
Not the poster above, but the description of FCV was pretty accurate, and yes, I have had a FCV parent try to get my child to try out at the club. |
Mine would have a spot with no tryout.... FCV is relentless |
So no other clubs approach players at all? |
defensive much? |
A FCV parent encouraged your kid to tryout?!?!?! Why, why that is just madness!!! Funny, I have had coaches and parents at clubs other than FCV say similar things to me and I just take it as a compliment regarding my kids without any ill feeling towards the parent, coach or the club represented. The bottom line is, all clubs, to some extent, poach kids. They'll offer guesting opportunities or clinics etc. Did you ever wonder how those new kids on your own teams got there? Is the new kid a "school friend of Suzie?". Don't you think Suzie's parents told new Mia's parents, "oh, they haven't played together since rec, you know you really should bring her to tryouts, our coach is great and we can carpool. It would be sooo much fun!!!!" Parents poach, coaches poach, everybody poaches. |
Not defensive. You do realize that you cant be forced to join a soccer club right? Again, my kids have been approached and I just take it as a compliment. And frankly, it is nice to know that there are options if circumstances change. Why would I be mad at a coach, parent or club that expressed interest in either of my kids? The soccer world is to small to take offense over being asked to play soccer somewhere else. |
Nobody poaches like FCV poaches. |
There's conversational recruiting that happens between players and their friends, or parents .... and then there's the outright poaching by FCV .... big difference |
NP here. I have a son on the Great Falls side of that game. That 14 year old ref had no idea what he was doing. They never should have put him out there without more training. We paid a lot of money to go to that tournament, and not so some inexperienced child could learn the ropes. If anyone yelled at that kid, they were only expressing what everyone else was thinking. It was bad call after bad call, and many more things not called out at all. |
I guess explain the difference then so that I know it when I see it. |
With all this poaching going on : ) and with the birth year changes, I suspect many kids will be jumping clubs next year. Anyone willing to share which club they are leaving, what age/gender, where you are going next year, and why? |
Is FCV that bad? Is it the same club that FCV South County is a part of? I thought it was a relatively new club or perhaps just the South County one is. I know that SCAA moved its soccer program over to them. |
How is SYA as a club? I am looking for clubs and am in the vicinity of NVSC, VSA, SYA and Loudoun. I have heard from here and have knowledge of the other clubs other than SYA |
I'll back off my comments about poaching a bit because it sounds like you are a coach because I just don't think a parent really thinks of it as "poaching" the way coaches do. Sure, if you are a coach it sucks to spend time developing kids only to watch them walk. But then again, how many average kids walked from your teams over the years without a second thought? Only the 'good players" get poached is your thinking. Well, if you have turnover in your club it is worth your time to find out why, regardless of your opinion of the player. Generally, players only leave for situations that are perceived to be better than the one they are in. So EVERY kid that has ever voluntarily left your team did so because they perceived the destination to be an improvement and selectively calling it "poaching" doesn't change that fact. |
FCV is just an umbrella that affiliates with clubs in order to use their fields and to be able to say they have a rec program ... they claim their affiliate's rec programs as their own to check that box with ECNL. South County is their latest affiliate, and just one of a long line of clubs FCV has already or will in the future burn bridges with. There is no development that happens with FCV, just taking players to overfill their ECNL rosters. Their lower level teams regularly roster ECNL players in an attempt to pad their stats. |