The flight attendant will gate check the bag not throw you off the plane |
You didn't specify that you were a new poster. You do know how this for site works, right? |
Please quote where it was said to buy bottles in the airport. When you can’t find it are you big enough to admit you were wrong? |
It’s all anonymous, you realize that don’t you? |
Which is why the convention is to specify when you're a new or different poster. |
I’ll admit I got that detail wrong by slightly misreading (embedding quote below)
I don’t think it changes the substance of my feedback/criticism |
You don’t make the rules here or on airplanes. |
That isn't what generally happens. Generally what happens is that the flight attendant apologizes, says they can't lift it, and someone kind hears and comes to help. Because it's only on DCUM that most people are a-holes. In real life they aren't. I sometimes travel with groups of people who can't lift their luggage. (e.g. leading trips for elderly or disabled people). We preboard, and I help people. I have never gotten to help everyone, because people realize what is going on and start helping. The thing that's important is that people who can't lift their luggage, for whatever reason, ask for preboarding. Because the process is much easier when the aisles aren't crowded. |
They. Can. Check. Their. Bags. |
This. I'm a small petite woman. I can lift my own bag. I've never had trouble with a man not offering to help me. I find it nice. I can imagine if you're older it would be difficult. I'm sure a flight attendant would help you if asked nicely. |
They can, but they aren't required to. Just like you could drive or not travel, but you aren't required to. They may have good reasons for wanting to keep their luggage close, just like other passengers. |
So you overreacted to the idea that pointed out some things can be purchased on the other side of security if needed and didn’t justify bringing an excessive amount of things in a carryon that was beyond the capabilities of the traveler? Also what if you need all of this excess at a time when turbulence is happening and you can’t get it? An under-seat bag of essentials makes more sense. |
My parents are older and no longer bring large bags on board. They have adjusted their travel realities to their current situation. |
As someone who once got caught for 12 hours on a layover, because my flight was delayed, with an infant who could only consume prescription formula, and who required both a nebulizer and a feeding pump, I was very glad I had extra diapers, formula, clean outfits, and a nebulizer in my carry on overhead. That doesn't mean that I didn't also have one outfit, a few diapers, and other things I might need during the flight in my personal item at my feet. It's not either or. |
I don’t think I overreacted, that is your judgement. And I have responded far more calmly than you have. Many posters have pointed out the importance of having a comprehensive bag if traveling with children (I was once stranded in nyc overnight without my luggage after missing a connection with two children under three and it was crucially important to have the basics). An airport is a terrible place to shop where everything is significantly more expensive and generally crappy quality, it’s an absurd suggestion. And would mean people were just walking with shopping bags instead of an organized suitcase. You clearly don’t understand the complexities of traveling with kids if you cannot understand this. Or you are so wealthy as to not understand most Americans at all. And generally this is not beyond the abilities of the traveler, just sometimes beyond the ability of one adult to manage at optimal efficiency. So others offer to help or they wait until the parents disabled person manages it. |