John is a New Testament name. If you name your son John, just call him John. For Jews, Jack is a first proper first name. In fact, it is for non-Jews too. It's hit the "proper" name status. Deal with it. Signed, a mom who did not name her son John or Jack. |
Not the PP, but I disagree with you. Jack is a nickname and is stupid as a real name. As are all nickname names. Name your kid something real and then call them by the nickname, if you wish. Signed, someone who has a nephew named just "Jack." |
The demographics of the site probably have a lot to do with that. |
No, I don't think so. |
Those names are not common in my community, so they really don't even enter my mind when I am thinking about names. The names I mentioned hating (I'm the poster who listed all the versions of Kaylee, Carleigh, Kylie, etc.) I see multiple times in my kids classes---this past year my first grader had a Caileigh, Kaya, and a Kayla in his class. |
NP. This is so stupid. What makes Jack any less of a real name than John. They're both one syllable, four letters and start with "J". Who cares?? And no, I don't have a child named Jack or any other nickname name. |
| Feeonah. |
Spelled this way? Yikes, I dislike this too. Now, Fiona is fine. |
What makes Jack less of a real name than John is the fact that, traditionally, Jack is a NICKNAME for John! What makes a name or not is not the # of syllables or letters! Duh! But if it is on your world, so be it! Carry on! |
|
Madison
Addison Kaylee Haylee Brooke Landon Grayson Brendan Cayden Jayden Most of these seem to be children of people who were mean girls in high school and want their children to be "popular." |
| Gertrude |
Are you over 50? What you say may have been true years ago but certainly not today. Even proper old England has embraced nickname names. Take a look at their equivalent to the SSA list sometime. It's pretty eye-opening. |
If you think all of England is proper and does not have its share of bumbling idiots, you must never have traveled or lived there. I would no more follow their example than the man on the moon. |
Yes! I totally agree with this! |
|
Porter
Cooper |