Governor Glenn Youngkin Calls for Attorney General Jason Miyares to Investigate the Leadership of Th

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So the Miyares investigation will also be looking at whether the change in admissions practices violates the Virginia Human Rights Act. The investigation is not limited to the non-disclosure or late disclosure to TJ students of their status as commended students.

I don't see how Bonitatibus survives this. She has become a liability for FCPS.


No. According to his press release, he is just looking into the slight delay of handing out paper certificates for something students would have already known.



Reading is fundamental.

"The investigation will examine if the administration’s decision to withhold National Merit Scholarship honors from students and the school’s new admissions policies violate the VHRA."

"My office will also investigate whether [TJ's] admissions policies violate the Virginia Human Rights Act."

https://www.oag.state.va.us/media-center/news-releases/2520-january-04-2023-attorney-general-miyares-launches-civil-rights-investigation-into-thomas-jefferson-high-school-for-science-and-technology

https://files.constantcontact.com/d3e83e11901/535c8d59-c909-4761-9e4d-4cd6dfbb9604.pdf?rdr=true
Anonymous
By the time an investigation is completed, whatever desired finding is reached, it goes to court, goes through trials, and appeals... we'll have a new attorney general. Even if he wins, FCPS can just withdraw from the school and be done with it
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My main question is why aren’t kids notified of these national merit awards electronically, given they are tied to test scores? Hand delivering a commendation award seems so outdated. And the colleges already have their test scores and know they are at the top!


Agree. It doesn't make sense why the College Board doesn't just electronically notify the kids directly.


They do.
When PSAT scores come out the year before on Collage Board, you can look up how to calculate the index score that National Merit Scholar derives to make the decisions. When the decision for what the index for 1% and 3% is decided on for all states, it is public ally published and has the info by state.
I guarantee every single parent in TJ knew exactly where there kid stood long before the certificates happened.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Northern Virginia High School Reportedly Withheld Test Scores from More Than 1,000 Students, Preventing College Scholarship Opportunities

RICHMOND, VA - Following recent news reports, Governor Glenn Youngkin today called for Virginia's Attorney General Jason Miyares to investigate allegations that information about National Merit Awards, as determined by student PSAT scores, was withheld from students at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology until after important deadlines for college scholarships had passed.

“We need to get to the bottom of what appears to be an egregious, deliberate attempt to disadvantage high-performing students at one of the best schools in the country,” said Governor Glenn Youngkin. “Parents and students deserve answers and Attorney General Miyares will initiate a full investigation. I believe this failure may have caused material harm to those students and their parents, and that this failure may have violated the Virginia Human Rights Act.”

https://www.governor.virginia.gov/newsroom/news-releases/2023/january/name-967965-en.html


Report says scholarship opportunities WERE prevented.

Please stop LYING about this fact.


A Youngkin press release is now a report. What scholarship would a student have qualified for if they had been notified two weeks earlier?

The investigation shall reveal all the details.


Commended students aren’t eligible for any National Merit scholarships. The only related scholarships they can apply for are called Special Scholarships with corporate sponsorship. (The first link goes through the procedure I’ve summarized below, the second has a list of sponsors and criteria on pages 9-10).

In many cases, corporations offer a specific number of grants to high school seniors of employees (sometimes also in a specific region or seniors with a particular major). In years when they can’t find enough finalists meeting their criteria, they will use non-finalists.

To qualify for a special scholarship, students have to complete an Entry Form with the sponsoring corporation as well as an application with the National Merit by mid-December. The National Merit program then compiles a specific list of students that qualify for each particular scholarship. Commended students have no priority over non-commended. If the scholarship goes to non-finalists, the award is not designated National Merit and recipients can’t call themselves National Merit Scholars.

Any student who didn’t apply or didn’t meet the specific criteria would not be considered. Any student whose parents worked for a company offering a corporate scholarship could have filled out an application at any time after getting their PSAT scores the year before. The delayed or even non-existent notification of Commended status is completely irrelevant and oh, by the way, came in long before the deadline for Special Scholarships.

No Commended student was denied the right to earn a scholarship because there are no scholarships for Commended students.


https://educationrealist.wordpress.com/


Wow, an anonymous blogger says otherwise, conveniently ignoring that there are over 800 other scholarship opportunities made available for students to apply to once they were recognized as Commended scholars and met that cutoff threshold.


