Forum Index
»
Political Discussion
You maybe mean well but this is 100% the attitude of pedophiles. I know both personally because my family has a few and because I work with kids many of whom have been abused. The "it's the parents job!" line is one of heard from basically even child molester I knew growing up. When you drive sex education or of schools you empower them. |
Totally agree. Nor is it up to the school to tell children that they are able to "choose" their gender based on how they "feel." |
They are explaining what is happening in the world around them. Even if you don’t understand them, transgender people exist. That’s a fact. There is nothing controversial to inform kids about this fact in an age-appropriate way. |
Telling a six year old they can change their gender is not age-appropriate. |
Do you have a reading comprehension problem? Every bolded statement refers to sex ed that has nothing to do with trans people. I'm responding to that. |
Sex education is not appropriate in the primary grades. Ever. These are discussions left for home. |
Transgender people make up less than to, by generous estimates, 1% of the population. The country with the highest population that identifies as transgender is Sweden, and they come in at about 3%. There is no "this is what is happening in their world around them" argument to this and therefore no need to inform 6 year old kids about about transgenders in any way unless a parent wants to tell their kid because of a particular instance in their individual life. There is nothing controversial whatsoever about NOT informing the kids about the 1 or so percent of the population that this affects. |
yes. It can wait until middle school unless there is a transgender person in their family or in their particular classroom. Flexibility on the part of the teachers should be allowed. |
How is that worded? Example? |
I’m from NJ and know several transgender people of all ages. It’s all over the news and social media. There are probably transgender kids at their school. It’s absolutely happening in the world around them. And kids aren’t dumb. |
They can certainly learn basic anatomy in elementary.
|
again you are gaslighting. Look at the OPs post. Nobody is upset about learning basic anatomy. Why obfuscate the conversation? What is your purpose in doing that? |
Do you really think these kids are all transgender? You answered that yourself - it is all over the news and social media. Kids are told if they are a girl and like boy things, or if they are a boy and like girl things, they are gender fluid, transgender, don't need to identify as a boy or a girl, nonbinary, etc. Of course they say they are transgender - because they have been conditioned to say so. 80 to 94% of kids will identify as their birth gender if left alone because we know that true transgenders are an extremely small percentage of the population. Instead of telling these kids they are trans, how about we let them sort out exactly what they are feeling and how those feelings evolve over time and through puberty and young adulthood? Is that too much to ask? |
I hope yuo dont live in DC. Thaty could be considered hate speech. |
Here is an example of a book recommended for K-2. No it is not appropriate. Because a girl wants to wear swim trunks like her dad and brother does not make her a boy truly in her heart. I was a real tomboy and thought all the boys stuff was way cooler than the girls stuff. Did everything with my dad outdoors and no cooking or sewing with my mom. Does that mean I am truly a boy in my heart? At 4 or 5, I thought I was a horse . Put noise makers on my hands and knees to clop around on the wood floors and made my younger brother ride on my back. Am I a horse? A 6 yo and even a teen does not understand phases in life, just how they feel at the moment. It is not appropriate to take a phase and tell a kid that they are born in the wrong body. It is harmful. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CAEkSkkIyU |