moms and wives who relate themselves with Christine. The average American mom, who gets cheated on by her husband with the “hot” Brazilian AP.
Every woman’s nightmare.

But we need to take a step out of the emotional involvement and understand that Christine could and most likely was involved (or starting an involvement) with JR. There are a lot of things that goes on in people’s minds that we don’t know about. Just look at yourselves for a second. Everyone has things that nobody has no idea about.

Actually if BB really did catch CB cheating, wouldn’t that give him even more motive to murder?

He looks guilty any way it went down

Pretty much. Which is why his mouth is shut.

I wonder if he may just stop paying for AP's lawyer at some point depending on how things play out. She's in a much more vulnerable position than she may understand.

I think of nurses as typically nurturing types. Not stone cold killers. She's a piece of work.

She's 23- she was 21 when she got to the US... how long do you think she was nurse for in Brasil?

[Anonymous]

JR's own text says he had never done knife play. CB had a blood clotting disorder. Who is left to push the idea of the perfect patsy showing up, knife in hand? Not too many candidates.

That and BB and AP walking into the house with 4yr old are pretty damning for him and the stories put out by AP's lawyer that he is paying for. When he is arrested, recollections may differ, time will tell.

CB & BB could have been active swingers for all we know and they sought JR out on F&tlife, or someone claiming to be CB did. None of that matters and it's all meant to devalue the lives of the victims so LE wouldn't do much. Thankfully they were suspicious immediately and JR's friend and family came forward.

Terribly tragic for the victims and child. None of the story has to make sense, hold together, etc. What matters is if they can get BB with knife in hand and for premeditation.

[Anonymous]

A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

[Anonymous]

It was well documented on social media that BB and AP were dating before the murders.

Also, JRs friend has come out and told us that JR said he was meeting with both BB and CB

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It was well documented on social media that BB and AP were dating before the murders.

Also, JRs friend has come out and told us that JR said he was meeting with both BB and CB

He never once said that. He said he met with a couple.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

Except for these things that don’t fit:
1- JR had told friends he was meeting with a couple that day
2- There's evidence of a relationship between BB and AP before CBs death
3- Text msg read in court said JR had never engaged in knife play before. CB has a blood clotting disorder and wouldn’t have asked for knife play. As a nurse she would understand that risk.
4- Still makes no sense that AP would run up to the room after hearing a gun shot or struggle. She’s employed to take care of a child. Why would she leave her and go to an unsafe situation risking her own life for….?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

Except for these things that don’t fit:
1- JR had told friends he was meeting with a couple that day
2- There's evidence of a relationship between BB and AP before CBs death
3- Text msg read in court said JR had never engaged in knife play before. CB has a blood clotting disorder and wouldn’t have asked for knife play. As a nurse she would understand that risk.
4- Still makes no sense that AP would run up to the room after hearing a gun shot or struggle. She’s employed to take care of a child. Why would she leave her and go to an unsafe situation risking her own life for….?

1- Not that day, that week.
2- So what? Before, after… doesn’t change what PP said. She’d be even more inclined to shoot if she was already involved w BB
3- Ok but maybe it was just a role play, no real cutting.
4- You think someone would think logically in that case? “Oh I’m here to take care of the kid; that’s part of my job, so I’m not gonna react”. No.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

Except for these things that don’t fit:
1- JR had told friends he was meeting with a couple that day
2- There's evidence of a relationship between BB and AP before CBs death
3- Text msg read in court said JR had never engaged in knife play before. CB has a blood clotting disorder and wouldn’t have asked for knife play. As a nurse she would understand that risk.
4- Still makes no sense that AP would run up to the room after hearing a gun shot or struggle. She’s employed to take care of a child. Why would she leave her and go to an unsafe situation risking her own life for….?

1- Not that day, that week.
2- So what? Before, after… doesn’t change what PP said. She’d be even more inclined to shoot if she was already involved w BB
3- Ok but maybe it was just a role play, no real cutting.
4- You think someone would think logically in that case? “Oh I’m here to take care of the kid; that’s part of my job, so I’m not gonna react”. No.

4- she’s going to risk her life for her employer??

