Nice try but not buying it |
|
Is living in public housing and reciving certain means tested welfare benefits counted in assessing a child’s SEN status.
Surely you can verify if a kids family is receiving SNAP and that’s a more concrete indicator of poverty than receiving free school meals which rich kids can get too. |
This is entirely logical and a great idea. However, it’s not what the TJ admissions office is using. They are using ONLY the meals questions for the economically disadvantaged experience factor. If you do not believe me, please call or email them yourself. Or ask your school board member to ask them for you. |
There are TWO questions: Are you eligible for free meals? Did you receive free meals? So the first question can be gamed by parents because of pandemic free meals. But the second? That would require outright lying. |
And some are doing it for political gain. |
|
What motivates the TJAAG is their fear that their TJ degrees will be worth less in certain circles if their alma mater is looked on less favorably because it doesn’t have enough Black and Hispanic students.
The TJAAG tries to portray itself as altruistic, but they are reactive and self-centered. |
The trouble with conservatives is that their world view is so deeply skewed that they can’t even CONCEIVE of a person or group doing something that is the right thing to do even if it harms themselves. Thus they have to engage in tortured logic to somehow reverse-justify the beliefs of their enemies. |
Bingo. |
Therefore diversity based on race is racist and counterproductive. |
Yes I demand we have more short people, like me, in TJ. What is their percentage of short students?! Can we get some equity please. |
Harming themselves..how? Self serving self righteousness is all I can see from the results you have achieved. Whites 26% up, Asians 26% down. In the first place,you lump a very diverse group of people that represent almost 50% of the world's population over 3.5billion.people if you just include China, India, Pakistan, Middle East, Bangladesh, Korea, Vietnam, Japan...Just India and China themselves have kids speaking second languages like Mandarin, Cantonese, Tamil, Hindi, Urdu. Telugu and many others.. TJ's so called Asian students have different racial backgrounds, national origins, languages, immigration status, income levels. Yet you insist on dehumanizing them by seeing them as a monolith. All this to serve your own purposes. Look in a mirror and think how you are actually helping. Bringing your politics to schools for your selfishness is just ugly, evil and ignorant. |
So, at 54% of the class, Asians are well represented. |
There's no such thing as "well represented." The appropriate representation in a gifted and talented program is the percentage of people that are gifted and talented. If those people happen to be asian, then so be it |
Sure if by gain you mean ensuring these programs are open to all their constituents not just the wealthy who are inclined to spend large sums on prep sure. |
Any school with over 50% of one group is hardly diverse. |