It's really hard to believe that doctors in a highly advanced and educated country like Canada or Sweden come to such a completely different conclusion when it comes to this medical issue. I could see there being a 10% or whatever difference, but we're talking about 50% or more. There has to be something cultural, but I can't figure out what it might be. The US has a circumcision rate that would make it fit in with poor countries in the Muslim world. |
Funny enough, I was congratulated for not doing it by the on-call ped at WHC when I gave birth there 10 years ago (she said her own sons were not). I'm white, she was AA. Husband is European, I'm the daughter of European immigrants, so we never even considered it, though I wouldn't consider us very liberal by any stretch. |
Yeah, though most of these are countries where Islam is a major religion . |
Or health care providers in the US are more cognizant of how much they can bill private insurance companies for a medically unnecessary procedure. |
there are definite medical benefits. You can argue that they are small and not worth the risk or worth overriding your prefence/child's autonomy whatever but the evidence for them is overwhelming. Although I would do circumcision for religious reasons regardless of medical benefit, it is a bonus that there is a clear and convincing medical benefit. |
I'm sorry what?! How does the presence of foreskin make changing a diaper any more or less gross? |
Certainly speaks to maturity level. |
Very funny to see the last line of defense is always "because it looks gross to me, and everyone I know agrees". I bet all these moms would explode into a sanctimonious rant if someone dared to comment on their middle aged (natural!) portly frame, and saggy appearance. |
You should probably be asking our sons, not us.
But y’all need to stop bashing each other. We all made the choice that we thought best. That’s what parenthood is all about. |
I'm not saying you have to circumcise your kid, and I'm not judging you if you don't, but if your justification for not doing it is "it's so common not to in the US that my son won't have to worry about getting teased or girls thinking he's gross" you are unfortunately mistaken. I'm sorry if it's shallow, but I didn't want my son to have to worry about girls thinking he's gross. Because that is absolutely a thing that happens for uncircumcised boys in the US even with "gen z" girls, no matter what you read on your intactivist Facebook groups. |
How do you know this? |
Or something similarly creepy about their daughters. Like, "your daughter should get labioplasty so the boys don't laugh at her for having a large outer labia." Ewww..... |
Younger gen-x here and I decided to not circumcise my kids because of my experience with uncut guys. |
Because my teenage daughter has talked about how her and her friends think uncircumcised is gross, and looking on TikTok that is not an unpopular opinion. The circumcision rate where I live in Virginia is as high now as it was when I'm a teenager. Why would the prevailing attitude that foreskin is gross had changed? |
You always chime in on these threads about your daughter and her friends and TikTok. Seriously? I personally live in VA, but believe it or not, my world extends beyond its borders. My kids' world does, too. We travel enough that this universal distaste is not a thing. |