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

Except for these things that don’t fit:
1- JR had told friends he was meeting with a couple that day
2- There's evidence of a relationship between BB and AP before CBs death
3- Text msg read in court said JR had never engaged in knife play before. CB has a blood clotting disorder and wouldn’t have asked for knife play. As a nurse she would understand that risk.
4- Still makes no sense that AP would run up to the room after hearing a gun shot or struggle. She’s employed to take care of a child. Why would she leave her and go to an unsafe situation risking her own life for….?

1- Not that day, that week.
2- So what? Before, after… doesn’t change what PP said. She’d be even more inclined to shoot if she was already involved w BB
3- Ok but maybe it was just a role play, no real cutting.
4- You think someone would think logically in that case? “Oh I’m here to take care of the kid; that’s part of my job, so I’m not gonna react”. No.

4- she’s going to risk her life for her employer??

Employer or lover/ live in girlfriend?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A theory just came to me! Probably dumb. But hear me out!

CB was having a consensual fetish relationship with JR. BB wasn't involved. Everything initially happened just as described- AP left with the child to go to the zoo and came back because she forgot lunches, saw the car, called BB, BB came back and went in with AP and the child to investigate. But, BB suspects CB is cheating, because theyve both cheated in the past per other posters who know them. That is the mindframe he walks in with- that she is cheating- which is why he has AP and child come in as well but tells them to stay in the basement while he goes upstairs. Then, he gets upstairs and sees the scene. CB and JR are both immediately like- it's ok it's not an attack! Since of course it looks like a sexual assault in progress. BB sees red- he is so angry that CB is cheating on him and in such a bizarre way- that's part of why he wanted the AP and the child to come in the house, too, because he wanted them to semi-witness CB cheating on BB, to turn them against her a little. Anyways, he sees red, and grabs the knife and goes, "what is going on?? this is what you want?? this is what you like??" and holds it to her throat and then kills her, in the heat of the moment, and JR grabs the knife from him at that point- and BB realizes what he's done. He pulls out his gun and shoots JR, because JR is holding the knife and can easily be passed off as an intruder, and he realizes he can pin it on JR. But the shot doesn't kill him. At this point, the AP runs upstairs, sees the scene and calls 911 immediately. JR moans in the background of the call. BB frantically grabs the phone and hangs it up. He tells her to grab the other gun and shoot him because his mind is trying to grasp at ways to pin blame on other people. So, panicked, she does. Then she calls 911 back.

Basically the AP is telling the truth as she knows it. Which is why she isn't flipping, because she truly thinks it happened this way. BB is being silent because he knows he panicked and frantically tried to frame JR and then weirdly through the AP into the mix also- he didn't have any kind of coherent story in his mind yet when LE showed up at the scene which is why from the get go, he refused to say anything. He knew enough to keep his mouth shut until he had a story. Then, AP is interviewed for 8 hours and gives her story, which never changes, because it's her true story. She doesn't know that BB stabbed CB in rage when he walked in on their knife play fetish and then shot JR to pin it on him. He probably wished she'd stayed downstairs with the kid the whole time. Maybe that's also why he entered a relationship with her , if he was worried she'd start to get suspicious about the evening, and he thought that being in a relationship with her would keep her not questioning things.

That’s a way more evolved way of saying what I think it happened than the post I made. I don’t think he got into a relationship w AP just bc of that but also for revenge. Like I said, bring the girl that would piss her off the most into her bedroom.

Except for these things that don’t fit:
1- JR had told friends he was meeting with a couple that day
2- There's evidence of a relationship between BB and AP before CBs death
3- Text msg read in court said JR had never engaged in knife play before. CB has a blood clotting disorder and wouldn’t have asked for knife play. As a nurse she would understand that risk.
4- Still makes no sense that AP would run up to the room after hearing a gun shot or struggle. She’s employed to take care of a child. Why would she leave her and go to an unsafe situation risking her own life for….?

1- Not that day, that week.
2- So what? Before, after… doesn’t change what PP said. She’d be even more inclined to shoot if she was already involved w BB
3- Ok but maybe it was just a role play, no real cutting.
4- You think someone would think logically in that case? “Oh I’m here to take care of the kid; that’s part of my job, so I’m not gonna react”. No.

4- she’s going to risk her life for her employer??

Refer to my answer to number 2