stay away from Farm raised salmon, esp. Norwegian

[Anonymous]

What about canned salmon for dogs, as in Purina or whatever? Doesn't say where they get it. Plus, they get fish oil, too.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

I bet you have great skin and hair

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

OP here. I do not think you are being realistic at all. This is not about measurable outcome in any given moment. This is about the sheer concentrations in this specific food being astronomically worse than wild fish, smaller wild caught fish AND beef or chicken.

Im not sharing a "thought" for you to appreciate. This is merely to inform you that wild caught and farm raised salmon are radically different in ways that are readily measured, and have been. If you want to eat a very toxic food because thats what is realistic for you, I get it. But just understand that you are talking about realistic in a general sense- its about your choice.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:With wild caught you really need to be concerned with micro plastics. There’s no good answer.

OP here, true that is another problem. But doxins and certain other chemicals build up in human tissue in specific ways that are bad. The good answer is probably to just eat any of this very rarely if at all?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

I'm curious how you doing a possibly destructive and very unhealthy behavior is in any way an own on OP.

It would be like someone posting an article about smoking causing cancer and someone posting, "I appreciate the thought OP but I smoke a pack of cigarettes every day." Okay? You deciding to perpetuate unhealthy behavior is a reflection on you, not OP or the facts she presented.

[Anonymous]

Also, to the same PP, you should seriously, and I mean SERIOUSLY, lay off that canned tuna unless you want to get mercury poisoning. Toxic heavy metals are no joke

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

I'm curious how you doing a possibly destructive and very unhealthy behavior is in any way an own on OP.

It would be like someone posting an article about smoking causing cancer and someone posting, "I appreciate the thought OP but I smoke a pack of cigarettes every day." Okay? You deciding to perpetuate unhealthy behavior is a reflection on you, not OP or the facts she presented.

OP here. Thats for chiming in.....I think the poster you referenced is not so much making this about me as much as reflecting the general fatigue probably so many of us feel at finding out yet another thing we enjoy is bad for us.

But this is really much more than that. This is the equivelant of finding out the cigarette industry manipulated nictotine levels and hid the facts their own scientists knew about specific damage from their additives. We all know smoking is bad, but the how and the WHY is far more relevant because it reflects that we cannot trust industry, period.

In particular the food industry has loopholes that allow things to happen that should not. The toxin present in the feed for farmed fish is not supposed to be in the feed of ANY animal.

As a breast cancer survivor, I took note of the portion where they were advising women to NOT EAT SALMON to reduce their breast cancer recurrence risk because basically the old omega 3's in salmon that used to be good for us all are far eclipsed by the damage done to us from the other things.

Fish farming practices globally are BAD NEWS but where you find big money like in big fish such as salmon, its far worse than you know.

WATCH THE DOC,

[Anonymous]

I wonder if this applies to fish oil too. My guess would be it does.

[Anonymous]

Hey all! This is why vegetarian is the way to go. Veering vegan. Grow your own, to the extent possible (greens, microgreens).

[Anonymous]

What am I missing - last I checked most farm raised salmon around here (I assume Op is posting from DC area) is Atlantic farm raised. I dont think I've ever really seen Norwegian farm raised here - why would we with the Atlantic a pebble's throw away?

FWIW, dh buys one if those 2lbers of farm raised salmon each week from Costco and eats it throughout the week.

The tradeoff it has helped tremendously with his diet and RA.

Plus, I find there are fear mongering stories with just about every food out there.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

Whoa... aren’t you worried about mercury??

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:With wild caught you really need to be concerned with micro plastics. There’s no good answer.

OP here, true that is another problem. But doxins and certain other chemicals build up in human tissue in specific ways that are bad. The good answer is probably to just eat any of this very rarely if at all?

Aren't most farm-raised fish netted off in the ocean/sea? In other words, I don't think they'd have less microplastic exposure. Also, farmed fish are eating wild caught fish.

[Anonymous]

I think it's okay to eat some fish, like trout and maybe cod.

Probably the best option is grass fed meat.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I appreciate the thought OP but I eat salmon at least 2-3 times a week and I don't really distinguish between farm-raised or wild-caught. I buy what looks good that day when I'm at the store. I also eat canned tuna practically every day for lunch. I'll keep you posted about how it all works out...fingers crossed for a good outcome! I'm not being snarky, just realistic.

I'm curious how you doing a possibly destructive and very unhealthy behavior is in any way an own on OP.

It would be like someone posting an article about smoking causing cancer and someone posting, "I appreciate the thought OP but I smoke a pack of cigarettes every day." Okay? You deciding to perpetuate unhealthy behavior is a reflection on you, not OP or the facts she presented.

NP +1

What you just said, PP, without realizing it, is "I appreciate the thought, OP, but I'll just keep poisoning myself and my family."

These chemicals also pass into the placenta and breastmilk.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:With wild caught you really need to be concerned with micro plastics. There’s no good answer.

OP here, true that is another problem. But doxins and certain other chemicals build up in human tissue in specific ways that are bad. The good answer is probably to just eat any of this very rarely if at all?

Aren't most farm-raised fish netted off in the ocean/sea? In other words, I don't think they'd have less microplastic exposure. Also, farmed fish are eating wild caught fish.

You obviously didn't even watch the video.