Girls name feedback (our list)

[Anonymous]

I also like Callie best (but not Calliope).

[Anonymous]

Rhiannon - like it don’t love it

Daisy (maybe on its own, maybe as nickname for Margaret) - LOVE Margaret nn Daisy, don’t love Daisy as a standalone name; what if she’s not a cutesy type person?

Maxine - dislike this; it feels old to me although I have no idea why

Molly - I like this; classic and cute

Virginia, nn Ginny - like it, don’t love it

Daphne - like it, although not my personal style

Thea, maybe Theodora as a full name - I like Theodora better than Thea which feel like it lacks an solid consonants at all

Calliope, nn Callie - I wouldn’t go with something like Calliope unless my family were Greek but I do think Callie is adorable

Miranda (no nickname, and we actively dislike Randy as a nn so nervous about this one though we really like it) - I love Miranda and don’t know anyone with the name who goes by anything but the whole thing

Michaela - has a very 80s/90s vibe to me


M names that might be worth considering: Marianne, Matilda, Mary, Magdalena-nn-Maggie (but only if you’re Christian and reasonably religious ), Maisie, Madeline

[Anonymous]

Molly, Daphne, and Callie are the best.

Callie is somewhat common. And yes, Molly is often a dog's name.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This is a rough list of names we've come up with that neither person has vetoed. It's kind of all over the map. Would like feedback (associations, like/dislike, etc.) just to get a sense of how these names might be received. We don't want to tell friends or family about names we're considering because we made that mistake last time and people were really annoying about it. So trying to use DCUM to get that same kind of feedback, but from strangers instead of my mom or our friends, who were sometimes hypercritical or kept trying to push certain names/nicknames on us and just pestered us too much. TIA!

The list:

Rhiannon NO
Daisy YES (maybe on its own, maybe as nickname for Margaret) I love Margaret but have never heard of Daisy as a nn. Why not just name your kid Daisy? Also, be prepared for your child to hate their nickname and want to be called their full name.
Maxine NO
Molly NO
Virginia, nn Ginny YES (love Virginia but dislike Ginny as a nickname; may be confusing since you are presumably located in or near Virginia the state)
Daphne MEH (like it but it does sound like you are trying too hard)
Thea, maybe Theodora as a full name NO
Calliope, nn Callie NO
Miranda (no nickname, and we actively dislike Randy as a nn so nervous about this one though we really like it) NO
Michaela MEH (many spelling and many pronunciations, feels very "in" right now - and not in a good way)

Also open to suggestions. Only parameters are: no names that start with a vowel, the first initial "M" would be nice but we aren't restricting ourselves to that. Also open to middle name suggestions because we have absolutely no idea!

Confused at why if you like names with the first initial M your list is full of names that start with letters other than M.

[Anonymous]

I do not understand the Daisy trend. At all. I fully hate this name.

Molly is my favorite by far. Would’ve used it for our daughter but sounded bad with our last name

[Anonymous]

Names that sort of go with your list:

Isadora (nn Izzy)
Delilah
Morgan
Meredith
Megan

[Anonymous]

Margaret is a classic. Can't go wrong with this name.

[Anonymous]

Love love Ginny

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is a rough list of names we've come up with that neither person has vetoed. It's kind of all over the map. Would like feedback (associations, like/dislike, etc.) just to get a sense of how these names might be received. We don't want to tell friends or family about names we're considering because we made that mistake last time and people were really annoying about it. So trying to use DCUM to get that same kind of feedback, but from strangers instead of my mom or our friends, who were sometimes hypercritical or kept trying to push certain names/nicknames on us and just pestered us too much. TIA!

The list:

Rhiannon NO
Daisy YES (maybe on its own, maybe as nickname for Margaret) I love Margaret but have never heard of Daisy as a nn. Why not just name your kid Daisy? Also, be prepared for your child to hate their nickname and want to be called their full name.
Maxine NO
Molly NO
Virginia, nn Ginny YES (love Virginia but dislike Ginny as a nickname; may be confusing since you are presumably located in or near Virginia the state)
Daphne MEH (like it but it does sound like you are trying too hard)
Thea, maybe Theodora as a full name NO
Calliope, nn Callie NO
Miranda (no nickname, and we actively dislike Randy as a nn so nervous about this one though we really like it) NO
Michaela MEH (many spelling and many pronunciations, feels very "in" right now - and not in a good way)

Also open to suggestions. Only parameters are: no names that start with a vowel, the first initial "M" would be nice but we aren't restricting ourselves to that. Also open to middle name suggestions because we have absolutely no idea!

Confused at why if you like names with the first initial M your list is full of names that start with letters other than M.

“the first initial "M" would be nice but we aren't restricting ourselves to that.”

[Anonymous]

Have you considered Meredith?

[Anonymous]

Here are my thoughts:
Rhiannon - like this
Daisy (maybe on its own, maybe as nickname for Margaret) - like as a NN for Margaret
Maxine - not crazy about this one
Molly - like this
Virginia, nn Ginny - don't like how closely it's tied to the word "virgin"
Daphne - like this
Thea, maybe Theodora as a full name - like, esp as a nn fo Theodora
Calliope, nn Callie - like this
Miranda (no nickname, and we actively dislike Randy as a nn so nervous about this one though we really like it) - like this
Michaela - like the sound of this but it's one of those names I think needs a break after being used so heavily for awhile

Other ideas:
Marianne, Matilda, Melody, Marissa, Alethia, Calista

[Anonymous]

I like Margaret (but not Daisy), Molly, Daphne, and Miranda.

Agree with PP on Matilda.

[Anonymous]

Rhiannon - just no.
Daisy (maybe on its own, maybe as nickname for Margaret) - too cutesy past the age of about 10 and Margaret is too ugly
Maxine - too ugly
Molly - yes, great name. note that many people will say "I have/had a dog named Molly!" happily, but that wouldn't bother me
Virginia, nn Ginny - not if you live in Virginia
Daphne - eh okay
Thea, maybe Theodora as a full name - just no
Calliope, nn Callie - everyone will ask if you liked Callie on Grey's Anatomy
Miranda (no nickname, and we actively dislike Randy as a nn so nervous about this one though we really like it) - ugly
Michaela - eh okay

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Margaret is a classic. Can't go wrong with this name.

A lot of things that are classic are ugly.

[Anonymous]

When I see Rhiannon I think of Rhiannon Giddens, so I kind of like it.
I don't like Maxine or Calliope, but the other names are fine. My favorite is Thea.