speed or technical ability? Age 11.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My kid can't juggle LOL but made huge club 2nd team - out of more than 5. For real. They have lots of speed and pretty good tech ability, aggressive. But no can do on the juggle I say DC has to be the only kid on a high team who can't juggle. I've always wondered exactly how important it is to juggle? That doesn't mean kid can't handle the ball pretty in real time like a throw ins, just that kid doesn't like to juggle as a technical exercise.

oxymoron

Juggling shows balance, touch, control, patience and the discipline to put in work (that's what it tells real coaches)
Impossible that a kid can have touch and control under pressure in game but can't juggle a ball unopposed. Impossible

Here's something you never see at a high level academy. A kid who can't juggle
Here's something you never see on a professional or semi-pro team. A player who can't juggle

Do you have to be able to juggle to a thousand? No
Do you have to be able to control a ball using different parts of your body to be above a recreational level player (regardless of what you call yourself). Yes

You don't have to have juggle to have great first touch.

If you can't juggle or use a rebounder without letting the ball drop constantly, you can't have great first touch with anything not already on the ground.
To say otherwise is ludicrous and showing lack of knowledge on the sport

which parts of your body are you using during the game differently than what it takes to juggle?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sadly, most clubs including academy will go with the super fast kid that is tall (or just tall) that along with tons of politics. Super sucky!

There's a reason the stands have thousands of seats and TV rights are worth millions

Everyone can't be on the field

Right, I doubt you even watch soccer to even understand what I am saying. Keep lobbying

Marco Verratti is 5ft 5in
If your kid is small, it isn't the only reason he/she isn't getting selected. It is probably one of the reasons.

Little Ballers get selected and play.

No one said they are selected. But if you pay attention, taller kids get more attention. Is the US way. Terrible, but factual.

Verrati? You could of use examples in the US? Of course you have the Iniestas, Xavi, etc. It happened that way for them and other in those countries, becuase real soccer skills are the focus. Not size.

Cavan Sullivan is 5ft 7in

happy now?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Its more like if you put the time in to juggling the ball becomes easier to manipulate when it its in the air, or coming at you with swerve, pace or whatever game situation soccer puts you in. When everything is moving faster around, and space is a commodity its an advantage to do first touch ball flicks into space, or bring a ball out of the air in one touch so your second touch you can create seperation. This can best be learned with hours of juggling, but more advanced stuff like wall juggling really helps and is more obvious too see the game like scenarios; but you got to put the time in with boring old juggling first with both feet, then one foot, and then alternating between thighs, chests shoulders, and head all can be used to control the ball so you got to practice with the whole body. There is little to no practice time set aside for this so hence juggling should be your friend, and not like making the bed or unloading the dishwaser. Beauty of it is, if you put in 10 mins every day, your kid will be a better and more confident soccer player after 60days guranteed

Better yes; more confident, not necessarily. Because coaches are still likely to overlook the technical player in favor of the big ones who can kick the ball far, which does a number on confidence.

Are we talking about soccer players or American football field goal kickers. LOL

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My kid can't juggle LOL but made huge club 2nd team - out of more than 5. For real. They have lots of speed and pretty good tech ability, aggressive. But no can do on the juggle I say DC has to be the only kid on a high team who can't juggle. I've always wondered exactly how important it is to juggle? That doesn't mean kid can't handle the ball pretty in real time like a throw ins, just that kid doesn't like to juggle as a technical exercise.

oxymoron

Juggling shows balance, touch, control, patience and the discipline to put in work (that's what it tells real coaches)
Impossible that a kid can have touch and control under pressure in game but can't juggle a ball unopposed. Impossible

Here's something you never see at a high level academy. A kid who can't juggle
Here's something you never see on a professional or semi-pro team. A player who can't juggle

Do you have to be able to juggle to a thousand? No
Do you have to be able to control a ball using different parts of your body to be above a recreational level player (regardless of what you call yourself). Yes

You don't have to have juggle to have great first touch.

LOL. This means that this player can only control passes that are rolling on the ground.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sadly, most clubs including academy will go with the super fast kid that is tall (or just tall) that along with tons of politics. Super sucky!

There's a reason the stands have thousands of seats and TV rights are worth millions

Everyone can't be on the field

Right, I doubt you even watch soccer to even understand what I am saying. Keep lobbying

Marco Verratti is 5ft 5in
If your kid is small, it isn't the only reason he/she isn't getting selected. It is probably one of the reasons.

Little Ballers get selected and play.

No one said they are selected. But if you pay attention, taller kids get more attention. Is the US way. Terrible, but factual.

Verrati? You could of use examples in the US? Of course you have the Iniestas, Xavi, etc. It happened that way for them and other in those countries, becuase real soccer skills are the focus. Not size.

Cavan Sullivan is 5ft 7in

happy now?

Please keep your kids and yourself in American sports.

[Anonymous]

Cavan Sullivan in the same conversation with those players is unfair to a 14 year old

#RememberFreddyAdu

[Anonymous]

OMG. Parents with lead-footed DCs are justifying size/speed over technical skills, speed of play and IQ. Unbelievable.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:OMG. Parents with lead-footed DCs are justifying size/speed over technical skills, speed of play and IQ. Unbelievable.

Thanks, I am with you!

[Anonymous]

Everyone knows that all of the BEST soccer players in the WORLD are all the big, fast, strong "athletic" type of players - not skillful technical players with high soccer IQ.

Raw physicality FTW

This is why we will always be the best in the world!

USA! USA! USA!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Everyone knows that all of the BEST soccer players in the WORLD are all the big, fast, strong "athletic" type of players - not skillful technical players with high soccer IQ.

Raw physicality FTW

This is why we will always be the best in the world!

USA! USA! USA!

But but if only this fill in the blank nfl linebacker wanted to play soccer we would dominate everyone.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Everyone knows that all of the BEST soccer players in the WORLD are all the big, fast, strong "athletic" type of players - not skillful technical players with high soccer IQ.

If we're talking about he best soccer players in the world, they are BOTH (skilled and athletic).

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Everyone knows that all of the BEST soccer players in the WORLD are all the big, fast, strong "athletic" type of players - not skillful technical players with high soccer IQ.

Raw physicality FTW

This is why we will always be the best in the world!

USA! USA! USA!

The best soccer players in the world are big fast strong athletic players with technical skills and high soccer IQ. It's not either or.

But that's not the question that was asked. The question that was asked is about 11 year olds.

If you don't have a big strong fast kid with excellent skills, so you have to choose between these three 11 year olds

Kid A: Big strong fast athletic and new to soccer so limited technical skills or soccer IQ

Kid B: Big strong fast athletic and has been playing awhile but skills are still limited

Kid C: Smaller, weaker kid with strong technical skills

Which one do you pick?

I'd say that Kid A is the one most likely to make varsity and eventually play in college if someone believes him in.

But Kid C might be the one that helps you win this year in U12.

So, it depends on coach's priorities.

[Anonymous]

Again, this confirms the 2018 Ballon D’Or winner and one of the baddest ballers of all time (hint it’s not Messi) would not make it the US under this criteria.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Again, this confirms the 2018 Ballon D’Or winner and one of the baddest ballers of all time (hint it’s not Messi) would not make it the US under this criteria.

My favorite player! The Croatian wizard.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Again, this confirms the 2018 Ballon D’Or winner and one of the baddest ballers of all time (hint it’s not Messi) would not make it the US under this criteria.

My favorite player! The Croatian wizard.

Except that Modric and Messi are both fast and athletic on top of having brilliant skills, same as with every single player in all the top leagues in the world. Even OP’s extremely overly simplistic question doesn’t ask about a kid’s height.