Wouldn't apply to this stop because stop was for no license plate and tinting. |
Different poster here. Unless the police had received a call about a stolen vehicle from a local car dealership, why did they assume that a new-looking car driven by a black man was possibly stolen? And as soon as they saw the paper tags, why didn't they just let him go? Why engage further, especially when it is now pretty widely known that many minority drivers do not feel safe when stopped by police? How does this overzealous policing help the public? |
Windsor is redneck land. |
Actually, tinting is included (see V) but, you're right, the tag/plate issue is not. But I wasn't saying it was or that it would have made a difference in this situation. I was saying that we need to change the laws surrounding traffic stops...and apparently VA, for one, has. |
Unfortunately the police can always make up a reason. See this case where they stopped him for not having a license when he in fact had a license plate. |
True. Even if states implement laws against pretextual stops, I think the police will still come up with reasons to stop someone. But maybe if they are told by their superiors not to do it except for in serious or potentially dangerous circumstances, maybe they will do it less. That should help keep everyone safer--both the citizens who are pulled over wrongfully...and the cops who stop a dangerous criminal and get shot to death because the criminal has something to hide (outstanding felony warrant, guns, illegal drugs, etc.) and shoots the cop to try to get away. As a society, we need to pick our battles. |
No tag you get pulled over 100% of the time no matter who you are. No exceptions ever. Might not get a ticket and just a warning but you get pulled over. No tag is a major red flag of issues. As innocent as no insurance and as bad as stolen or plate off to commit a crime. He was pulled over not because it might have been a stolen car but because that it had no tag. Tag in window will not get a ticket but it is supposed to be on the outside. Once cop sees the tag, he still gets to check it out -- is it real, why on inside, still valid. So no issue there at all on the stop. No plate is not a BS thing like tint too dark or blinker out. No plate is a red flag. As it turns out he has a tag and this should have ended with the LT going on his way. |
This was a bad stop so I am not trying to justify it. But he did not have the tag where it was supposed to be. Car dealers have special paper that these are printed on and they are made to go right where the plate it and be exposed to the elements. They are not on copy paper. Nothing wrong with pulling him over. It is what happened next that is the problem. |
RS is a very low standard. You might want to brush up on your case law (or google skills haha). The police have the authority to control the traffic stop, which means they can force you to stay in the vehicle or they can make you exit the vehicle. A couple of states do have a higher standard, but they are obviously the exception. Gotta love all the clueless people posting nonsense because hate the police. |
Not the PP but I really don't think that most people hate cops. Don't interpret questioning the actions of police officers as hating them. There's clearly some confusion amongst the public about what is permissible in a traffic stop. And there are understandable concerns about how some[b] police officers handle interactions with the public, particularly minorities. If there are institutional/structural issues within specific police forces, then now might be a good time to look at them as a society and rethink how we want policing to work in our communities. |
That’s BS. I had my temp tag on the window. That’s where the dealer put it. I never got pulled over. I see them on windows all the time. Maybe it’s not correct but it’s incredibly common. The difference is I’m a middle aged white guy who the cops would never think stole a car. |
Maybe the temp tag wasn't visible to the officer at night. Didn't he also have tinted windows? Yeah, cops are always picking on black guys and always let the white people do whatever they want |
If they saw the tag, they would not pull you over. DMV does make the paper plates to go on the outside. Because your dealer put it there is not a defense. The cops said they did not see it. It was young cop that was not fired and he said that before pulling him over. He did not see the tag. He can be pulled over legally. |
You could see the tag in the video. |
Once he stopped at the gas station the tag was visible and there was no reasonable suspicion for the insane reaction of the cops. The young cop started the fiasco by calling for backup because the driver didn’t immediately pull over. |