Which has nothing to do with the school passing out a paper certificate. Straight from the horse's mouth:

Although Commended Students will not continue in the competition for National Merit Scholarships, some may be candidates for Special Scholarships offered by corporate sponsors (see pages 9–10). NMSC will notify those candidates in November 2023.


https://www.nationalmerit.org/s/1758/images/gid2/editor_documents/student_guide.pdf?gid=2&pgid=61


It has everything to do with the piece of paper. A student has to provide it when applying for the other 800 scholarship opportunities offered by the colleges and corporations.


No they don't, lol. No one provides pieces of paper to apply for anything anymore.


+1

The 800 scholarships are the corporate special scholarships. Those are open to any non-finalist, including semifinalists, commended, and non-commended. Applicants have to meet the specific criteria (children of employee, etc) to be considered. Students already had info on how to apply and knew their status. Deadline for scholarship applications was 12/15/22. More than a month after the certificates were handed out.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:So we will bring the exceptional down to the gutter level of those that can not or choose not to achieve?

Well, yes, that according to the progressives is equity. Well in the REAL world, as a general rule, the exceptional go on and do exceptionally well with great achievements and those that can not or choose not to, wave the 'race' card (Here I am using the left's definition of race, which I am guessing means any minority that feels victimhood) and demand money....lots of money, because they feel bad because others achieved when they didn't.

Well they had the chances and opportunities and either weren't smart enough or chose not to apply themselves (or to party hearty). This is NOT affirmative action, it is harmful, deceitful and just plain Wrong, and probably illegal.

I hope the lawsuits are directed at the individuals that perpetrated these heinous acts, and each of them is left destitute and jobless....they earned both.


What in the WORLD are you talking about? While some people are mad about TJ changing admission and working to make the school a more enjoyable supportive place to attend, the investigation and “wrong doing” here literally equate to someone forgetting to hand out on time certificates that many TJ students themselves say would not normally be included on a TJ kid’s college application due to typical TJ kids having other higher awards to list in limited space. And these awards are handed out each year to the kids - as they were this year once TJ realized the oversight. ALL “commended” kids at the school - not just Asian ones - were impacted the same by this delay of a few weeks in the normal process.

Your rant makes zero sense in the context of those facts.
Anonymous
Attorney General Miyares Launches Civil Rights Investigation into Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology

RICHMOND, VA – Attorney General Jason Miyares today announced that his Office of Civil Rights will be investigating Fairfax County Public Schools and the administration of Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology (“TJHSST”) for unlawful discrimination in violation of the Virginia Human Rights Act (“VHRA”).

The investigation will examine if the administration’s decision to withhold National Merit Scholarship honors from students and the school’s new admissions policies violate the VHRA.

“No student should be treated differently because of their race. Students at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology are amongst the brightest in the nation, yet some have been punished in the name of ‘equity.’ Racism and race-based government decision making in any form is wrong and unlawful under Virginia’s Human Rights Act,” said Attorney General Miyares. “The controversial admissions policies at TJHSST, which have significantly decreased the amount of Asian American students enrolled in recent years, is another example of students being treated differently because of their ethnicity. My Office of Civil Rights will investigate any potential violations of the law and vindicate the civil rights of these students and their families.”

Read the letter here.
Anonymous
So what if they find it has. Given that FCPS has won so far in the courts on this wouldn’t they win a legal challenge of the VA AG’s findings?

My kid is a freshman. I just hope this takes long enough to play out that the current approach of making TJ a more humane place to attend school survives while she is there. I doubt my younger will want to attend.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:By the time an investigation is completed, whatever desired finding is reached, it goes to court, goes through trials, and appeals... we'll have a new attorney general. Even if he wins, FCPS can just withdraw from the school and be done with it


Given what a total mess FCPS has made of TJ in recent years, and how much more attention it seems to get than the other 197 schools and centers in FCPS combined, ending TJ as a selective magnet may make the most sense. I'm sure the kids who have to cross both 395 and 495 to get to Edison now would benefit from having a school where that wasn't required, and it would give FCPS an opportunity to revisit the Annandale/Falls Church/Woodson/Lake Braddock boundaries as well.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:So what if they find it has. Given that FCPS has won so far in the courts on this wouldn’t they win a legal challenge of the VA AG’s findings?

My kid is a freshman. I just hope this takes long enough to play out that the current approach of making TJ a more humane place to attend school survives while she is there. I doubt my younger will want to attend.


A district court ruled AGAINST FCPS; that ruling is currently on appeal to the Fourth Circuit.

