Are you asking about illegal immigration? Yang's flagship proposal is $1000 a month for every adult US citizen. Illegal immigrants are not eligible. Even though illegal immigration is not the cause of the loss of jobs in swing states, his proposal has a side effect of giving displaced workers a leg up over illegal immigrants. His plan is all about decreasing the illegal immigration, and attracting them to go through the legal channel to ultimately becoming citizens. He is for increasing guest worker programs and strengthening cooperation with Mexican government so they come legally and leave timely when work is done. Neither party in power has presented any real solutions. Trump has not built any new wall, and there doesn't seem to be any compromise possible. Yang is for border security and the solutions proposed by groups across the political spectrum. |
^ That sounds like something I’d like to hear more about. |
I find Yang’s ideas interesting (except for the $1,000/mo idea - weird), but, I’m not interested in an idea person. I’m interested in a pragmatist who can build support, make compromises, and get things passed. |
That seems to be his biggest problem - "he is literally trying to give everybody money" but many have never heard of him or some like you are suspicious about it. https://twitter.com/AndrewYang/status/1195520687286308864 For me, if I think in a macro economics sense, the idea becomes less - weird. We have a $20 trillion economy which is made up of total cash and credit spending. Yang wants to rearrange it and return a slice of it, about 12% to citizens, which then gets recycled in the economy over and over. You are looking at a small scale of reallocation of economic resources, so the poor and middle class get a share of the wealth created by big business and machines. |
Hmmm. I am done with businessmen running. (He's kind of coming at a bad time.) Now if an economist (like Warren) said this thing was a good idea, I might be swayed. Our foray in to having a businessman has been bad. Also I don't know how he is addressing health care costs but health care costs including insurance are bankrupting people. |
I am actually happy I don’t have to make that choice in 2020 |
Yang is more a nonprofit guy than a businessman. He is probably one of the poorest of all the candidates running. I am not sure Warren is an economist. She is a law professor. "Elizabeth Warren says Andrew Yang-backed universal basic income among 'options to consider' to ensure American financial well-being" https://twitter.com/AndrewYang/status/1196567756600152064 |
I’m not entirely comfortable with our economy being “rearranged”.....who would pay for this? How would it happen? Would Republicans in Congress, or even Democrats, agree to this? I don’t think so. It’s just an idea! We can’t even do small things in Congress, were so dysfunctional. |
This is the biggest issue for 2020 - get the GOP out of Congress. |
Where wlll the $1000 a month per person come from? |
Lots and lies and corruption from the Clintons. I was able to get past that and vote for Bill twice and Hillary once. I'll be able to get past it again this time and vote for Trump. |
Thank you, I am the one you replied to. This is good to hear. |
Is it $1000/month for adult US citizens or kids also? Income limits? I could see how Yang’s plan could really appeal to the rabid pro-life continent in the Republican Party. People would be popping our kids left and right if they know they can get $1000/month per kid! Definitely a decrease in the number abortions. |
Contingent not continent |
Bigger problems for who? |