Down with success. |
LOL |
These days, you get more "public support" if you are trans, queer or some minority group than if you are motivated passionate student. |
That's what the pro-privilege parents like to tell themselves. |
I know Gates went to a very elite private school before attending Harvard. |
If by success, you mean the privilege that wealth affords the wealthy then sure. |
Members of every one of the former groups that you mentioned are literally murdered every day for no reason other than their identification in those groups. Motivated passionate students are having difficulty maintaining exclusive access to elite academic spaces because schools are finally accounting for the fact that there are other ways to find motivated passionate students. These two problems are not in the same universe. |
You'll never be a success if you drop out of school. |
You are serious about "privilege" how about dropping preference for children of alumni at universities? That goes a long way in increasing the capacity that is available to others. How about actually helping minorities and economically disadvantaged from pre-k and in FCPS from k onwards with extra additional support. Special after school programs, additional hours, tutors, etc. right from k. Actively put money towards education of these children, who deserve this kind of support at an early age which builds a solid foundation. But no, what you want is really signal your woke status and pretend to help. Getting 50 kids to TJ from these groups would allow you to signal your own moral superiority. All the tens of thousands of other kids from these groups who need help are ignored. There is no story there. My child and I help coach kids at an elementary school in math from 3rd grade and many kids show a big improvement and lose fear of math. Many are economically disadvantaged. Some actively love math competitions. It is very little effort on our part actually. FCPS could scale this 1000x with a little investment. But no this is too low level and not much woke signaling is possible here. So they would rather focus on getting a few more kids to TJ to signal their wokeness. |
Not "some" minority group -the "privileged" minority group. |
The vast majority of people who believe in the recent TJ reforms would be THRILLED to see alumni preferences go away at universities. They won't because of donor relation concerns, but we would certainly love it if they did. The bottom line is that academic institutions can and should be able to admit who they want to based on what's in the best interest of the school, its educational environment, and its students. There's no universe in which admitting an entire class of students along the same evaluation axis creates a positive academic environment. And that is why you need subjectivity in an admissions process. |
I believe in the reforms and also feel the alumni preference is also complete BS. |
I'm pro TJ reform but also believe the alumni preference is also a problem. I'd like to see more equitable admissions everywhere. |
+1. South Asian mom here. Totally agree. I would add, create opportunities for developing friendship with driven kids (with committed parents). Once your kids are in 8th grade their peer group keeps them motivated. Then you just want to watch them and make sure they are not taking on too much. I remember my kids enthusiastically started piano when they were 6. Around 8-9 it was a big task reminding them to practice every day for 20 mins. Now in 8th grade, my son practices 30-45 mins every day with very little reminders. He just got comfortable working very hard. Take on most advanced classes, but pick one class in middle school which is fun and may not attract the most competitive kids- Theatre for my kid was a stress buster after all the academic classes. |
Good points. grunt work isn't woke/cool. |