It's exactly the issue. PP said 9-10 is too young. How old is not "too young"? |
Actually, it was 9 or 10. |
What does that have to do with this book? There are lots of great books to have in a school library. That's not one of them. |
I don’t know the book and I don’t really care. It’s a book. |
Then don’t read it. |
Would be better to have higher standards than this. |
| Ironic that SB censored the woman's testimony on the video--yet, young children are free to check the books out and read them. |
|
I think you all are acting like the school board here, focusing on the wrong damn things. Your kids are going to face serious challenges in the future - climate change, civil unrest, possible economic devastation, an ongoing pandemic. Let the books and the school names and the other trivial stuff go. These kids wil need to be smarter and stronger and more capable than previous generations, and right now, administrators who care more about covering their asses or advancing their careers than actually educating children are instituting policies that ensure they will be lazier, dumber, and weaker.
It’s a book. Let it go. If the harshest reality your kid ever has to face is the mere *idea* or *portrayal* of gay sex or pedophilia, then he or she will have a pretty ideal life. I don’t need to be a fortune teller to predict that more harsh realities are in their futures. Don’t get derailed from what needs to be done by this sideshow. |
And that was the case for many other kids exploring their bodies. Totally normal. This character remembered something similar and reflected on it, looking back with an adult’s perspective. |
Tell me you don’t know what ironic means without telling me you don’t know what ironic means. |
It’s relevant because people were saying it’s too young for kids to experiment with sex. Why do you think this book isn’t great? |
She wasn’t censored. She wouldn’t stop when her time was up. And “young children” don’t go to high school. |
Three errors in your response. 1. The video of the SB meeting has censored her testimony. It says that it has been edited because of "sexually explicit language." 2. Her testimony was interrupted before her time was up. 3. These books are available to 12 year olds in FCPS libraries. |
Books are not trivial when we are discussing education. What a strange thing to say. Since the book is not a big deal it should be no problem for the school board to remove it. They shouldn't let something so insignificant distract the populace. |
But we censor To Kill a Mockingbird? |