Not everyone is shooting for the moon here! Union is a great opportunity for good kids |
+1, but even Grinnell is also heavily lotteried, esp students targeting CS + Stats / Data Science |
Yes, with great salaries and research opportunities for people with PhDs.. |
| Denison |
Pomona has a lottery system (which btw, I’ve heard noise of it dropping soon due to professor hiring, any news?) to randomly select students who can become CS majors. This was after more than 20% of one of their classes declared CS majors. |
They’ve hired a tenure track professor and have been searching for an open rank and visiting professor. The issue for Pomona is it’s in California and only can pay $100k for assistant profs, which is much lower than industry pay for a PhD in CS. |
|
Very useful thread, really helpful.
What I gather so far on some the best/nice are: College / challenge or issue Pomona - heavily lotteried Swarthmore - heavily lotteried Grinnell - middle of nowhere / internship issues / lotterried Harvey Mudd - very competitive / low acceptance rate |
Carleton and Swarthmore are great options. They both are repeat regional finalists in ICPC competitions, both place well into CS PhD programs, and both have strong writing/humanities programs. |
+1 Most CS PhDs end up industry and use their training for innovative R&D. Those who think PhDs are only for academia are poorly informed. |
| Hamilton |
|
Harvey Mudd
WPI Lafayette St. Olaf Union Smith Swarthmore |
There’s no incentive to getting a PhD in CS- that’s a massive cut to your salary for not much pay increase with a detrimental time sink. This indicates that swarthmore cs grads aren’t learning enough to get jobs in industry. Swarthmore also has a long lottery with waitlist and caps for your course load- that’s not worth the cost. You know whose also great at the ICPC competitions, better than swarthmore? UCSD. Competitions don’t mean anything of substance- Princeton hardly gets any Putnam placements, and it’s the best math program in the world. |
+1, getting a PhD in cs is silly. Worth it only for the top 0.1% who’ll go into quant finance. |
Midd actually places decently into the FAANGs. A Midd CS grad is an engineering/product VP at Google as well. |
CS PhD is 400k plus right out of school at Meta. |