Is Notre Dame screwing up?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
| This is like Fyre festival |
Anonymous
I just can't believe how bad this is. |
Anonymous
Did anyone die? |
Anonymous
|
She's right -- No medical doctors on these ND Covid committees:
https://here.nd.edu/our-approach/leadership-teams/medical-health-sub-committee/ https://here.nd.edu/our-approach/leadership-teams/operations-reopening-sub-committee/ |
Anonymous
DP. I’m pretty sure every hall staff members is trying to take care of students who are sick, in worse shape than your daughter, or — more likely — responding to dozens of calls and emails from parents (not to mention multiple calls, texts and emails from same parents) who are freaking out even though there child has not been a close contact of a positive case, and is exhibiting zero symptoms. So give those RAs and rectors a pass the next few weeks, tell the kids to get ahead in their classes, grab another freshman and ask them to go walk around the lake, read a book, study on the quad, or whatever. Patience, flexibility and kiNDness. |
Anonymous
| They worked extensively with infectious disease specialists from the Cleveland Clinic. |
Anonymous
How can they call it the Medical/Health SubCommittee and have not a single person on it from the medical field? |
Anonymous
These are internal committees. ND does not have a medical school so of course there aren't doctors on them. They have hired extensive medical professional consultants to work with the committees. |
Anonymous
Exactly. ND has been working with the Cleveland Clinic and Johns Hopkins to devise the plans. That said, it is has not gone well. I am VERY worried about my son who is there right now and currently healthy. I do not want him to end up in one of the isolation units as they are not well staffed for the influx of cases. My prediction is he will be on a plane home by next week. Very upsetting and disappointing. |
Anonymous
| Are they just waiting for the football team to take the field once, so they can proceed with the rest of the season and then send the rest of the students home? I recall reading no NCAA football unless the college has real students on campus. |
Anonymous
This is correct. |
Anonymous
|
They have a medical committee with zero medical people on it? That is ridiculously stupid.
Can you imagine that discussion? “We need a medical committee to advise us on all the medical ramifications of our plan”. “Good idea. Who shall we put on the medical committee?” “One thing for sure is we don’t want any doctors or nurses on the medical committee”. Hmmmm what could possibly go wrong? Everyone will think, “hey we are really on top of this if we have a medical committee. We don’t really have to say we don’t have any medical folks on the medical committee do we?” |
Anonymous
There's a reason why Cleveland Clinic and Hopkins are not listed on these websites. It's because no reputable epidemiologist or infectious disease specialist would put associate their name and sully their reputation by associating publicly with a college that planed to open fully during the height of a national pandemic. |
Anonymous
Just because they worked with Hopkins and the Cleveland Clinic doesn't mean ND took all of their advice. JHU is not doing anything onlien this fall and told its students not to come to Baltimore. No regular weekly or biweekly asymptomatic testing and full isolation / quarantine = outbreaks. It is true that outbreaks puts faculty and staff at far greater risk of illness than students but as an employer they cannot take that risk. They also should monitor whether they will be overburdening local hospital capacity. These universities do not operate in a vacuum, expecting any community to fully comply with social distancing is foolish (look at nearly ever communty around the country). People who thought this fall would not be a grim experience for students is insane. This was the year to take a gap year, especially if you are first year student. |
Anonymous
For the third time, it's an internal committee consisting of administrators. there is no medical school at ND. None of the committees have outsiders on them. They have used consultants who ARE medical experts to form the plan. which clearly didn't work, but they certainly had a plan formed with the advice of medical experts. You seem to not have much experience working with committees. That makes you 1. very lucky, but 2. unused to how they operate. I have spearheaded a number of committees, too many committees, and they are rarely filled with experts. You hire the experts, you don't put them on the committee. |