Stop the FCV (DA) and McLean (ECNL) hate
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
| Just don't argue that ECNL and DA are the only route to elite college soccer. It is a great route for those who have the means or who have a DD focused 100% on soccer but for others of us, that route does not work. |
Anonymous
| That young lady is an exceptional athlete and one of the best basketball players in America. With that being said, nobody is getting recruited through high school soccer. Please stop with that. |
Anonymous
YouTube fcv dad says DA is the only route. I believe him. He knows everything. |
Anonymous
Sorry but you don't score 40 goals against competition that includes ECNL defenders unless you have skill and understand tactics. Fortunately, college soccer coaches are not as myopic in their analysis as parents on this board. There is no way she will not get contacted by top college coaches. I know folks want to believe that their paying thousands of dollars buys them exclusive entry to DI soccer but that just is not reality. |
Anonymous
Did she play travel soccer before high school? For what team? |
Anonymous
Are you still trying to argue this?? This is not a pathway for 99.999%, so it’s effectively not a pathway. |
Anonymous
Instead you can pay 10’s of thousands of dollars to Sidwell for that same exposure. |
Anonymous
LOL, that's right. All you fools paying $5000/year for club soccer are so misguided. Just have your DD pay HS instead and save your money. Look at this kid who goes to Sidwell Friends for example (where tuition is $40,000 per year). Too funny. Also, she's 5'11", and fast. 40 goals in the DC High School league is not hard to believe. Doesn't make her D1 material, and she didn't "beat out" the YNT player (from Bethesda), b/c as others have said, the Gatorade "Player of the Year" award is not really a best player of the year award. Putting aside the fact that it is also based on academic achievement and "character" (community service), you really think Gatorade is sending scouts to high school games all over the country to evaluate players? LOL they must be deeply undercover, hiding in the bushes and stuff. Do all the coaches in the league vote on who the best player is every year? That would mean something. Regardless, the affect on college placement of the decision whether to play both club and hs, or just club, can be debated. The idea that playing only HS - and not club - is a realistic path to playing in college, is simply laughable. Unless of course you're a 5'11" freshman with good speed who scores lots of goals against very weak competition. In that case sure, you might get some goober college coach to take a chance that they can "train up" the raw athlete into a real soccer player. Good luck with that. |
Anonymous
Don't want to go too far off topic, but isn't Sidwell the school being sued because a student wasn't 100% immediately accepted to all the schools she applied to? But a 5'11" national team baller? that's a heck of an athlete. Back to the soccer, how many of the team schools in the DC private school conference are primarily ECNL based talent? |
Anonymous
|
She made All-Met you morons along with some of the best ECNL players in the region, none of which made All-Met as freshman.
You folks are as bad as the parents caught up in the "Varsity Blues" scandal. You think just because you forked out tens of thousands of dollar in a legal scheme to buy your DD's access to Di soccer, the only way someone else can do it without doing the same is if she is a "unicorn." I am the first to admit that you are not going to reach DI soccer by relying on HS soccer as your main vehicle. I assume that even the Sidwell freshman played club at some point but gave it up to focus on bb. The point is that you do not have to play ECNL/DA to reach elite DI. You people have ECNL/DA derangement syndrome. Step away for a few weeks! |
Anonymous
She is a unique athlete and the previous poster who called her a Unicorn is correct in that assessment. In fact it was stated that ONLY unicorns could play only HS and get noticed. She fits that bill. But, in terms of soccer she has not gone up against top DA or ECNL teams to really judge her dominance. In terms of the Gatorade award. She was awarded for DC. Gatorade awards kids at the State level, so even in that regards she was only going up against kids in DC not in VA or MD. Sidwell also prominently displays that they have had 16 athletes receive such recognition so clearly Sidwell uses this award as a platform. |
Anonymous
|
Did you not read the entire previous post -- She made All-met as a freshman against teams featuring ECNL players. I can't recall any player recording that many goals ever and definitely not as a freshman.
If she scored 40+ goals at Sidwell she would show well against ECNL/DA talent her age. |
Anonymous
A HS team with a 4 or 5 ECNL players on it does not an ECNL team make. |
Anonymous
Not PP, but completely agree. Too many holes to fill on a regular pitch for 4-5 players to overcome. |
Anonymous
+1000 |