Yes, I’ve seen the cherry picked data and heard the constant shrieking about “learning loss”. I’ve also seen the data on how 1 in 8 NYC public school teachers have had COVID this year. I’ve seen the data from the UK and from Wisconsin, which also state an increased risk for teachers. And I’ve seen parents continue to insist that the risk is worthy, without actually taking on any themselves. I’ve also seen the contact tracing data which indicates that children readily infect others, although people (unscientifically) insist that just doesn’t happen. I read the study that the CDC used to change their recommendation that 3 feet is safe, and was baffled to find that the schools did not actually measure the distance between students (and indicated that there might have been, in fact, much greater than 3 feet between students due to reduced capacities). I was also baffled to read that neither the MA study or the Wisconsin study relied on actual surveillance testing, just self reporting of cases by administrators. “Study” is a strong word for what the slapped together to push this policy. |
| Weren't NYC schools closed most of the year? |
Some of you are either idiots or have reading comprehension issues. Did you really not understand what I wrote? I wrote "if schools do not open in September", after teachers and most adults will be vaccinated. How can it be risky at that point? You cannot be serious! |
I’m not the one complaining about what schools here are doing? YOU are. Fix your life, sis. |
|
Wow, that's a really fascinating list of claims which are all incorrect. Why don't you go try to get your claims published? |
| Like, show us one paper which shows that learning loss related to DL isn't happening in the US. I'll wait right here. |
I guess you're looking in the mirror when you're talking about "idiots" who may "have reading comprehension issues." Because you certainly don't have a grasp on what is going on. It is risky because the children won't have been vaccinated and they are known vectors - they are asymptomatic superspreaders. That makes them risky for vaccinated adults because no vaccine is 100% effective and no vaccine has even 50% efficacy for ALL of the current mutations let alone the new mutations that will occur over the next 6 months. THAT's why it is risky. I don't understand what you don't understand about this. It really isn't that difficult to comprehend. I'm a DIFFERENT POSTER by the way - just a newcomer wading into the fray. |
1,000,000, but every one of these parents will claim I DON'T WORK AT HOME IVE WORKED IN PERSON SINCE THE BEGINNING, because they don't have to prove it on anonymous message board. They're full of crap. |
Millions of Americans are working from home this year in jobs that previously were thought "couldn't " be done remotely. It turns out in a pandemic, yes, they can. You not liking, approving of r agreeing with DL is not teachers' problem, but yours. Nobody has been "out of school" for 1-2 years, because education is not buildings. And the claim that parents are "getting mentally ill" from taking care of their own children and the bogus manipulative "but suicide!" cards are disgusting and pathetic. |
Seriously? So how long would you like to stay in DL? 2-3 more years? I am curious. |
For as long as it takes for the pandemic to no longer be a pandemic. I cannot believe you are even asking that question. It is a "duh" to me...and anyone who gives a fig about other people. A kid's education is NOT worth an adult's life. My husband and I will keep doing what we're doing. Our kids are thriving and we're having a great year. |
+1, but you're about to get jumped on by the rapid Open 'Er Up crowd, who will insist that you don't know your own children, that they can't be thriving, that you live in your basement (they're imbeciles) and that you can't know what your kids are or aren't learning, even when you hear what they're learning and see how they perform every day. To them, anyone who doesn't agree with their agenda that OMG DL IS AN EVIL HATEFUL CATASTROPHE FOR ALL CHILDREN is a liar or a troll. Don't waste your time with them. |
I 100% believe that there are parents who are mentally ill as a result of spending 24/7 with their own kids. It used to drive middle class married white women into depression in the 1950s and ‘60s. Now their granddaughters are experiencing the same thing and think no one cares. It’s not that no one cares. It’s that mental health care is available now in a way it wasn’t mid-century and you need to exhaust that before you start demanding other people (mostly women, often less well-off than you, and sometimes POC) risk their lives so you don’t need to take an antidepressant or tell your DH to share parenting duties. |
SARS and H1N1 were also pandemics, should we have shut down schools for a year for each of those as well? Every profession comes with risks and every year teachers die from flu and other viruses contracted in the classroom, accidents traveling to/from work, etc...Unless you have never sent your kids to in person school, claiming now that kids’ education is not worth an adult’s life makes you a hypocrite. The more accurate question is how many adult lives are an acceptable trade off? A pandemic is simply an epidemic in multiple countries/continents and the definition has nothing to do with lethality so “when the pandemic is over” is a pretty arbitrary benchmark. |