Absolutely agree! Mine loves playing the game but hates the disorganized nature of rec. Her teammates didn't take practice seriously and the coach was a volunteer dad with little experience and no license. Every saturday was a guessing game of who will or won't show up to play. At least with travel, she gets 10 months of continuous training, multiple tournaments, and teammates that are more serous about playing. She won't play professionally and almost no chance of playing in college but she's happy. |
It must be a significant difference in the commitment and tempo in all the teams. |
Well stated. We started travel cause honestly $3K isn't a ton of money and we wanted reliability in both coaching and teammates. |
Ironic that this sentiment was shared and supported on page 70 of this thread. Looks like we are going in circles. |
Someone keeps bringing up the same topic over and over. I think it’s the “just saying” poster. Someone who had a bad experience and is now weirdly obsessed with Valor cannot fathom that some people do know exactly what they’re getting into being on a lower team, and yet are still satisfied with it. |
IDK. Not take anything away from Valor, but 117 pages filled with mostly negative comments seems it a bit consistent. There are certainly good coaches in Valor, but I 'don't hear many positives coming for the lower-level teams on some of the issues here...
unqualified coaching staffs No player improvement Revenue focused They will take anyone with a heartbeat. Unorganized tryouts and practices. Coaches not showing up. Loudon?? not sure about this comment on other clubs. Full roster of paying customers, if this is a terrible thing. The girls teams seem to have better experiences. |
Is this a repost? I agree with some of the posts here. Also, I don't believe anyone here is struggling to make ends meet on travel, but $3K depends on its relativity. I wouldn't necessarily tell my kids that $3K is not a lot of money. |
Agreed you better in a lower team with any Nova club (Valor, GFR, Herndon, Loundon, Arlington ,etc) than with rec in 90% of the cases. Only exception (the 10%) are the better organized rec team with a good group of friends with a volunteer coach who understands the game but that is rare to find over a long period of time. |
What it really boils down to is if you're in the market for a club and don't really have high expectations to be on the top teams then shelling out a the extra $ can be acceptable to other parents. I certainly wouldn't say with confidence that the lower-level teams are treated with the same level of support or attention even though the ask ($$$) is the same. Now, if you know your kids a high-level performer, then you may be justified, but you need to be your own devil's advocate. For example: -Assessed properly or ID'd session at other outside clubs; #1 Pre-ECNL/Academy or #2 Team with equal divisions... -Is he/she killing each practice or technical drill ahead of his/her peers: hustling on the field, not just offensively, but more importantly defensively; are they just waiting for call to arrive; executing and making plays? Are they a one trick pony? Can they play every position? If the answer is yes... This should inform you on what direction you ought to take next. If you wait for any club to move up, that's just pure stupidity. In my experience, do not rely on any club to dictate your kid's progression or development. It can be very damaging at a young age. All in all, don't put your eggs in one basket. Shop around and look for better pastures. Believe it or not, they do exist. |
Mmmm...........reliable, not always the case. |
Just stop being combative for no reason. You and your kids have no skin in this game, obviously; get a life and let people spend their money and time how they want. |
Why is there 117 pages dedicated to Valor?
|
a lot of people seem to have had a bad experience at Valor. no other club has this many bad reviews, even much larger clubs like Loudon and Alexandria. |
FC Virginia has 146. Is it a contest? |
Well, that hit a nerve. Does Johnny need a time out? Must be Valor marketing at it again. You would like to have parents spend their money, wouldn't you? |