And a federal decision that the changes at TJ didn't violate the U.S. Constitution wouldn't preclude a finding that they violated a state statute, as they operate independently. States can confer rights not conferred under the Fourteenth Amendment.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Good. And yes I am a democrat. If this is true, it is beyond disgraceful. All this participation trophy bull is going to be our undoing.

+1


Who got a participation trophy under the circumstances? These kids already knew their test score, which is the sole criteria for a commendation. Nothing was withheld, it was simply a delay in hand delivering a a piece of paper, which is just a small formality. Nobody’s future was truly affected by this administrative snafu. Certainly no case for discrimination or human rights violations will succeed.

I predict this will be as successful as Youngkin’s teacher reporting email hotline.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Good. And yes I am a democrat. If this is true, it is beyond disgraceful. All this participation trophy bull is going to be our undoing.

+1


Who got a participation trophy under the circumstances? These kids already knew their test score, which is the sole criteria for a commendation. Nothing was withheld, it was simply a delay in hand delivering a a piece of paper, which is just a small formality. Nobody’s future was truly affected by this administrative snafu. Certainly no case for discrimination or human rights violations will succeed.

I predict this will be as successful as Youngkin’s teacher reporting email hotline.


Not to mention the Loudoun investigation, which was a complete bust
Anonymous
Hello FCPS Students, Families, and Community,

You may be aware that Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology (TJHSST) and Fairfax County Public Schools are now the subject of a Commonwealth of Virginia Attorney General investigation.

Last month, we were made aware that there had been a delay in sharing National Merit Scholarship Corporation recognition with TJHSST students designated as Commended Students by the National Merit Scholarship Corporation. After learning of this delay, impacted students and their families were notified, and staff sent emails and made follow-up calls to colleges where these students had applied to inform them of the National Merit Scholarship Corporation commendations.

Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS) has initiated an investigative review by an independent third party into the circumstances surrounding this situation. Our current understanding is that the delay at TJHSST this fall was a unique situation due to human error, but we will leave it to our investigative review to draw any final conclusions. We are committed to sharing any key findings and any updates to our processes to ensure future consistency in appropriate and timely notification of National Merit Scholarship Corporation recognitions going forward. In addition, the Virginia Attorney General investigation will include a review of the TJHSST admissions policies.

FCPS stands ready to work with our partners at the state level on both areas of investigation. I have already communicated this to the Office of the Attorney General for the Commonwealth of Virginia. 

We understand and value the hard work and dedication of each and every student, and the families and staff who support them. Please be assured that we remain resolutely committed to supporting every student in reaching their unique and fullest potential.

Sincerely,
 
Michelle Reid, Ed.D.
Superintendent
Fairfax County Public Schools
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My main question is why aren’t kids notified of these national merit awards electronically, given they are tied to test scores? Hand delivering a commendation award seems so outdated. And the colleges already have their test scores and know they are at the top!


Agree. It doesn't make sense why the College Board doesn't just electronically notify the kids directly.


They do.
When PSAT scores come out the year before on Collage Board, you can look up how to calculate the index score that National Merit Scholar derives to make the decisions. When the decision for what the index for 1% and 3% is decided on for all states, it is public ally published and has the info by state.
I guarantee every single parent in TJ knew exactly where there kid stood long before the certificates happened.


Asra 100% knew that her child was not in the NMSF camp, but was instead in Commended.

I cannot believe that so many on the right are falling for this package of lies.
Anonymous
The AG is clueless. Youngkin is scraping some brownie points.

This will pass, like other attempts to tarnish the efforts to enhance the TJ experience..
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Give Youngkin a gold star for having the guts to take on the education establishment..

I've been writing for years that "diversity" and "racial equity" are merely euphemisms for reverse discrimination. Denying or disparaging the achievements of others is no way to address the racial imbalance in academic performance.

Offering remedial courses for underachievers is a better idea, but liberals reject that solution because many underachievers have no interest in remedial courses or in genuine learning-- that want distinction as a matter of "right" rather than merit, like participation trophies in children's sports. But education is not a game -- and life awards no participation trophies.



What racial discrimination exists at TJ?


discrimination against high-performing Asian students


You mean the group with the highest representation at the school?


There are more women than men in this world. By your logic, women cannot be discriminated against?

You are probably ok with colonialism as well. How could the majority in these countries be victims? Look at their numbers?
Forum Index » Advanced Academic Programs (AAP)
Go to: